Hollywood loves a meta-narrative, but sometimes reality outpaces the script. When Netflix announced that Joel McHale would play a young Chevy Chase in the 2018 biopic A Futile and Stupid Gesture, the internet didn't just double-take. It collectively gasped. This wasn't just a casting choice; it was a cosmic joke with years of tension baked into the punchline.
You see, the two actors had spent four seasons together on the cult-hit sitcom Community. It wasn't exactly a buddy-comedy behind the camera. By the time McHale stepped onto the set of David Wain’s film to portray the 1970s version of his former co-star, the two had a history of verbal sparring, physical altercations, and very public "agree to disagree" moments.
Honestly, the whole thing felt like a fever dream for fans of the show.
The Irony of the Casting
Casting Joel McHale as Chevy Chase was a stroke of genius, mostly because McHale was essentially hired for Community to fill the "tall, sarcastic, handsome guy" archetype that Chase himself pioneered in the 70s. In his autobiography, Thanks for the Money, McHale even pointed out that he was essentially playing the "Chevy Chase role" in the series.
It’s easy to imagine the friction. Chase, a comedy legend from the original Saturday Night Live era, and McHale, the quick-witted host of The Soup who was essentially the new face of snark.
David Wain, the director of A Futile and Stupid Gesture, has gone on record saying it wasn't just stunt casting. He genuinely believed McHale was the right actor for the job. But McHale was a bit more self-deprecating about the whole thing. He joked in interviews that he probably got the part because he was the same height as Chevy.
Height wasn't the only thing they shared. They shared a specific brand of deadpan delivery that defines their careers.
👉 See also: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
Preparation Meets Paranoia
Playing a living person is always a tightrope walk. Playing a living person you’ve actively feuded with? That’s a whole different animal. McHale was surprisingly diplomatic during the lead-up to the film's release. He didn't want the performance to be a "hit job" or a cruel caricature.
Instead, he went back to the source material. He watched hours of early SNL footage and rare tapes of Chase from his National Lampoon days. He wanted to capture the essence of a man who was, at the time, the most confident person in any room he entered.
"It was very odd at first," McHale admitted during a podcast appearance. He had to separate the man he knew—the one who reportedly hated the long hours of a TV set and occasionally used slurs—from the 1970s comedy icon who was friends with Doug Kenney.
To get the look right, McHale had to wear a series of wigs and, famously, a significant amount of fake chest hair. It was a transformation that leaned into the swagger of the "Weekend Update" era.
The Phone Call Nobody Wanted to Make
Before the cameras rolled, McHale did the unthinkable: he called Chevy Chase to tell him he was playing him.
Imagine that conversation for a second.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
According to McHale, Chase’s reaction was surprisingly chill, or at least as chill as Chevy gets. He reportedly laughed and expressed happiness that Doug Kenney, his best friend and the co-creator of National Lampoon, was finally getting a biopic. Chase and Kenney were inseparable during the 70s, and the film focuses heavily on their relationship.
But there’s a layer of complexity here. While they were filming Community, McHale and Chase had several legendary fallouts. McHale has openly admitted to dislocating Chevy Chase’s shoulder during a bit of "advanced horseplay" on set that got out of hand.
So, when McHale called to say, "Hey, I'm playing you in a movie," it wasn't just a courtesy call between actors. It was a check-in between two guys who had spent years pushing each other’s buttons.
A Performance of Nuance
In A Futile and Stupid Gesture, McHale doesn't actually get a massive amount of screen time. He’s a supporting player in the tragic story of Doug Kenney (played by Will Forte). However, every second he’s on screen, he nails the specific "Chevy" energy: that mixture of effortless charm and a slightly dangerous edge.
The film highlights Chase as an enabler for Kenney’s downward spiral into drug use. It’s a bit of a "villain" role, but one grounded in real friendship. Critics generally praised McHale for avoiding a cheap impression. He caught the way Chase stood, the way he looked at people like they were slightly less interesting than whatever he was thinking about, and that signature smirk.
Some fans felt it was the ultimate revenge. After years of dealing with Chase’s difficult behavior on the Community set, McHale literally stepped into his skin and owned his legacy.
🔗 Read more: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Why This Still Matters in 2026
As we look back, the Joel McHale as Chevy Chase era serves as a weird time capsule for comedy. It represents the passing of the torch—or perhaps the snatching of it.
The Community movie is finally a reality, and it’s no secret that Chevy Chase won't be involved. His character, Pierce Hawthorne, was killed off years ago, and the real-life bridge is essentially ash at this point. Recently, Chase went on Marc Maron's podcast and doubled down on his dislike for the show, saying it "wasn't funny enough" for him and that he didn't want to be "surrounded by those people."
McHale’s response? A simple: "The feeling’s mutual, bud."
There’s a strange beauty in the fact that McHale gave one of the most respectful portrayals of Chase’s early brilliance, even while their personal relationship was in tatters. It shows a level of professional maturity that people don't always give McHale credit for.
Actionable Takeaways for Comedy Fans
If you're fascinated by the messy history of these two, there are a few things you should actually do to see the full picture:
- Watch the "Advanced Documentary Filmmaking" episode of Community. This is the one that reportedly led to the final blowout that got Chase fired.
- Stream A Futile and Stupid Gesture on Netflix. Pay close attention to the scenes in Hawaii; they offer the most insight into the Kenney/Chase dynamic.
- Read "Thanks for the Money." McHale’s book is surprisingly honest about the physical altercations on set and how he handled the ego of a comedy legend.
- Listen to the Marc Maron "WTF" interview with Chevy Chase. It explains a lot about why the cast felt the way they did.
Ultimately, Joel McHale playing Chevy Chase wasn't just a movie role. It was a weird, meta-resolution to one of the most famous feuds in modern television. It proved that you can respect the art even when you can't stand the artist.