You’re walking through a desolate-looking stretch of Long Island City, dodging industrial trucks and wondering if your GPS is messing with you, when the smell hits. It isn’t that faint, "maybe there's a grill nearby" scent. It’s heavy. It’s hickory. It’s the kind of aroma that sticks to your clothes and makes your stomach growl before you even see the door. That is the John Brown Smokehouse NYC experience in a nutshell. It’s out of the way, it’s unassuming, and it serves some of the best burnt ends you will ever put in your mouth.
Kansas City is a long way from Queens. Like, halfway across the country long. But Chef Josh Bowen managed to portal the entire flavor profile of the Missouri-Kansas border into a corner of New York that, frankly, needed some soul. People argue about BBQ in this city constantly. They fight over the fancy spots in Brooklyn or the massive pits in Manhattan. Most of those people are wrong. If you want the real deal—the kind of meat that doesn't need a gimmick or a celebrity endorsement—you end up here.
The Burnt End Obsession
Let's talk about the burnt ends. Seriously. If you go to John Brown Smokehouse NYC and don't order them, you’ve basically wasted a trip. In the BBQ world, burnt ends are the nuggets of gold cut from the "point" of a smoked brisket. They’re fatty, charred, and tender. At John Brown, they aren't just an afterthought or a scrap heap item. They are the main event.
Most places over-sauce their meat to hide the fact that it's dry. Bowen doesn't do that. The meat has this crust—the "bark"—that provides a crunch before melting into rendered fat. It’s salty, sweet, and smoky all at once. Honestly, it’s a little bit aggressive how good they are. You’ll see people sitting at the communal tables, completely silent, just working through a pile of these things. It's like a religious experience, but with more grease and better napkins.
The menu isn't some massive, leather-bound book. It’s a chalkboard. You see what they have, you order by the pound or the half-pound, and you find a seat. It feels like a backyard party that got out of hand in the best way possible.
Beyond the Brisket: What Else Matters?
While the burnt ends get the Instagram glory, the rest of the menu is doing some heavy lifting. The pulled pork is moist. That sounds like a simple thing, but anyone who has eaten "dry-as-a-bone" pork at a midtown cafeteria knows it’s a rare feat. They smoke it long enough that the connective tissue just gives up, leaving you with strands of pork that soak up their vinegar-based sauce perfectly.
📖 Related: Charlie Gunn Lynnville Indiana: What Really Happened at the Family Restaurant
Then there are the ribs. These aren't those "fall-off-the-bone" ribs that people think are good but are actually overcooked. A real rib should have a "tug." When you bite it, the meat should come away from the bone cleanly, but it should still have some texture. John Brown nailed this.
The Sides You Actually Need
Don't ignore the sides. Please.
- The Collard Greens: They’ve got some kick. They aren't just soggy leaves; they’re flavored with enough smoked meat to be a meal on their own.
- Cornbread: It’s dense. It’s slightly sweet. It acts as the perfect sponge for any leftover sauce on your tray.
- Mac and Cheese: It’s creamy, not grainy. It's the kind of comfort food that makes you want to take a nap immediately after finishing.
The vibe of the place matters too. It’s gritty. It’s got a patio that feels like a hidden oasis in an industrial park. You’ll see guys in suits from the nearby Citigroup building sitting next to construction workers and hipsters who trekked from Bushwick. BBQ is a great equalizer, and John Brown Smokehouse NYC is the ultimate proof of that.
The Kansas City Connection
Josh Bowen is a character. If you follow the NYC food scene, you know he’s outspoken. He’s a massive Kansas City Chiefs fan—the restaurant is basically a shrine to the team. During football season, the energy in there is electric. It’s loud. It’s partisan. It’s fun.
But his passion isn't just for the team; it's for the specific style of KC BBQ. In Kansas City, the sauce is king, but the smoke is the foundation. It’s a thick, tomato-based sauce that balances sweet and spicy. At John Brown, they don't drown the meat in it before it hits your tray. You get the meat in its naked, smoky glory, and you add the sauce yourself. That’s a sign of a pitmaster who trusts their process. They aren't hiding anything.
👉 See also: Charcoal Gas Smoker Combo: Why Most Backyard Cooks Struggle to Choose
There was a bit of a scare a few years back when they had to move locations, but the new spot on 40th Ave kept the soul of the original. In fact, it might even be better because the outdoor space is more expansive. It feels permanent.
Why It Beats the Manhattan Competition
Manhattan has some decent BBQ, sure. But those places often feel like they were designed by a corporate committee to look "rustic." They have perfectly distressed wood and Edison bulbs. John Brown Smokehouse NYC feels rustic because it is rustic. The decor is whatever was available. The focus is 100% on the smokers.
When you go to a place like Hometown in Red Hook, you’re looking at a two-hour wait on a Saturday. It’s great, don’t get me wrong. But John Brown offers that same level of craft without the soul-crushing line. It’s accessible. It’s for the neighborhood. It’s the kind of place you can go on a random Tuesday night when you just can’t deal with cooking.
The Logistics: Getting There Without Getting Lost
Long Island City is weird. You’ve got the shiny glass towers by the water and then you’ve got the "oily rag" section further inland. John Brown is in the latter.
- Take the 7, N, or W train to Queensboro Plaza.
- Walk about ten minutes toward the industrial area.
- Look for the Chiefs flags.
If you’re driving, parking is actually surprisingly easy compared to the rest of the city. Just watch the street signs; the traffic cops in LIC don't play around.
✨ Don't miss: Celtic Knot Engagement Ring Explained: What Most People Get Wrong
The prices are fair. You aren't getting a $5 meal—good brisket is expensive to source and labor-intensive to cook—but you won't feel ripped off either. You're paying for 12 to 14 hours of wood-fired patience. That’s a bargain in a city where a mediocre salad costs twenty bucks.
Final Word on the Experience
Is it the "best" in the city? That’s subjective. But if you value authenticity and a lack of pretension, John Brown Smokehouse NYC is at the top of the list. It’s a place that knows what it is. It doesn't try to offer a "fusion" menu or vegan brisket (thank God). It offers wood, fire, meat, and salt.
Sometimes, that’s all you really need.
Next time you find yourself bored with the usual dinner options, get on the 7 train. Get the burnt ends. Grab a beer. Sit outside and listen to the trains rumble nearby. You’ll realize that despite all the changes in New York, there are still pockets of the city that feel real, smoky, and damn delicious.
Actionable Steps for Your Visit
- Check the hours before you go. They sometimes close early if they run out of meat, though they’ve gotten much better at pacing their inventory lately.
- Order the "Big Man" if you’re with a group. It’s a platter that lets you sample a bit of everything without having to make the hard choices yourself.
- Don't skip the pickles. They provide the necessary acid to cut through the richness of the brisket fat.
- Bring a jacket. Even in the shoulder seasons, the patio can get a bit breezy, and that’s the best place to sit.
- Check the game schedule. If the Chiefs are playing, expect a crowd. If you're a fan, it's the best place in the city to watch. If you aren't, maybe pick a different afternoon.
Stay hungry. Support the local pits. And remember, the bark is the best part.