Money doesn't just buy houses; it buys reality. Or at least, it did for John E du Pont.
He was the guy who had everything—a multi-million dollar chemical fortune, an 800-acre estate in Pennsylvania, and a scientific reputation as an ornithologist. But by the 1990s, the "Golden Boy" of the du Pont dynasty was living in a world of ghosts, secret tunnels, and "clock-stopping" treadmills. Most people know the name because of the movie Foxcatcher, where Steve Carell played him with that eerie, prosthetic nose. But the real story is messier. It’s a story about how extreme wealth can mask a total mental collapse until it's too late for anyone to stop a murder.
📖 Related: Who is Predicted to Win the House: The Realities of a Razor-Thin Majority
The Wrestling Obsession and the Rise of Team Foxcatcher
John E du Pont didn't just like wrestling. He wanted to own it.
Growing up, he was essentially a lonely kid in a massive mansion. His father was gone; his mother, Jean Liseter Austin, was a world-class horse breeder who didn't exactly shower him with warmth. In fact, John once found out that his mother had paid a local boy just to be his friend. Imagine that for a second. That kind of childhood creates a person who views relationships as transactions.
He couldn't be a wrestler himself—he’d lost both testicles in a horse-riding accident as a young man—so he poured money into the sport instead. He built a 14,000-square-foot training center on his estate, Foxcatcher Farm. He funneled over $3 million into USA Wrestling. For a while, he was the hero of the amateur wrestling world. He was the benefactor. He was "Eagle" or "Golden Eagle," as he liked to be called.
But there was a catch.
To train at Foxcatcher, you had to play by John’s rules. You had to call him "Coach." You had to endure his awkward, middle-of-the-night speeches. For the athletes, many of whom were living in houses on his property for free, it was a weird trade-off. They got world-class facilities; he got a "family" he could control.
When the Delusions Took Over
Honestly, the red flags weren't just red; they were neon.
After his mother died in 1988, John’s grip on reality started to snap. It wasn't just "eccentricity" anymore. He started carrying a gun everywhere. He once drove two Lincoln Continentals into a pond, one right after the other, for no apparent reason. He’d show up at his wrestlers' houses at 2:00 AM, rambling about international conspiracies.
He became convinced that the trees on his property were moving. He thought Nazis were hiding in the walls. He even fired several black wrestlers because he decided Foxcatcher was now a "KKK" organization. He once pointed a machine gun at wrestler Dan Chaid and told him to get off the farm.
The most bizarre part? People just let it happen.
The local police in Newtown Square considered him a "friend of the department." He’d donated money for their gear and trained their dogs. When athletes complained about his behavior, they were often told, "That’s just John." His wealth acted like a giant buffer between him and the consequences of his actions.
The Murder of Dave Schultz
On January 26, 1996, the buffer failed.
Dave Schultz was an Olympic gold medalist and, by all accounts, one of the few people John actually trusted. Dave was the "peacekeeper" on the farm, the guy who could calm John down when he was spiraling. But John’s paranoia had reached a boiling point. He’d become jealous of the respect Dave commanded.
John drove his Lincoln Town Car up to Dave’s guesthouse. Dave was outside working on his car. John rolled down the window, asked, "You got a problem with me?" and fired three shots from a .38-caliber revolver. He killed Dave in cold blood, right in front of Dave’s wife, Nancy.
What followed was a surreal 48-hour standoff. John barricaded himself in his 47-room mansion, which was basically a fortress. He had high-powered weapons and even an armored personnel carrier. The police eventually caught him because they turned off the heat in the middle of a Pennsylvania winter. John crawled out to fix the boiler, and they jumped him.
The Trial and the "Mentally Ill" Verdict
The trial was a battle of experts. Was he insane? Or was he just a rich guy who thought he could get away with murder?
His defense team argued he was a paranoid schizophrenic. They pointed to the fact that he thought he was the Dalai Lama, the Christ Child, and a CIA agent. They said he saw bugs from outer space crawling on his skin. Even the prosecution's experts agreed he was mentally ill, but they argued he still knew right from wrong.
In 1997, the jury came back with a unique verdict: Guilty of third-degree murder but mentally ill.
It meant he was responsible, but he’d serve his time in a way that acknowledged his condition. He was sentenced to 13 to 30 years. He was the only member of the Forbes 400 to ever be convicted of murder.
🔗 Read more: Is Gaza part of Israel? The messy reality behind the borders
What Most People Get Wrong About the Legacy
People often think John E du Pont died shortly after the trial, but he actually lived in prison for quite a while. He died in 2010 at the age of 72 at the Laurel Highlands State Correctional Institution.
There's also a common misconception about his money. People assume the du Pont family took it all back after the murder. They didn't. In a final twist of the knife to his own family, John left 80% of his estate to Valentin Yordanov, a Bulgarian wrestler who had remained loyal to him. His family fought the will, but they lost.
The real tragedy isn't just the loss of a great wrestler like Dave Schultz. It’s the fact that the warning signs were there for a decade. The system didn't fail because it couldn't see the danger; it failed because it didn't want to see the danger in a man with that much money.
Actionable Insights from the Foxcatcher Story
If you're looking at this story today, it's more than just a true crime curiosity. It's a case study in power dynamics and mental health.
- Understand the "Wealth Buffer": This case is a prime example of how social status can delay intervention in mental health crises. Recognize that "eccentricity" in the powerful is often just untreated illness.
- Prioritize Safety Over Opportunity: For the athletes at Foxcatcher, the prestige of the facility masked the physical danger. If a environment feels unstable, no amount of funding is worth the risk.
- Trust the Patterns: John’s behavior wasn't a one-off. It was a years-long escalation. When someone shows you who they are through consistent, erratic patterns, believe them the first time.
The Foxcatcher estate is gone now—most of the buildings were demolished and turned into a luxury housing development. But the story of John E du Pont remains a chilling reminder that no amount of money can fix a broken mind, and no amount of prestige should ever buy silence.
Next Steps
To get a full picture of the events, you should watch the documentary Team Foxcatcher on Netflix. Unlike the Hollywood movie, it uses actual home video footage from the farm that shows just how awkward and tense the atmosphere really was before the tragedy. You can also read Mark Schultz's memoir, Foxcatcher: The True Story of My Brother's Murder, John du Pont's Madness, and the Quest for Olympic Gold, to hear the story from the man who lived through it.