Netflix reality TV is a wild ride, but nothing quite prepared fans for the chaotic, emotional, and eventually heartbreaking saga of Joey and Kariselle Perfect Match season one. People still talk about it. They were the "it" couple of the villa. From the second Kariselle Snow walked through those doors and saw Joey Sasso, the vibe shifted. It wasn't just a random pairing; they had a history that predated the show by years.
That history is exactly why their trajectory felt so heavy.
Reality dating shows usually thrive on "newness," but this was different. Joey and Kariselle weren't starting from zero. They had a messy, "will-they-won't-they" past in the real world long before they stepped onto a soundstage in Panama. Honestly, it felt like watching two people try to fix a broken vase with duct tape and high-definition cameras.
The Long Road to the Perfect Match Finale
Joey Sasso came into the show as the winner of The Circle Season 1. He had this "lovable guy from Rochester" persona that people genuinely clicked with. Kariselle, coming from Sexy Beasts, was vibrant, loud, and unapologetically herself. When they matched, it wasn't just for a challenge. It was a commitment.
They didn't swap partners. They didn't really "play the field" like Francesca Farago or Dom Gabriel did at various points. They were locked in. Joey even did the unthinkable in reality TV land: he proposed.
Actually, let's talk about that proposal. It was a massive moment for the Joey and Kariselle Perfect Match storyline. On the final day, Joey got down on one knee. He talked about his growth. He talked about how she was the only one for him. Kariselle said yes. They were the runner-ups for the season, losing out to Georgia Hassarati and Dom Gabriel, but in the eyes of many fans, they were the "real" winners because they left engaged.
But the reality of reality TV is that the cameras eventually turn off. And that's when things got complicated.
Why the Engagement Didn't Last
Kariselle has been pretty open about the fact that life after the show wasn't a fairy tale. The transition from a tropical villa to real-world responsibilities is a notorious relationship killer for Netflix stars. For Joey and Kariselle Perfect Match fans, the breakup news hit hard because it felt like they had finally figured it out.
✨ Don't miss: Chase From Paw Patrol: Why This German Shepherd Is Actually a Big Deal
They didn't.
Shortly after the finale aired, it was revealed they had split. Kariselle later shared insights into the breakup, hinting that the same issues that plagued them before the show—commitment fears, communication breakdowns, and the pressure of the spotlight—resurfaced. Joey, for his part, has maintained a relatively respectful distance from the drama, though he's acknowledged that they just weren't meant to be in the long run.
It's sorta sad when you think about it. You watch a couple go through the ringer, commit to marriage on global television, and then watch it dissolve in a series of Instagram stories and podcast interviews.
The Real-World Pressure Cooker
What most people get wrong is thinking the show "faked" their connection. It didn't. The chemistry was clearly there. You could see it in the way they looked at each other during the compatibility challenges. But "chemistry" and "compatibility" are two very different things.
Joey and Kariselle struggled with the fundamental "how do we live together?" part of a relationship. In the villa, your only job is to date. In the real world, you have bills, travel schedules, and different social circles. Joey’s life in LA and Kariselle’s life on the East Coast created a physical and emotional distance that the engagement couldn't bridge.
Examining the "Perfect Match" Success Rate
If we’re being honest, the show's track record is abysmal. Joey and Kariselle Perfect Match were supposed to be the gold standard. If they couldn't make it work with years of history behind them, who could?
- Georgia and Dom: Split almost immediately after filming.
- Chloe and Shayne: A chaotic mess that ended before the flight home.
- Bartise and... anyone: We know how that went.
Joey and Kariselle lasted longer than most, but the "engagement" tag added a layer of scrutiny they probably weren't ready for. When you get engaged on TV, the public feels like they own a piece of your relationship. Every "like" on a photo or lack of a birthday post becomes a news headline. That’s a lot of weight for a couple that was already struggling with trust issues from their pre-TV days.
🔗 Read more: Charlize Theron Sweet November: Why This Panned Rom-Com Became a Cult Favorite
What Kariselle Said Post-Split
Kariselle didn't hold back in her post-show reflections. She mentioned that while the love was real, the "version" of the relationship they showed on TV was the best possible version of themselves. Once the stress of daily life returned, the old patterns came back.
She's spoken about wanting a partner who is 100% sure about her without the nudge of a production crew. That’s a fair point. Sometimes, the environment of a reality show forces a "peak" in a relationship that isn't sustainable. You’re in a beautiful location, you’re competing to win, and you’re surrounded by people telling you how great you are together. It’s an artificial high.
Joey’s Perspective and Life After Kariselle
Joey Sasso has stayed busy. Since Joey and Kariselle Perfect Match ended, he's leaned into his brand as a personality and actor. He’s always been someone who wears his heart on his sleeve, which is why people liked him on The Circle.
He's hinted that the breakup was mutual but difficult. In the world of influencer dating, it's easy to turn a breakup into a "feud" for clout. Neither of them really did that. There were some spicy comments here and there, but for the most part, they handled it with as much grace as you can expect from two people whose engagement was a plot point for a multi-million dollar streaming giant.
Lessons Learned from the Joey and Kariselle Saga
There is a lot to unpack here regarding how we consume reality TV. We want the happy ending. We want the proposal. But we often ignore the red flags that the contestants themselves are pointing out.
Throughout the season, Kariselle was vocal about her insecurities regarding Joey's commitment. Joey was vocal about his need for space. These weren't just "tv drama" moments; they were foundational cracks.
- History isn't always a foundation. Sometimes, having a "past" means you have too much baggage to build a future.
- Location matters. Long-distance is the silent killer of reality TV romances.
- The "Engagement" Trap. Proposing on camera creates a legal and social contract that is incredibly hard to maintain once the lights go out.
Actionable Insights for Reality TV Fans
If you're following the lives of the Joey and Kariselle Perfect Match cast, there are ways to keep up without falling for the "edit."
💡 You might also like: Charlie Charlie Are You Here: Why the Viral Demon Myth Still Creeps Us Out
First, look at their social media activity about six months after the finale. That is usually when the non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) loosen up and the real truth comes out. Kariselle’s TikTok and Joey’s Instagram are the best places to see where they stand now—which is, currently, in very different places.
Second, understand that "Perfect Match" is a game show first and a dating show second. The goal is to stay in the house. This influences why people match. Joey and Kariselle had the benefit of a real connection, but even that wasn't enough to overcome the "game" aspect of their initial reunion.
Third, don't expect a reconciliation. While fans often hold out hope for their favorite couples to get back together, both Joey and Kariselle have moved on to different projects and, seemingly, different headspace. The "Perfect Match" chapter of their lives is firmly closed.
The story of Joey and Kariselle serves as a reminder that even the most "solid" reality TV couples are subject to the same pressures as anyone else—just with a much larger audience watching them fail. They gave us a great season of television, but the real "perfect match" for both of them is likely someone who was never in the villa to begin with.
Next Steps for Followers
- Check the Timeline: Look for Kariselle's guest appearances on podcasts like "U Up?" or "Not Skinny But Not Fat" for the deep-dive audio interviews where she explains the nuances of the breakup.
- Verify Socials: Follow Joey Sasso’s official channels for updates on his upcoming acting projects, as he has largely moved away from the "dating show" circuit to focus on his original career goals.
- Watch Season 2: Compare the dynamics of the first season couples to the second to see if Netflix adjusted the "casting for history" strategy that defined the Joey and Kariselle arc.
The ending of their engagement wasn't a failure of love, but a reality check. In the world of streaming entertainment, the "happily ever after" usually ends when the credits roll, and the real work begins when the microphones are unclipped.