He isn't a hero. If you've spent any time at all playing Naughty Dog’s masterpiece, you know that calling Joel Miller a "good guy" is a stretch that would break most people's logic. He’s a survivor. More specifically, he is a man who had the world's most agonizing front-row seat to the collapse of civilization, lost his daughter in the first twenty minutes of the outbreak, and spent the next two decades becoming the kind of person you’d avoid in a dark alley. The Last of Us Joel is a character study in trauma, selfishness, and the terrifying lengths a person will go to when they finally find something to lose again.
Most games give you a moral compass. They guide you toward the "right" choice or at least give you a dialogue tree where you can pretend to be a saint. Joel doesn't give you that luxury. He’s messy.
The thing is, we love him anyway. Or we hate him. Or we’re somewhere in that uncomfortable middle ground where we understand exactly why he did what he did at the Salt Lake City hospital, even if we know it probably doomed humanity to a slow, fungal-infested extinction. It’s that moral gray area that keeps the internet arguing about him over a decade after the first game dropped.
The Construction of a Broken Man
Joel wasn't always a hardened smuggler with a penchant for smashing heads. Before the Cordyceps Brain Infection (CBI) hit on September 26, 2013, he was a single dad in Austin, Texas, struggling to make ends meet as a contractor. He was tired. He worked late. He worried about his mortgage. He was, for all intents and purposes, us.
When Sarah dies—not from the fungus, but from a soldier’s bullet—Joel’s world doesn't just end; it hardens. It’s a crucial distinction. He doesn't become a hollow shell; he becomes a fortress. By the time we meet him in the Boston Quarantine Zone (QZ), he’s twenty years older, cynical, and deeply involved in the black market with Tess. He has a reputation for being ruthless. He’s not "saving" people. He’s surviving.
Then Ellie happens.
At first, she's just "cargo." He’s doing a job for the Fireflies to get his guns back. But the brilliance of the writing in The Last of Us is how slowly that armor chips away. It isn't a sudden realization. It’s a series of small, agonizing steps—a shared joke from a pun book, a narrow escape in Pittsburgh, a tense standoff at a ranch house in Jackson. Joel tries so hard not to love her. Because in Joel’s world, loving someone is a death sentence.
👉 See also: What Can You Get From Fishing Minecraft: Why It Is More Than Just Cod
That Ending: The Decision That Changed Everything
We have to talk about the hospital. If you're reading this, you likely know the beats, but the weight of it bears repeating. Joel finds out that to create a vaccine, the Fireflies have to kill Ellie. Jerry Anderson, the surgeon, is convinced it’s the only way. Marlene, who knew Ellie’s mother, is convinced it’s the only way.
Joel? Joel doesn't care about "the only way."
He tears through that hospital like a force of nature. It’s one of the most uncomfortable sequences in gaming because the game makes you pull the trigger. You aren't watching a cutscene of Joel killing doctors; you are the one pressing the buttons. You're the one walking into that operating room.
What really sticks in the craw of many players is the lie. He doesn't just save her; he robs her of her choice. He tells her the Fireflies had stopped looking for a cure. He looks her in the eye and lies to her face to preserve the father-daughter dynamic he’s rebuilt. It’s deeply human and incredibly toxic. It’s the ultimate "dad" move—the desire to protect your child even if it means destroying their sense of purpose.
The Last of Us Part II and the Consequences of Violence
If the first game was about finding love in a hopeless world, Part II is about the bill coming due. You can't kill a dozen people in a hospital, including a lead surgeon, and expect to live happily ever after in Jackson.
Joel’s death at the hands of Abby Anderson is one of the most controversial moments in media history. Period. People were livid. They felt betrayed. But looking at it objectively, Joel’s arc required a reckoning. He had spent years being the villain in someone else’s story. Abby wasn't some random monster; she was a girl whose father was killed by a man who decided his "daughter" was more important than the world.
✨ Don't miss: Free games free online: Why we're still obsessed with browser gaming in 2026
The shift in Joel's character in the beginning of Part II is subtle but vital. He’s softer. He’s playing guitar. He’s making wood carvings. He’s trying to be the man Sarah would have wanted him to be. That’s what makes his death so jarring—he finally allowed himself to be vulnerable, and that’s exactly when the world caught up to him.
