People love a good mystery. Especially when it involves a guy who once wrote "Your Body Is a Wonderland" and the man who basically birthed the Real Housewives empire. For years, the internet has been obsessed with one question: what exactly is going on with John Mayer Andy Cohen?
It’s a bromance for the ages. Or maybe it's just a regular friendship that looks weird because we’re used to seeing celebrities in rigid little boxes. Honestly, if you scroll through Instagram or catch a glimpse of them together at a Dead & Company show, it’s easy to see why the rumors keep swirling. They’re touchy. They’re affectionate. They literally go on road trips in a giant off-road camping truck named the EarthRoamer.
👉 See also: Is Tillie Walton Part of the Walton Family? What You Need to Know
But here’s the thing. They’ve both said, over and over again, that it isn't what you think.
The Grateful Dead Connection
You can’t talk about John Mayer Andy Cohen without talking about the Grateful Dead. That’s the glue. It’s the "how they met" story that sounds like a fan-fiction fever dream but is actually 100% real. Back in 2015, they took a road trip to Santa Clara to see the Dead’s "Fare Thee Well" shows.
Andy, a lifelong Deadhead, was the one who really brought John into that world. Imagine that for a second. The Bravo king taking the pop-rock guitar hero to his first real jam band experience. John ended up falling so deep down the rabbit hole that he eventually joined Dead & Company, playing lead guitar for Bob Weir and Mickey Hart.
That road trip was legendary. They drove up the 101, hit up gay bars in San Francisco, and celebrated the day marriage equality passed in the U.S. Andy later wrote about it, mentioning how they debated which one of them was Oprah and which was Gayle. It’s that kind of easy, sibling-like energy that defines them.
Why the "Dating" Rumors Won't Die
The speculation reached a boiling point a couple of years back. In 2023, Andy sat down with Howard Stern—who is notorious for asking the most invasive questions possible—and said, "I am in love with John Mayer. We are in love with each other."
Predictably, the internet exploded.
Howard asked Andy to "swear on his children’s lives" that they had never been sexual. Andy did it without blinking. He swore. But the headline was already out there. Even as recently as late 2025, Andy was still clarifying things on the Call Her Daddy podcast. He told Alex Cooper that they often sit on the same side of the booth at dinner. They cuddle. They’re physical. But, as Andy put it, "nothing ever turns sexual."
✨ Don't miss: Selena Gomez Curly Hair: What Most People Get Wrong About Her Natural Texture
John Mayer’s Pointed Response
John usually stays pretty quiet about his personal life these days. He’s in his "elder statesman of guitar" era. But in May 2024, he finally snapped. Sorta.
He wrote a letter to The Hollywood Reporter after they asked Andy if people were "dubious" that a straight rock star and a gay TV host could just be friends. John didn’t just give a PR answer. He went deep. He called the premise "specious" and "deeply flawed."
"I’d like to think they’re sophisticated enough to see a relationship like ours without assuming it must include a sexual component. That turns the concept of being gay into an ignorarily two-dimensional one." — John Mayer
He basically argued that by constantly asking if they’re sleeping together, the media is actually being a bit homophobic. It suggests that a gay man and a straight man can't have a profound, loving, non-sexual bond. It’s a fair point. Why does love always have to mean sex in the eyes of the public?
The "Uncle John" Role
Beyond the red carpets and the concert pits, there’s a domestic side to this. John is a massive part of Andy’s kids' lives. There are photos of "Uncle John" reading to Ben and Lucy. When Andy got his star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame in 2022, John was the one giving the speech.
👉 See also: Beyonce Pregnancy and Blue Ivy: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
It was a beautiful speech, actually. He talked about how Andy had unwittingly become the "gay best friend" to people in America who didn't have one, softening hearts and opening minds through his transparency. It showed a level of respect that goes way beyond "hanging out at a bar."
What This Tells Us About Modern Friendship
The obsession with John Mayer Andy Cohen actually says more about us than it does about them. We live in a culture that struggles with "platonic intimacy," especially between men.
We’re used to:
- "The Boys" (surface-level sports talk and beer).
- Romantic partners (the only people you're allowed to be vulnerable with).
- Work colleagues.
When two men—one gay, one straight—openly say "I love you" and lean on each other’s shoulders, it breaks the script. It makes people uncomfortable or suspicious. But in 2026, maybe it’s time to accept that "soulmates" don't always have to be romantic.
Sometimes, your soulmate is just the guy who understands your obsession with a twenty-minute version of "Dark Star."
Real-World Takeaways
If you’re looking at this friendship and wondering why it’s so polarizing, consider these points:
- Intimacy isn't a zero-sum game. You can be deeply, physically affectionate with a friend without it being romantic.
- Shared passions matter. Their bond over the Grateful Dead provided a foundation that survived the chaos of their individual fame.
- Labels are for jars, not people. Both men have pushed back against the need to "categorize" their bond for the sake of public comfort.
The next time you see a photo of them at a dinner in West Hollywood sitting on the same side of the booth, don't look for a "scandal." Look for the rarity of it: two people who actually, genuinely show up for each other.
If you want to see this dynamic in action, go back and watch John’s 2022 Walk of Fame speech for Andy. It’s probably the most honest look at their relationship you’ll ever find. It isn't a PR stunt. It’s just two guys who found their person in a town—Hollywood—where "real" is a hard thing to come by.