When you hear "Joe Montana Score 91," your brain probably does a quick double-take. Are we talking about a passer rating? A video game stat? Or that specific piece of cardboard sitting in a shoebox in your parents' attic?
Honestly, it's usually the latter.
The 1991 Score Joe Montana card is a weirdly iconic piece of hobby history. It isn't his rookie card—that's the 1981 Topps #194, for those keeping track—but it represents a very specific, high-tension moment in NFL history. It was the year Joe Cool was basically the undisputed king of the world, right before the wheels started to wobble in San Francisco.
Why the 1991 Score Joe Montana #1 Matters
In 1991, Score was trying to be the "premium" alternative to the dusty, gray-bordered cards of the past. They gave Joe Montana the #1 spot in the set. You've got to remember the context here. Montana had just come off back-to-back MVP seasons in 1989 and 1990.
He was at the peak of his powers.
💡 You might also like: What's the score of the 49ers? Everything from the Seahawks Playoff Battle to the 2026 Season Outlook
The card itself—1991 Score #1—features Montana in that classic red 49ers jersey, scanning the field with that "I'm about to ruin your Sunday" look in his eyes. It’s a clean card. No crazy gimmicks. Just the GOAT doing GOAT things.
The Value Reality Check
Let's get real about the money. If you find this card in a junk bin, it’s worth about $1. Maybe $2 if the person buying it is feeling nostalgic.
But collectors get confused because they see "Score 91" and think it’s a grade. It's not. It's the year. However, if you have a PSA 10 (Gem Mint) version of this card, the price jumps. Not into "buy a new car" territory, but certainly enough for a very nice dinner.
- Ungraded/Raw: $0.50 – $2.00
- PSA 9 (Mint): $15 – $25
- PSA 10 (Gem Mint): $35 – $100+ depending on the day
Why the gap? Because 1991 was the height of the "Junk Wax Era." Companies printed millions of these things. Finding one that survived 35 years without a soft corner or a surface scratch is actually harder than it sounds.
👉 See also: Courtney Jackson Arkansas State: The Speedster Who Proved Everyone Wrong
The 91 Connection: More Than Just a Card
There is another reason people search for "Joe Montana Score 91."
1991 was the year Joe Montana Football hit the Sega Genesis. It was supposed to be the "Madden killer." It wasn't, but it was close. If you played it, you remember the digitized voice yelling "I'm open!" and the fact that Montana’s stats in the game were basically "cheat code" levels.
Then there’s the weight. Did you know Joe Montana weighed roughly 91 kg (around 200 lbs) during his playing days? For a guy who took hits from Lawrence Taylor and Reggie White, he wasn't exactly a giant. He won with his brain and his feet, not by being a tank.
The Turning Point of '91
While the cards and games were celebrating him, the actual year 1991 was kind of a nightmare for Joe. He missed the entire 1991 season due to a torn tendon in his elbow.
It was the beginning of the end for his time in San Francisco.
While Joe sat on the sidelines, Steve Young took the reins. The "Score 91" era represents the final moment of the 49ers being "Joe's Team" without any "ifs," "ands," or "buts." By the time he came back, the world had moved on, eventually leading to his trade to the Kansas City Chiefs in 1993.
Identifying Your Joe Montana Score 91 Card
If you're looking at a stack of cards and trying to figure out what you have, look for these markers:
- The Number: The most common "Score 91" is #1. There is also a "Team MVP" card (#620) from the same year.
- The Border: The 1991 Score set has a very distinct, multi-colored border that looks sort of like a 90s windbreaker.
- The Back: It should have a full stat block. By '91, Joe's stat block was already longer than most players' entire careers.
What to Do With Your Joe Montana Items
If you’ve got a 1991 Score Joe Montana, don't quit your day job just yet. But don't throw it away either.
First, check the corners. If they aren't sharp enough to draw blood, it’s probably not worth grading.
Second, look for the "Scorecard" parallel. These are much rarer and have a holographic-style finish. Those actually carry some weight with serious collectors.
Third, if you have the autographed version—Score actually inserted 2,500 signed cards into packs back then—get that thing into a protective case immediately. A certified 1991 Score Montana auto is a legitimate four-figure item.
Essentially, "Joe Montana Score 91" is a snapshot of an era. It was the peak of sports card mania and the tail end of a legendary dynasty. Whether it’s a card in a plastic sleeve or a memory of a pixelated quarterback on a CRT television, it’s a piece of sports history that still holds a weirdly specific grip on fans today.
👉 See also: Herschel Walker Rookie Card: Why It's Still One of the Most Confusing (and Valuable) Items in the Hobby
Actionable Next Steps
Check the back of your card for the number. If it's #1, look at the surface under a bright light for any "dimples" or scratches. If it looks flawless, it might be worth the $20-25 fee to get it graded by PSA or SGC, especially if you plan on selling it to a 49ers completionist. If it's got wear and tear, keep it as a cool memento of the era when Joe Cool ruled the NFL.