Politics is a game of inches, but sometimes it feels like a game of accidental grenades. One minute the news cycle is laser-focused on a controversial comedian at a Madison Square Garden rally, and the next, everyone is arguing over an apostrophe. Honestly, if you were offline for even six hours in late October 2024, you probably missed the exact moment the phrase "garbage" took over the national conversation. It wasn't just a stray remark; it became a full-blown crisis for the Harris-Biden campaign just days before the election.
So, let’s get into it. What was the Joe Biden garbage comment, and why did it make everyone—from MAGA supporters to the White House stenography office—lose their minds?
The Spark: A "Floating Island" in New York
You can't understand what Biden said without knowing why he was talking in the first place. On October 27, 2024, Donald Trump held a massive rally at Madison Square Garden. One of the opening acts was Tony Hinchcliffe, a roast comedian known for his edgy, often abrasive style. During his set, Hinchcliffe made a joke that landed like a lead balloon for many: "There's literally a floating island of garbage in the middle of the ocean right now. I think it's called Puerto Rico."
The backlash was instant. Republicans and Democrats alike condemned the remark. For the Harris campaign, this was a political gift. They spent the next 48 hours hammering the Trump team for being out of touch and disrespectful to the Latino community. Then came the Zoom call.
The Viral Moment: "The Only Garbage I See..."
On Tuesday, October 29, President Biden joined a virtual "get-out-the-vote" call with the advocacy group Voto Latino. He was clearly trying to defend Puerto Ricans and push back against Hinchcliffe’s rhetoric. But as often happened during his presidency, the delivery got a bit... messy.
Here is what people heard (and what the video clip appeared to show):
💡 You might also like: Why the 2013 Moore Oklahoma Tornado Changed Everything We Knew About Survival
"The only garbage I see floating out there is his supporters—his—his demonization of Latinos is unconscionable, and it's un-American."
Wait. Did the President of the United States just call half the country garbage?
The clip went nuclear. Within minutes, Senator Marco Rubio was announcing the quote on stage at a Trump rally in Pennsylvania. Trump supporters were outraged. It felt like a sequel to Hillary Clinton’s 2016 "basket of deplorables" comment—a moment that many political analysts believe helped cost her the election.
The White House Response and the "Apostrophe" War
The White House press office immediately went into damage control mode. They insisted that Biden wasn't calling the supporters garbage, but rather the supporter's (singular) hateful rhetoric. Basically, they argued he was talking about Tony Hinchcliffe, not the millions of people voting for Trump.
This is where things got weird.
📖 Related: Ethics in the News: What Most People Get Wrong
The official transcript released by the White House Press Office included a very specific edit. They added an apostrophe: "his supporter’s." This change was meant to narrow the target of the "garbage" label to the comedian. However, this didn't sit well with the actual White House stenographers—the career professionals whose entire job is to record exactly what the president says for the National Archives.
According to internal emails that later leaked to the Associated Press, the head of the stenography office called the Press Office’s edit a "breach of protocol." The stenographers had transcribed it as "supporters" (plural). The Press Office changed it anyway after "conferring with the president."
It was a total mess. Instead of the news cycle being about Trump’s rally, it was now about whether the White House was "scrubbing" the record to protect the president from a gaffe.
Why the Joe Biden Garbage Comment Actually Mattered
Context matters, but in a high-stakes election, perception is reality. Even if Biden meant to talk about the comedian, the phrasing was clumsy enough to give his opponents a massive opening.
- The Trump Counter-Move: Donald Trump, never one to let a PR opportunity go to waste, showed up in Wisconsin the very next day in a high-visibility orange safety vest. He climbed into a white garbage truck emblazoned with his logo and asked reporters, "How do you like my garbage truck?" It was a classic piece of political theater.
- Kamala Harris’s Dilemma: Vice President Harris had to spend her precious "closing argument" time distancing herself from her own boss. She told reporters on the tarmac, "I strongly disagree with any criticism of people based on who they vote for."
- The Base Factor: For many voters, it reinforced a feeling that the "elites" in Washington looked down on them. Whether it was "deplorables," "clinging to guns and religion," or "garbage," the narrative of a condescending establishment was easy to sell.
Misconceptions You Might Have Heard
There are a few things people get wrong about this whole saga. First, Biden did issue a clarification on X (formerly Twitter) almost immediately, saying his comment was directed at the "hateful rhetoric" of the comedian. He didn't double down.
👉 See also: When is the Next Hurricane Coming 2024: What Most People Get Wrong
Second, the "garbage" comment didn't happen in a vacuum. Just a week earlier, Trump had referred to the United States as a "garbage can for the world" when discussing illegal immigration. So, both sides were throwing the "G-word" around, but Biden’s version hit the voters directly, which is always more dangerous for a politician.
The Actual Impact
Did it change the outcome of the election? It’s hard to say. By late October, most people had already made up their minds. But it certainly energized the GOP base and sucked the oxygen out of the room for the Harris campaign during what should have been her strongest week. It turned a moment of Republican weakness (the Puerto Rico joke) into a defensive slog for the Democrats.
Actionable Takeaways: How to Read the News in a Gaffe Cycle
When a story like the Joe Biden garbage comment breaks, it moves fast. If you want to avoid getting caught in the spin, keep these things in mind:
- Check the Source Video: In this case, the audio was garbled. When a president mumbles, both sides will hear what they want to hear.
- Look for Transcript Discrepancies: The fact that the stenographers and the press office disagreed is a huge red flag. It tells you the White House knew the remark was a political disaster.
- Watch the Response: The "garbage truck" stunt was a textbook example of how to flip a negative headline.
Politics is often a battle of who can stay "on message" the longest. For one chaotic week in 2024, the message was literal trash, and neither side wanted to be the one left holding the bag.
To see how this fits into the broader 2024 campaign timeline, you can look up the "Madison Square Garden rally fallout" or the "White House stenographer transcript leak" for the nitty-gritty legal details on the Presidential Records Act.