It is 1980. Lorne Michaels is gone. The original cast of Saturday Night Live has vanished. What was once the coolest show on television is now a car wreck in slow motion. Critics are sharpening their knives. The ratings are in the basement. Most people think the show is dead.
And then, Joe Piscopo and Eddie Murphy happened.
Most modern fans think of Eddie Murphy as a solo phenomenon who descended from the heavens to single-handedly rescue the show. But history is a bit more complicated than that. In the early 80s, you didn't have Eddie without Joe. They were the "Twin Towers" of Studio 8H. They were the only two people kept after the infamous "Saturday Night Massacre" of the 1980-81 season.
Honestly, it’s a miracle they liked each other at all. You had Joe, the Jersey-born powerhouse with a jawline like a superhero and a disciplined, athletic approach to comedy. Then you had Eddie, a 19-year-old kid from Roosevelt, Long Island, who possessed a "reckless abandon" that terrified and thrilled the producers.
The Night the Axe Swung
By 1981, executive producer Jean Doumanian was out, and Dick Ebersol was in. He walked into a room of talented people—Gilbert Gottfried, Denny Dillon, Charles Rocket—and basically fired everyone. Everyone except Joe Piscopo and Eddie Murphy.
Joe likes to tell this story about how they were summoned into the office like they were in the military. They thought they were toast. Instead, Ebersol told them they were the only ones staying. Their reaction? They basically shrugged, said they had a stand-up gig to get to, and walked out.
🔗 Read more: Why Snow Tha Product Tour Dates Are Different Than Any Other Rap Show
That cockiness saved them. They weren't desperate. They were just funny.
Why Joe Piscopo and Eddie Murphy Worked (When Nothing Else Did)
On screen, their chemistry was electric because it felt organic. They weren't just two actors reading lines; they were two guys who spent all night riffing in their offices until they got "punchy."
Take "Solomon and Pudge."
This was Joe’s favorite sketch. It usually aired at 12:55 AM, the "death slot." They played two old guys in a neighborhood bar, bickering and reminiscing. It was slow. It was character-driven. It was the exact opposite of the high-energy "Buckwheat" or "Mr. Robinson" sketches that made Eddie a household name. Joe has often said that Solomon and Pudge embodied their real-life relationship more than anything else they did.
Then there was the "Ebony and Ivory" parody. Joe’s Frank Sinatra was legendary—smooth, boorish, and surprisingly accurate. Eddie’s Stevie Wonder was equally iconic. Seeing them together wasn't just a sketch; it was a transition of power.
The Fame Gap and the Rumors
By 1982, the dynamic shifted. 48 Hrs. came out. Suddenly, Eddie Murphy wasn't just a cast member; he was the biggest movie star on the planet.
People love a good rivalry story. For years, the narrative was that Joe was jealous of Eddie’s meteoric rise. It makes sense on paper, right? You’re the veteran, the "utility player," and this kid comes in and steals the sun.
But if you listen to Joe talk today, there’s zero bitterness. He describes watching Eddie become "Elvis" right in front of his eyes. He saw the security teams grow, the cameras multiply, and the world change for his friend. Joe has spent decades dispelling the rumors of a rift. When Eddie won the Mark Twain Prize for American Humor in 2015, Joe was right there. He wasn't just an attendee; he was one of the people Eddie wanted there, alongside guys like Chris Rock and Dave Chappelle.
The "Eddie Murphy Show" Myth
There’s an infamous moment in SNL history where Nick Nolte backed out of hosting at the last second. Eddie Murphy stepped in to host while still being a cast member.
Imagine the ego trip that could have been.
👉 See also: The Gremlin from The Twilight Zone: Why That 20,000 Foot Nightmare Still Works
A lot of books and articles claim this caused a massive blow-up backstage. Joe says they’re all wrong. According to him, Eddie didn't do it to show off; he did it because they were in a bind. "He saved our ass that week," Joe said in a Reddit AMA. They were like roommates cramming for a final. They were in the trenches together.
What Most People Get Wrong About the 80s Era
People forget that SNL was almost cancelled three times during their tenure.
Without Joe's reliability and Eddie's supernova talent, the show wouldn't have made it to the Lorne Michaels "renaissance" of 1985. They were the bridge. They proved that the "brand" of SNL could survive a total cast turnover.
- The Utility Factor: Joe could play anyone. He was the athlete, the singer, the straight man.
- The X-Factor: Eddie had the charisma that forced people to keep the TV on.
- The Bond: They actually liked each other. You can't fake that 12:55 AM energy.
How to Appreciate Their Legacy Today
If you want to see what real comedic chemistry looks like, stop watching the highlight reels of just Eddie. Go back and watch the full episodes from 1981 to 1984.
Watch "Just a Nickel."
✨ Don't miss: Wake Me Up Before You Go-Go: Why This Wham\! Hit Still Rules the Radio
It was Eddie’s last sketch as a regular cast member. They play two old men on a park bench talking about how things used to cost a nickel. They’re trolling each other. They’re breaking character. They’re laughing. It’s a beautiful, messy, human moment between two guys who knew they were at the end of an era.
Joe and Eddie didn't just survive the 80s; they defined them.
Actionable Insights for Comedy Historians and Fans:
- Watch the "Death Slot" Sketches: Search for "Solomon and Pudge" on Peacock or YouTube. These sketches show a side of Eddie Murphy’s acting—and Joe Piscopo’s range—that gets overshadowed by the bigger characters.
- Read "Live From New York": If you want the "official" oral history, this book by Tom Shales and James Andrew Miller is the gold standard, though you should take the gossip with a grain of salt, as Joe often does.
- Follow the Sinatra Connection: Joe’s Sinatra wasn't just a parody; it was a tribute that Frank himself eventually acknowledged. It’s a masterclass in how to do an impression without being mean-spirited.
- Check out the 1982 "Ebony and Ivory" clip: It remains one of the most culturally significant parodies in the show's history, perfectly capturing the tension and humor of the early 80s.