Hollywood loves a "type." Usually, that looks like two genetically blessed twenty-somethings holding hands on a red carpet while promoting a shared streaming project. But then you have the outliers. The ones that make you double-take. The relationship between Joe Pesci and Angie Everhart was exactly that—a fascinating, eight-year-long enigma that defied the usual Tinseltown logic.
She was the 5'10" redhead who dominated Sports Illustrated covers and sashayed down runways for Thierry Mugler. He was the 5'4" Academy Award winner famous for playing hair-trigger mobsters and a burglar who couldn't outsmart an eight-year-old. On paper? It’s a sitcom premise. In reality, it was one of the most enduring, low-profile relationships of the 2000s.
People still talk about them. Why? Because it felt real in a way most celebrity "showmances" don't.
The Eight-Year Slow Burn
Most people don't realize how long they actually lasted. We aren't talking about a summer fling or a weekend in Vegas. They started dating around 2000 and stayed together until 2008. Think about that for a second. That’s an eternity by industry standards.
While Joe Pesci was largely "retired" from acting during this era—focusing on his music and his golf game—Everhart was still very much in the mix. They weren't constant tabloid fixtures. You wouldn't see them calling the paps for a "candid" stroll on the beach. Instead, they were the couple you’d spot at Ago in West Hollywood, Joe smoking a cigar and Angie laughing at something he said.
✨ Don't miss: The Billy Bob Tattoo: What Angelina Jolie Taught Us About Inking Your Ex
That Famous Engagement Rumor
By 2007, the "Will they or won't they?" chatter reached a fever pitch. Reports swirled that Joe had finally popped the question. Major outlets like the San Francisco Chronicle even ran headlines announcing their upcoming nuptials.
But here is where it gets weird.
If you ask the internet, they were engaged. If you look at Wikipedia, it says they were engaged. But if you listen to Angie Everhart herself in recent years, she tells a different story. In a 2024 interview with TooFab, she flat-out denied it. "I was not engaged to Joe," she said.
Was there a ring? Maybe. Was it a formal proposal? Maybe not. It’s possible the media ran with a "fiancée" label because they’d been together so long it just seemed like the next logical step. Or perhaps, in the private world of Joe Pesci, labels didn't matter as much as the company.
🔗 Read more: Birth Date of Pope Francis: Why Dec 17 Still Matters for the Church
Why They Actually Worked (and Why They Didn't)
Opposites attract. It’s a cliché because it’s often true.
Angie has always been vocal about what she likes: smart, funny men. If you’ve ever seen a Joe Pesci interview, you know the guy is sharp as a razor. He’s not just the "funny guy" from Goodfellas; he’s a student of the game, a jazz musician, and someone who doesn't suffer fools.
- The Height Difference: It was the first thing everyone noticed. She towered over him, especially in heels. They didn't care. There’s something inherently confident about a man who stands five-foot-four and dates a supermodel without standing on a milk crate for photos.
- The "Goodfella" Shield: Joe is notoriously private. Angie, having survived the high-octane dating world of the 90s (including a brief engagement to Sylvester Stallone), seemed to appreciate the protection of Pesci’s low-key lifestyle.
- The Turning Point: 2008 was the end of the road. No giant scandal broke them up. No "cheating in the Hamptons" headlines. They just... stopped.
Interestingly, just months after the split was confirmed, Angie gave birth to her son, Kayden Bobby Everhart. The father was an ex-boyfriend, Chad Stansbury. This timing suggests that the final year of the Joe Pesci and Angie Everhart era was likely a period of "on-again, off-again" flux.
Life After the Split
They stayed friends. Honestly, that’s the most "non-Hollywood" part of the whole thing.
💡 You might also like: Kanye West Black Head Mask: Why Ye Stopped Showing His Face
When Angie went through a messy legal situation with an ex-boyfriend in late 2008, paparazzi caught her and Joe leaving a restaurant together. He was there for her. When Joe’s ex-wife, Claudia Haro, was involved in a shocking legal trial involving a hitman, Joe was the one showing up to court, staying loyal to the people in his inner circle.
Angie still speaks incredibly highly of him. In that same 2024 reflection, she called him "awesome" and "so much fun to be around." She noted that while he and Stallone were both Italian, they couldn't be more different.
What We Can Learn From Them
The fascination with Joe Pesci and Angie Everhart usually starts with a joke about their physical appearance, but it ends with a lesson in celebrity survival.
- Privacy is Power: They didn't let the public into their living room, which is why their relationship lasted eight years instead of eight months.
- Compatibility Trumps Optics: If you only date people who "look good" next to you on Instagram, you're going to have a boring life.
- Endings Don't Have to Be Ugly: You can spend nearly a decade with someone and still think they're "awesome" twenty years later.
If you’re looking for a deep dive into the glamour of the 2000s, look at the photos of them at the 2002 Race to Erase MS gala. They look happy. They look like they're in on a joke that the rest of us aren't quite getting. That’s the real legacy of this pairing—it wasn't about the "supermodel and the movie star." It was just two people who liked each other's company in a town where that is the rarest thing of all.
To better understand the career paths that led them together, you might want to look into Joe Pesci's brief musical career or Angie Everhart's transition from runway to 90s cult cinema. Both had lives far more complex than their "typecast" roles suggested.