John Marston is a bit of a mess. Honestly, when we first see him in John Red Dead Redemption 2, he’s literally being eaten by wolves on a snowy mountain ledge. He’s not the legendary gunslinger we remember from the first game. Not yet. He’s a deadbeat dad, a mediocre outlaw, and kind of an idiot. But that’s exactly why his presence in Rockstar Games' 2018 prequel is so damn effective.
Most people went into the game expecting to see the origin of the "Hero of the West." Instead, we got a slow-burn character study about a man who doesn't even want to be there. He's grumpy. He's immature. He treats Jack and Abigail with a coldness that makes players—who spent eighty hours loving them in the original 2010 title—genuinely frustrated. This isn't fanservice; it's a gritty, uncomfortable look at how a boy becomes a man through the most painful lessons imaginable.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Hellhound Call of Duty Fans Love to Hate is Actually a Masterclass in Game Design
The Problem with John Marston in the Prequel
Early on, John Red Dead Redemption 2 portrays him as a foil to Arthur Morgan. While Arthur is the loyal, capable enforcer, John is the guy who constantly needs saving. Think back to the mission "Enter, Pursued by a Memory." Javier Escuella and Arthur have to drag John's bloody carcass off a mountain because he couldn't handle a few wolves. It's a humbling start for a character who eventually takes down entire army outposts.
The game is smart about this. It uses Arthur’s perspective to criticize John. Arthur's journal entries are scathing. He calls John out for running away from the gang for a year, for doubting Jack is his son, and for generally being ungrateful. It’s a bold move. Rockstar risked making their former protagonist unlikable to make his eventual growth feel earned. You aren't playing as John for the first 40 hours; you're watching him fail from a distance.
That distance is vital. It allows us to see the "Legend" as a flawed human being. Most sequels (or prequels) try to make the hero look cooler. RDR2 does the opposite. It makes him look vulnerable.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Every Pair of Stellar Blade Glasses: What Most Players Miss
That Weird Epilogue Transition
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room. When the game shifts to the Epilogue and you finally take control of John Red Dead Redemption 2, it feels weird. Many fans complained that "John-Arthur" (the model used for John that looks suspiciously like Arthur’s body) felt off. But narratively? It works.
You go from being a rugged outlaw to a guy shoveling literal manure at Pronghorn Ranch. It’s a massive tonal shift. The game forces you to experience the mundanity of "going straight." You aren't robbing trains; you're milking cows and nailing planks together. This is where the game’s "ludo-narrative resonance"—a fancy term for the gameplay matching the story—really kicks in. You feel John’s boredom. You feel his itch to pick up the gun again.
The Real Reason John Survived (For a While)
It wasn't just luck. John survived the events of 1899 because Arthur Morgan saw something in him that John didn't see in himself. Arthur’s sacrifice wasn't just about saving a friend; it was about saving a family. Arthur knew his own time was up—TB made sure of that—but John had a "get out of jail free" card in the form of Abigail and Jack.
Why the Marston-Morgan Dynamic Still Matters
The relationship between these two men is the beating heart of the game. It’s a brotherhood built on resentment that turns into deep, tragic respect.
- The 1899 Conflict: John represents the life Arthur could have had (a son, a partner), which makes Arthur bitter.
- The 1907 Redemption: John builds Beecher's Hope as a monument to Arthur’s sacrifice, even if he doesn't talk about it much.
- The Narrative Loop: Without Arthur’s influence, the John Marston we meet in the 1911 timeline wouldn't have the moral compass to even try to save his family.
Understanding the "Vanderlinde" Shadow
Dutch van der Linde is a cult leader. Let’s just say it. He didn't just recruit John; he raised him. John was a literal street urchin when Dutch found him. That kind of indoctrination doesn't just go away. Throughout John Red Dead Redemption 2, we see John struggling to unlearn everything Dutch taught him.
Dutch’s philosophy was built on a chaotic version of freedom. John, however, eventually realizes that true freedom is the exact opposite: it’s the responsibility of a home. It’s the fence he builds. It’s the boring, quiet life. The tragedy, of course, is that the Pinkertons—specifically Edgar Ross—use that very "responsible" life to find him. By settling down at Beecher’s Hope, John essentially signed his own death warrant. He became a stationary target.
The Gunplay Evolution
If you pay close attention to the mechanics, John’s "Dead Eye" feels different than Arthur’s. It’s more frantic. In the early chapters, John is a bit of a loose cannon. By the time you reach the mission "American Venom," he's a surgical instrument of death.
That final climb up Mount Hagen isn't just a revenge mission. It’s a relapse. It’s John proving that even though he can build a house, he is still the man Dutch created. When he kills Micah, he thinks he’s closing a chapter. In reality, he’s opening the door for the Bureau of Investigation to track him down. It’s a bittersweet victory that defines the entire series.
A Legacy of Failure and Redemption
Is John a "good" man? Probably not. He’s killed hundreds of people. He’s a thief. But in the context of the American Frontier, he’s as close to a hero as we get. He’s someone who tried to change.
💡 You might also like: Why the Criminality Skin Value List is Basically a Wild West Economy
The complexity of John Red Dead Redemption 2 lies in its refusal to give him a happy ending. Even when you’re playing the "happier" epilogue, there’s an underlying sense of dread. You know where this leads. You know that the ranch you're building will eventually be the site of his final stand. That knowledge makes every moment spent with Jack and Abigail feel incredibly heavy.
Key Takeaways for Your Next Playthrough
If you're hopping back into the saddle, don't rush the epilogue. The beauty of John's story is in the slow moments.
- Read the Journal: John’s drawings are terrible compared to Arthur’s. It’s a hilarious, humanizing detail that shows his lack of artistic refinement but his effort to carry on Arthur’s tradition.
- Interact with the Ranch: The chores at Beecher's Hope aren't just filler. They are the "Redemption" part of the title. Do the work.
- Watch the Hair: John's hair and beard grow in real-time just like Arthur's, but his "classic" look is only achievable after the main story. It’s a visual cue that he’s finally becoming the man we knew in 2010.
To truly understand John's arc, you have to accept his flaws. He isn't a stoic badass. He's a man who spent his whole life being told what to do—by Dutch, by Arthur, by the government—and only in his final years did he try to make his own choices. That's the real story of John Red Dead Redemption 2. It’s about the struggle to find an identity in a world that’s already decided who you are.
The best way to experience this is to focus on the optional camp dialogues. In Chapter 2 and 3, John is often found moping or arguing. If you ignore these, you miss the baseline of his character. By Chapter 6, his tone shifts. He stops asking "What does Dutch want?" and starts asking "What is right?" That shift is the most important journey in the entire franchise.
Actionable Steps for Players:
- Check out the "Marston Family" photos in the epilogue house; they provide a rare look at their life between the two games.
- Travel back to the old camp locations as John; he has unique dialogue and "ghost" memories that trigger in certain spots like Horseshoe Overlook.
- Finish the "Stranger" missions as John that Arthur started; the NPCs will often comment on Arthur's passing, providing a sense of closure that is genuinely moving.