If you’ve ever ridden through the digital plains of New Austin or survived the snowy peaks of Colter, you know that voice. It’s gravelly. It’s tired. It sounds like a man who has swallowed a gallon of West Texas dust and washed it down with cheap whiskey. That’s the voice of John Marston.
Most people just assume there’s a professional actor in a booth in Los Angeles somewhere, cashing checks and moving on to the next gig. But the story of the john marston voice actor is way weirder than that. It’s actually one of the most grounded, "human" stories in the entire gaming industry.
Rob Wiethoff didn't just play a guy trying to get back to his farm. He basically lived it.
The Audition That Almost Didn't Happen
Back in 2008, Rob Wiethoff was just another guy in LA trying to make it. He was bartending. He was doing some construction. He’d landed a few tiny roles—like "Court Officer" in the Bruce Willis movie 16 Blocks—but he wasn't exactly a Hollywood A-lister. Honestly, he was kind of over the whole scene.
Then his agent calls. There’s an audition for an "untitled video game project" from Rockstar Games.
Rob goes in. He sees a room full of dudes dressed in full military tactical gear. He thinks, "Great, I'm at the wrong place." He wasn't a soldier. He was just a guy from Indiana. But he went in anyway.
The audition was weird. He had to fold laundry while reading lines. He thought he blew it. He told himself it was a waste of time. A few days later, he was the lead in one of the biggest games ever made.
Moving From Hollywood Back to the Dirt
Here is the thing that trips people up: after Red Dead Redemption launched in 2010 and became a massive, culture-shifting hit, Rob didn't stay in LA to capitalize on it. He didn't try to get a role in a Marvel movie or start a podcast about being a celebrity.
He moved back to Seymour, Indiana.
He literally did what John Marston wanted to do. He went home to be with his family and work a "regular" job. For years, the voice of one of gaming's most iconic outlaws was just a guy you might see on the side of the road wearing a high-vis vest and a hard hat. He went back to construction. He raised his twin boys. He lived a life that was almost entirely disconnected from the gaming world.
It wasn't that he hated the industry. He just liked his life in Indiana more.
🔗 Read more: The Xbox Chronicles of Riddick is Still the Best Movie Game Ever Made
The Call for Red Dead Redemption 2
When Rockstar decided to make Red Dead Redemption 2, they knew they couldn't just replace him. Fans would have rioted. The problem was that Rob was 2,000 miles away and had a whole life that didn't involve standing in a mo-cap suit for years.
The commitment was massive. We're talking about a game that took nearly eight years to develop.
Rob has talked about this in interviews, and it’s pretty wild. He used up all his vacation time from his construction job. Then he used his sick leave. Eventually, he just had to quit that job to finish the game. Think about that for a second. The lead actor of a billion-dollar franchise had to juggle his PTO like a regular office worker.
Why the Voice Works So Well
There is a specific quality to Rob’s performance that feels unforced. A lot of voice actors try to "act" like a cowboy. They do the drawl. They do the "tough guy" growl.
Wiethoff doesn't really do that. That’s just his voice.
He took inspiration from the "tough dudes" he knew back in his hometown. He wasn't pulling from old John Wayne movies; he was pulling from guys who actually worked with their hands and didn't talk much. That’s why John Marston feels so authentic. He isn't a caricature of a gunslinger. He’s a tired father who is way over his head.
Is He a Gamer? Not Really.
You’d think the john marston voice actor would be at home playing Call of Duty or Elden Ring.
Nope.
👉 See also: Why the Ocarina of Time Spirit Temple Still Messes With Your Head
Rob has been very open about the fact that he’s not really a gamer. He played Red Dead Redemption and the Undead Nightmare expansion, but he mostly does it because he’s in them. He once mentioned that he’s afraid to get into other games because he knows himself—he’d probably get obsessed and never get any work done.
There’s something incredibly refreshing about that. He’s a guy who treats his work with immense respect and gives it 100%, but then he goes home and lives a life that has nothing to do with the "biz."
The Famous "Nothing Gets Forgiven" Quote
When asked about his favorite line, Rob often points to the one that defines John: "People don't forget. Nothing gets forgiven."
It’s a grim outlook. But Rob played it with a sense of regret that made you root for him anyway. He understood that John wasn't a hero. He was a man with a past he couldn't outrun.
Life After the Van der Linde Gang
These days, you can find Rob on TikTok or doing the convention circuit. He’s incredibly nice to fans. Seriously, if you ever see a video of him at a booth, he looks like he’s having the time of his life. He calls himself a "jackass" for making TikToks at 48, but the community loves him for it.
He’s even started playing through the original Red Dead Redemption on stream recently. Watching a guy hear his own voice from 15 years ago while trying to figure out the controls is genuinely wholesome.
Key Takeaways for Fans
If you're looking to follow Rob Wiethoff’s career or understand the man behind the hat, here’s what you need to know:
- He’s an Indiana native through and through. He didn't let Hollywood change him.
- The voice is real. It’s not a filter or a forced rasp.
- He quit a regular job to finish RDR2 because he cared that much about the fans and the project.
- He’s not "active" in Hollywood. If you see him in something, it’s probably because it’s a project he truly cares about or a favor for a friend.
The legacy of John Marston is safe because the man who played him is just as legendary in real life. He isn't an "industry" guy. He’s just Rob. And that’s exactly why we love him.
If you want to support the man himself, you can find him at various gaming conventions throughout the year—he’s a regular at places like Fan Expo and MCM. He also occasionally does shoutouts on Cameo, which is a great way to get a personalized "Hello, brother" in that iconic gravelly tone.