Ask any Phillies fan over the age of forty about 1993, and you’ll see a specific look cross their face. It’s a mix of nostalgia for the "Macho Row" era and a sudden, sharp pain in the chest. That’s because the Phillies Blue Jays World Series didn’t just end; it exploded. It was a collision of two completely different baseball philosophies. You had the Toronto Blue Jays, the sophisticated, back-to-back champions in waiting with a lineup full of Hall of Fame talent. Then you had the Philadelphia Phillies, a group of mulleted, dirt-stained outcasts who looked like they’d arrived at the ballpark in a fleet of pickup trucks.
People forget how weird that series actually was. It wasn't just the Joe Carter home run. It was the 15-14 score in Game 4. It was the freezing rain at Veterans Stadium. It was a series that felt like a heavyweight fight where neither guy bothered to block a punch.
Why the 1993 World Series Was Pure Chaos
If you look back at the box scores, the sheer offense is staggering. Modern baseball fans complain about a lack of action, but the Phillies Blue Jays World Series was the antidote to that. Game 4 remains the highest-scoring game in World Series history. Think about that for a second. Fifteen to fourteen. In a championship game. On a wet, miserable night in South Philly, the Phillies blew a five-run lead in the eighth inning.
Todd Hundley once said that the Vet was a "dump," but it was our dump. That night, it felt like the apocalypse.
The Blue Jays were basically an All-Star team. Rickey Henderson was leading off. Paul Molitor was hitting behind him. Roberto Alomar was in his absolute prime. These aren't just names; they are three of the greatest players to ever pick up a bat. Toronto had a payroll that reflected their ambition, and they played a crisp, professional brand of ball.
On the other side, Philadelphia was led by Darren Daulton and John Kruk. Kruk famously told a reporter, "I ain't an athlete, lady, I'm a baseball player." That summed up the '93 Phils. They led the league in walks and grit. They didn't care if they looked pretty; they just wanted to outlast you.
The Pitching Nightmare
Let’s talk about the arms. Or the lack thereof.
📖 Related: NFL Football Teams in Order: Why Most Fans Get the Hierarchy Wrong
Curt Schilling was the ace for Philadelphia, and he was brilliant in Game 5, throwing a complete-game shutout to keep the Phillies alive. It was a masterpiece. But outside of Schilling, the Phillies' staff was hanging on by a thread. Terry Mulholland and Danny Jackson were solid, but the bullpen was a high-wire act every single night.
Mitch "The Wild Thing" Williams was the closer. He walked people. He fell off the mound. He threw 98 mph with zero idea where it was going. It was exhilarating and terrifying. On the Toronto side, they had Dave Stewart, a big-game hunter who already had a World Series MVP under his belt from his time with Oakland. The mismatch on paper was glaring, yet the Phillies kept hanging around.
The Moment Everything Changed: Game 6
Toronto was up 3-2 in the series as it shifted back to the SkyDome. For most of Game 6, it looked like the Phillies were going to force a Game 7. They were up 6-5 in the bottom of the ninth.
Mitch Williams came in to close it out.
He walked Rickey Henderson. Of course he did. You can't walk Rickey. Then, after a flyout, Paul Molitor singled. That brought up Joe Carter.
"Touch 'em all, Joe!"
Joe Carter wasn't the best hitter on that Blue Jays team. Molitor and Alomar were probably more "dangerous" in a traditional sense. But Carter had power. Williams got ahead in the count, then tried to sneak a slide-step fastball/slider hybrid past him. He didn't get it down and in. He left it up.
👉 See also: Why Your 1 Arm Pull Up Progression Isn't Working (And How to Fix It)
When Carter hit it, he didn't even know it was out. He started sprinting. It was only when he saw the ball clear the left-field fence that he started that iconic jumping, skipping trip around the bases.
Tom Cheek’s radio call—"Touch 'em all, Joe! You'll never hit a bigger home run in your life!"—is burned into the psyche of every Canadian sports fan. For Philadelphia, it was the sound of a heart breaking in real-time. It was only the second time a World Series ended on a walk-off home run while the hitting team was trailing. The first was Bill Mazeroski in 1960.
The Aftermath and the Legacy of the Phillies Blue Jays World Series
The fallout for Mitch Williams was brutal. He received death threats. He had to sell his house. It was one of the first times we saw the ugly side of sports fandom in the modern media era. Honestly, it was unfair. The Phillies wouldn't have even been there without him saving 43 games that year.
Toronto became a dynasty of sorts, the first team to repeat since the '77-'78 Yankees. But they also became a "what if" story. After 1993, the MLB strike happened. The Blue Jays’ momentum vanished. They wouldn't make the playoffs again for 22 years.
Philadelphia went back into the cellar. That 1993 team was a fluke in the best possible way. They were a collection of veterans having career years at the exact same time. Once the magic wore off, the team aged rapidly.
Why It Still Matters in 2026
We look back at the Phillies Blue Jays World Series because it represented the end of an era. It was the last World Series played before the 1994 strike changed baseball forever. It was played on AstroTurf—both stadiums had that rock-hard green carpet that destroyed players' knees. It was the last gasp of 80s-style baseball played in the 90s.
✨ Don't miss: El Salvador partido de hoy: Why La Selecta is at a Critical Turning Point
Also, it's a reminder that talent usually wins, but "vibe" keeps it close. The Phillies had no business being in that series against a juggernaut Toronto lineup, yet they were one pitch away from a Game 7.
Lessons for Modern Fans
If you're looking for a takeaway from this specific slice of baseball history, it’s about the volatility of the bullpen. The Phillies’ reliance on a high-stress closer eventually caught up to them. Today, managers use "closers by committee" or high-leverage specialists to avoid exactly what happened to Mitch Williams.
Toronto’s win also solidified the importance of the trade deadline. They traded for Rickey Henderson in July of '93. He scored the winning run in Game 6. Without that trade, maybe the Phillies win. Small moves change history.
What to Do Next
If you want to really understand the gravity of this series, don't just watch the highlights of the Carter home run. Go find the full broadcast of Game 4 on YouTube. Watch the 15-14 slugfest. Look at the way the pitchers were left out to dry and the way the hitters dominated the strike zone.
- Watch the "Last 9 Innings" documentary on the 1993 Phillies. It gives context to the personalities that made that team so beloved.
- Compare the roster builds. Look at how Toronto built through big-ticket acquisitions versus Philly’s bargain-bin hunting.
- Check out the 1993 stat lines. Look at John Kruk’s .430 on-base percentage. It’s a masterclass in hitting.
The Phillies Blue Jays World Series remains a singular moment in baseball. It was ugly, it was beautiful, and for those of us who watched it, it was unforgettable. It taught us that in baseball, you can do everything right for 161 games, but the 162nd—and the ones that follow in October—don't care about your story. They only care about where the ball lands.