Why the HBO Series Changed the Conversation
Pedro Pascal brought a different energy to Joel than Troy Baker did in the games. While Baker’s Joel felt like a brick wall that slowly grew moss, Pascal’s Joel felt like a man who was constantly on the verge of a panic attack.
The show leaned heavily into Joel’s physical failings. He’s deaf in one ear. His knees hurt. He gets scared. This version of The Last of Us Joel made the character feel even more grounded. It reminded us that he isn't a superhero; he’s an aging man who is terrified that he’s failing the one person he cares about. The show also gave us more context regarding his relationship with his brother, Tommy, highlighting the "nightmares" Joel had about failing Ellie. It made his eventual choice at the hospital feel even more inevitable.
Addressing the "Joel Was Right" Debate
You'll see this on every Reddit thread and Twitter (X) argument: "Joel did nothing wrong."
Did he, though?
- The Pro-Joel Argument: The Fireflies were incompetent. They didn't even ask Ellie’s permission. There was no guarantee a vaccine would even work, let alone be distributed in a world run by hunters and cannibals. Why should a 14-year-old die for a world that’s already gone to hell?
- The Anti-Joel Argument: He took away the one thing that gave Ellie’s life meaning. He killed the only people left who had the scientific infrastructure to actually fix things. He lied to his best friend for years. He acted out of his own fear of loss, not out of what was best for Ellie.
The truth is that both sides are right. That’s why the character works. Joel is a mirror. If you believe the individual is more important than the collective, you’re with Joel. If you believe in the "greater good," he’s the villain.
🔗 Read more: Catching the Blue Marlin in Animal Crossing: Why This Giant Fish Is So Hard to Find
Surviving Like Joel: What We Can Actually Learn
While we don't live in a world with clicking monsters (yet), Joel’s character offers some pretty harsh, practical insights into human nature and resilience.
First, your past doesn't disappear just because you found a new hobby. Joel tried to be a carpenter in Jackson, but he was still the guy from the hospital. If you have "unresolved business," it’s going to find you. You have to own your choices, even the ones you made while in survival mode.
Second, communication is literally life or death. The rift between Joel and Ellie in Part II exists entirely because of a lie. If Joel had been honest—if he had treated Ellie like an adult who could handle the truth—things might have ended differently. Probably not much better, but differently.
Finally, vulnerability is a choice. Joel spent 20 years being "safe" by being alone. The moment he let Ellie in, he became happy, but he also became a target. It’s a trade-off we all make in our relationships. Is the risk of heartbreak (or a golf club) worth the reward of connection? Joel clearly thought so.
Real-World Takeaways for Fans
If you’re looking to dive deeper into the lore or just appreciate the craft behind the character, there are a few things you should actually do.
- Play the Left Behind DLC: If you only played the main game, you're missing half of the context for why Joel’s protection of Ellie is so significant. Seeing what she lost before she met him makes his "theft" of her choice even more tragic.
- Listen to The Last of Us Podcast: The official podcast features Neil Druckmann, Troy Baker, and Ashley Johnson. They break down the specific intent behind Joel’s most controversial lines. It’s a goldmine for understanding the why behind the what.
- Watch the "Grounding" Documentary: It shows the motion capture process. Seeing Troy Baker perform the ranch house scene in a gray suit with balls stuck to it—and still making you cry—is a testament to how much of Joel's character comes from the actor's physical performance.
Joel Miller is a reminder that in the end, we aren't defined by our intentions. We’re defined by what we do for the people we love. Even if what we do is objectively terrible. Especially then.
To really grasp the impact of The Last of Us Joel, look at the way the industry changed after 2013. We stopped wanting "perfect" heroes. We started wanting fathers who fail, survivors who lie, and characters who make us feel a little bit gross for rooting for them. That is Joel's real legacy. He made gaming grow up by showing us that sometimes, the "hero" is just a man who refuses to lose his daughter twice.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Playthrough:
- Pay attention to Joel's posture in the "Jackson" prologue vs. the "Summer" chapter; notice how his physical language changes as he warms up to Ellie.
- Note the environmental storytelling in Joel's house—the books on the shelves and the photos—to see the man he was trying to become before the events of the second game.
- Try to find every optional conversation; these are where Joel's most human (and often funniest) traits are hidden, providing a much-needed contrast to his brutal combat animations.