Look, the internet loves a good scandal. We've all seen the headlines that pop up every few years. You know the ones. They usually involve a grainy photo and a loud claim that Joe Simpson, the man who managed Jessica and Ashlee Simpson into superstardom, has finally "come out."
It’s been over a decade since the news of Joe and Tina Simpson’s divorce first hit the wire. That was back in 2012. Ever since then, the question "Is Joe Simpson gay?" has lived a weird, immortal life in the corners of gossip blogs and Twitter threads.
But if you’re looking for a definitive "yes" or a public coming-out party, you’re going to be waiting a long time.
The truth is a lot more nuanced than a tabloid splash. It’s a mix of denied reports, "unnamed sources," and a family that has circled the wagons to protect their own. Let’s actually look at the facts.
The Divorce That Started Everything
Back in October 2012, Tina Simpson filed for divorce after 34 years of marriage. That’s a lifetime. The court documents cited "discord or conflict of personalities." Pretty standard legal talk.
Then The National Enquirer dropped a bomb.
They claimed Joe had sat the family down and admitted he was gay. They even alleged he had a 21-year-old boyfriend named Bryce Chandler Hill.
Suddenly, everyone had an opinion.
The media frenzy was intense. You’ve gotta remember, this was the guy often called "Papa Joe." He was a former youth pastor. He was the architect of the "wholesome" Simpson brand. The irony wasn't lost on anyone.
What the Family Actually Said
Here is where the "official" story stands.
📖 Related: Pictures of Sharon Stone Nude: What Really Happened Behind the Lens
A representative for the Simpson family told People magazine at the time that the split was "amicable" and—this is the important part—"there is no third party involved." They explicitly called the rumors about Joe’s sexuality "completely false."
Joe himself didn't stay silent. He took to Twitter (now X) to call the reports "ridiculous" and "more mis-information in the news." He claimed the guy he was photographed with was just a modeling client.
He was transitioning into photography at the time. It made sense. Sorta.
Jessica Simpson eventually addressed it, too. In 2020, when she released her memoir Open Book, everyone expected the big reveal. It didn't happen. When asked about her father's sexuality during her press tour, she told Andy Cohen, "That’s not my story to tell."
That’s a heavy sentence. It’s not a denial, but it’s definitely not a confirmation. It’s a boundary.
Why the Rumors Won't Die
Honestly, the rumors persist because people love to project.
Joe changed after the divorce. He swapped the "dad" sweaters for high-fashion leather jackets. He started hanging out with a younger, male-heavy crowd in the fashion and modeling world. He bleached his hair.
To the public, this looked like a "late-in-life awakening." To Joe, it might have just been a mid-life crisis or a career pivot.
We also have to talk about the "modeling client" defense. Joe spent years photographing young male models. In the world of celebrity gossip, if a man over 50 is seen with a man in his 20s, the internet assumes the worst (or best, depending on the site).
✨ Don't miss: Jonathan Scott and Zooey Deschanel Baby: What's Really Going On With Their Family?
Understanding the "Expert" Perspective
As someone who has followed celebrity PR for years, this is a classic case of controlled ambiguity.
By not giving a flat "yes" or a continuous, aggressive "no" after the initial denial, the Simpson camp managed to move the conversation along. They shifted the focus to Joe’s health—he battled prostate cancer in 2016—and his relationship with his grandkids.
It’s a smart move. If Joe Simpson is gay, he clearly doesn't want to be a poster child for it. If he isn't, he’s realized that fighting every internet troll is a losing battle.
The Actionable Reality
So, where does that leave us?
- Verify the Source: If you see a headline today saying "Joe Simpson Confirms He’s Gay," check the date. These stories are often recycled "zombie" articles from 2012 or 2014.
- Respect the Boundary: Jessica’s stance is the most healthy one here. A parent’s private life belongs to them, regardless of how much of their life was spent in the spotlight.
- Look at the Work: Joe has largely moved away from management and into photography. His portfolio is public, and that’s how he chooses to define himself now.
In the end, Joe Simpson hasn't "come out" in any official capacity. The rumors remain exactly that: rumors. Whether he's living his truth privately or just living a life that people don't understand doesn't change the fact that he hasn't handed the public the confirmation they keep looking for.
👉 See also: Who Was Kelly Ripa Married To: The Truth About Her One and Only
Stop looking for the "smoking gun" in old paparazzi photos. Instead, pay attention to how the family supports him today. They’re closer than ever, and in the world of Hollywood, that's the only endorsement that actually matters.
Check the latest interviews from Jessica or Ashlee. You'll notice they talk about his strength and his role as a grandfather. That's the real story they want you to see.
Next Steps for Readers:
If you want to understand the Simpson family dynamic better, read Jessica Simpson's Open Book. It doesn't "out" her father, but it gives a very raw look at their relationship and the pressures of their early career that most people never saw. It provides the context that makes these rumors feel much less important.