If you’ve spent any amount of time watching TruTV over the last decade, you’ve probably asked yourself: "Wait, is Joey Fatone actually in this group?" Honestly, it's a fair question. Most celebrity cameos on hidden-camera shows feel like awkward corporate synergy—a PR-mandated stop on a press tour where the star looks like they’d rather be getting a root canal.
But Joey Fatone is different.
The former NSYNC star has become such a fixture of the Joey Fatone Impractical Jokers universe that fans often refer to him as the "Fifth Joker." He isn't just a guest; he’s a guy who clearly loves the chaos. From hosting the After Party to filling in for a broken-ribbed Brian "Q" Quinn, Fatone has earned his stripes in a way few outsiders ever could.
👉 See also: Whatever Happened to Bumpty? The Truth About the Grown Ups 2 Breakout Kid
The Random Origin of a TV Bromance
How does a global pop icon end up as the unofficial mascot for four guys from Staten Island who make a living by embarrassing each other?
It wasn't a talent agency deal. It was a podcast.
Back in the day, Q and Sal Vulcano hosted a podcast called What Say You?. During one episode, they mentioned they were fans of Fatone. As luck would have it, Joey—or his kids, depending on which interview you believe—was already a fan of the show. He reached out on Twitter. A few days later, he was on set.
That first appearance happened way back in Season 3, in an episode titled "Toasted." Q was struggling with a challenge, and suddenly, there’s Joey Fatone, casually standing in as a waiter.
He didn't just stand there, either. He committed. He took the earpiece, said the ridiculous things the guys told him to say, and won the challenge for Q. That was the moment the fans realized this wasn't going to be a one-off thing.
Why Joey Fatone and Impractical Jokers Just Works
The magic of Joey Fatone Impractical Jokers appearances lies in his lack of ego. Most celebrities are terrified of looking stupid. Joey? He seems to thrive on it.
Think about the "Fat-Ones" episode. Joey opened a hot dog stand in Orlando (actually named Fat One’s, because of course it is). The Jokers showed up to "help" him run it. Instead of protecting his brand, Joey let them turn the grand opening into a total circus.
The Hosting Era
For a long time, Joey was the face of Impractical Jokers: After Party. While the Jokers are masters of the prank, they aren't always the most polished interviewers. Joey brought a professional "broadcaster" energy to the table while still being able to hang with the guys' constant ribbing.
🔗 Read more: Michael Che Leaving SNL: Why the Rumors Just Won't Die
He stayed in that role for years, becoming the bridge between the fans and the behind-the-scenes madness. He’s the guy who asks the questions we actually want to know, like how much of the "punishments" are truly staged (spoiler: not as much as you’d think).
That Time He Actually Got Punished
For years, Joey had a "get out of jail free" card. He was the guest, the host, or the replacement, but he never actually had to face a punishment.
That changed in Season 10.
In a 2024 episode, the show flipped the script. Joey wasn't just a guest; he was a full-blown Joker for the day. He did the receptionist challenge—which, let’s be real, is a classic—and he actually lost.
The punishment was a "Best Of" gauntlet. They didn't just give him one task. They made him endure a highlight reel of the show’s most miserable moments.
- They numbed his mouth with Novocaine.
- They made him host a fake dance party show while drooling.
- They even threw in the "wetting the pants" bit for good measure.
Seeing a guy who sold 70 million records standing in a public space with wet pants while trying to talk through a numb face is the peak of the Joey Fatone Impractical Jokers legacy. He didn't complain. He just laughed his way through the humiliation.
Could He Ever Be a Permanent Member?
When Joe Gatto left the show in 2021, the internet went into a frenzy. Who could replace him?
Joey Fatone’s name was at the top of every Reddit thread.
"He’s already there anyway," fans argued. "He has the chemistry."
Honestly, it makes sense on paper. He’s close friends with Sal, Murr, and Q. He’s been in the movie. He’s done the live tours. But as of 2026, the show has stuck to its "rotating guest" format rather than naming a permanent fourth member.
There’s a nuance to the "four lifelong friends" dynamic that’s hard to replicate. Even though Joey is a great friend, he wasn't there in high school when they were forming the Tenderloins. Keeping him as a frequent "special operative" preserves the original spirit of the show while giving us the "Fatone fix" we clearly want.
The Impact on His Career
It’s easy to forget that Joey has had a massive career outside of being the Jokers' favorite target. He’s the announcer for Family Feud. He’s been on Dancing with the Stars. He was the Rabbit on The Masked Singer.
But his work with the Jokers has given him a second life with a younger audience. He isn't "the guy from that 90s band" to Gen Z; he’s the funny guy who hangs out with Q and Sal.
What to Watch Next
If you want to see the best of the Joey Fatone Impractical Jokers crossover, you've got to dig into the archives. Don't just stick to the main show.
- The "Toasted" Episode (Season 3): The first time he fills in for Q. It’s pure, early-era Jokers gold.
- The Nitro Circus Special: Joey competing on Q's behalf again during a live event.
- Season 10, Episode 18: The "Joey Fatone" episode where he finally gets punished.
- Impractical Jokers: The Movie: Look for his cameo—it’s quick, but it’s there.
Joey Fatone has proven that you don't have to be a founding member to be part of the family. He’s the guy who showed up for a podcast and ended up becoming an integral part of one of the biggest comedy franchises on television.
📖 Related: Why Bossman Dlow Money Talks is the Anthem Florida Rap Needed
To keep up with Joey's latest shenanigans on the show, you should definitely check the TBS schedule or the TruTV app. They’ve been leaning into the celebrity guest format more than ever lately, and with the chemistry he has with the remaining trio, it’s only a matter of time before he’s back in the earpiece, ruining his reputation for our entertainment.
Keep an eye on his social media too—he often posts behind-the-scenes clips when he’s filming with the guys, giving a much more "human" look at how these pranks actually come together.
Next Steps for Fans:
- Check out the Impractical Jokers official YouTube channel for the "Best of Joey Fatone" compilations.
- Listen to the old episodes of the What Say You? podcast to hear the literal moment this friendship started.
- Look for Joey’s hot dog brand, Fat One's, if you're ever in the Orlando area; the Jokers' influence is literally written on the menu.