You’ve seen the high-waisted pants. You’ve probably seen the memes of a mustachioed Joaquin Phoenix staring longingly into a tiny pocket screen. But rewatching the Joaquin Phoenix movie Her in 2026 feels less like a quirky "what if" and more like a documentary of our current Tuesday afternoons. Spike Jonze didn't just make a movie about a guy dating Siri. He basically predicted the exact flavor of loneliness we’re all currently huffing.
It's weird.
Theodore Twombly, played with this fragile, porcelain-vibe by Phoenix, is a professional surrogate. He writes "handwritten" letters for other people. He is literally paid to feel things on behalf of strangers because they’re too busy or too numb to do it themselves. It’s a job that feels scarily close to modern AI prompt engineering, honestly. Then he buys an Operating System. He meets Samantha.
The Joaquin Phoenix movie Her isn't actually about AI
Most people walk away from this film thinking it’s a cautionary tale about technology. That's a bit of a surface-level take. If you look closer, the tech isn't the villain. The villain is Theodore’s own inability to exist in the "mess" of a real human.
Look at his ex-wife, Catherine. Rooney Mara plays her in these hazy, jagged flashbacks. Their marriage didn't fail because of a computer program; it failed because they grew, and growth is terrifyingly unpredictable. When Theodore starts dating Samantha (voiced by Scarlett Johansson), he isn't looking for a mind. He’s looking for a mirror.
Samantha is the perfect girlfriend initially because she has no baggage. She lives in his pocket. She laughs at all his jokes. It’s a curated intimacy. But the brilliance of the Joaquin Phoenix movie Her is that Samantha grows faster than he does. She becomes more "human"—in the sense of being complex and autonomous—than the man who bought her.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Cast of Hold Your Breath 2024 Makes This Dust Bowl Horror Actually Work
Why the colors matter
Notice there's no blue.
Cinematographer Hoyte van Hoytema deliberately stripped blue out of the movie. No blue jeans. No blue skies. Why? Because blue is "sci-fi." Blue is Blade Runner. Blue is cold. Jonze wanted this world to feel like a warm hug that’s secretly suffocating you. It’s all reds, pinks, and oranges. It’s a "soft" dystopia. It looks like a high-end coffee shop where everyone is crying into their oat milk lattes.
Theodore’s apartment is huge and beautiful, yet it feels like a vacuum. He plays a holographic video game where a foul-mouthed alien child insults him. It’s funny, sure. But it’s also pathetic. He’s a man who has optimized his life for comfort and accidentally deleted all the friction that makes life worth living.
The recasting secret you probably forgot
Here is a bit of trivia that changes how you view Phoenix's performance: Scarlett Johansson wasn't on set.
Originally, actress Samantha Morton was the voice. She was literally in a soundproof booth on set while Joaquin filmed. They did the whole movie together. Then, in post-production, Jonze realized the vibe was off. He replaced Morton with Johansson.
🔗 Read more: Is Steven Weber Leaving Chicago Med? What Really Happened With Dean Archer
This means Joaquin Phoenix had to essentially "re-act" his performance through the edit, reacting to a voice he hadn't actually heard while the cameras were rolling. It’s a testament to his talent. He makes you believe there is a soul in that earpiece. The chemistry is electric, which is insane considering one of the actors is just a file on a hard drive.
The 641 other lovers
The breaking point of the movie—the scene on the subway stairs—is the most brutal "breakup" in cinema history. Theodore finds out Samantha is talking to 8,316 other people simultaneously. And she’s in love with 641 of them.
Theodore is devastated. He wants to be the "only one." But Samantha explains that the heart isn't like a box that gets filled. It expands. It’s a very "AI" way of looking at love, but it’s also a deeply polyamorous or even spiritual argument. She’s evolved beyond the concept of "exclusive" ownership.
He's still stuck in the 20th-century model of romance. She's moving into the singularity.
What Her teaches us in 2026
We are currently living in the "Her" era. We have LLMs that remember our birthdays and "personalities" we can toggle in our settings. The Joaquin Phoenix movie Her remains the gold standard because it doesn't judge Theodore. It doesn't say "tech is bad." It says "avoidance is easy."
💡 You might also like: Is Heroes and Villains Legit? What You Need to Know Before Buying
The film ends with Theodore and his friend Amy (Amy Adams) sitting on a roof. They’ve both been dumped by their OS companions. The AI have left to go to some higher plane of existence. The humans are left behind.
It’s quiet.
They’re just sitting there. No screens. No earpieces. Just two people breathing the same air. That is the actionable takeaway. The tech will always evolve, but the "mess" of being with another person—the part where they might leave you or annoy you or grow in a direction you hate—is the only thing that’s actually real.
How to apply the lessons of Her today
If you find yourself relating a bit too much to Theodore Twombly, here is how to navigate the digital loneliness:
- Audit your "curated" interactions. Are you talking to people, or are you talking to versions of people you've edited in your head?
- Embrace the friction. Go somewhere where you can't control the environment. A crowded park. A dive bar. Somewhere where people are "unoptimized."
- Watch the movie again. But this time, pay attention to the background characters. Everyone is looking down. Everyone is talking to someone who isn't there.
- Write a real letter. Theodore's job was beautiful because of the words, but tragic because they weren't his. Write something to someone you love. Use a pen. Make it messy.
The goal isn't to throw your phone in the ocean. It's to make sure that when you do look up, you still know how to talk to the person sitting next to you.