If you’ve driven down the Berlin Turnpike recently, you probably noticed the massive gap where a crafting empire once stood. It’s weird. For over 25 years, that specific Joann Fabrics Berlin Turnpike location was the north star for every quilter, cosplayer, and last-minute school project parent in central Connecticut.
Then, the doors stayed shut.
The 39,000-square-foot space at 3105 Berlin Tpke is currently a hollow shell of its former self. While the "Everything Must Go" signs are long gone, the story of why this specific Newington hub vanished tells us a lot about the state of retail in 2026. It wasn't just a "bad economy" thing. It was personal for the locals who spent decades wandering those aisles.
What Happened to the Joann Fabrics Berlin Turnpike?
Honestly, the closure of the Newington store was the beginning of a domino effect that wiped out nearly every Joann presence in Connecticut. The store officially locked its doors on May 24, 2025.
🔗 Read more: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
It felt sudden. One day you’re buying bias tape, and the next, there’s a 90% off liquidation sale that looks like a scene from a movie.
The parent company, Joann Inc., had been struggling for a while. They hit Chapter 11 bankruptcy twice in a span of about a year. While the first time in 2024 seemed like a "reorganization," the second hit in early 2025 was the nail in the coffin for the Berlin Turnpike spot. They were bleeding cash—about $26 million a month in rent across all locations—and the Newington lease was a monster.
Why This Location Mattered More Than Most
Berlin Turnpike isn't just a road; it’s a retail gauntlet.
💡 You might also like: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
The Joann store there was huge. We’re talking nearly 40,000 square feet of inventory. Because it was so big, it acted as a regional hub. If the smaller Joann in Southington or the one in Torrington didn't have that specific shade of Kona cotton, you went to Newington.
- The Vibe: It was nestled in a plaza that has seen better days. With other businesses in that same strip shuttering over the last five years, the "Joann's Plaza" (as locals often called it) started feeling lonely.
- The Community: This wasn't just a shop. It was where people took sewing classes and asked the staff—many of whom had worked there for a decade—how to fix a jammed bobbin.
- The Competition: Being right down the road from Walmart and Five Below meant high foot traffic, but it also meant Joann had to fight for every dollar against cheaper, lower-quality alternatives.
The Quality Scandal and the End of an Era
Toward the end, things got a bit... messy. If you spend any time on crafting forums, you probably heard about the "Happy Value" cotton controversy.
Around 2024 and 2025, Joann started stocking a super-cheap line of fabric. It was $2 a yard. Sounds great, right? Except people started reporting that it was essentially flammable garbage. There were stories of microwaveable potato bags catching fire because the fabric wasn't actually 100% cotton as labeled.
📖 Related: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
This loss of trust, combined with massive staffing shortages that left the Newington store with 15-person deep lines at the cutting counter, made the experience frustrating. People loved the store, but they hated the corporate decisions.
Where to Go Now for Your Crafting Fix
So, the Joann Fabrics Berlin Turnpike is gone. What do you do if you’re mid-quilt?
You've basically got three options in the 2026 landscape. First, there’s the "big box" pivot. Michael’s and Hobby Lobby are still standing, but their fabric selection is nowhere near what a massive Joann offered. Second, you can go the independent route. Local quilt shops in towns like Berlin and New Britain are seeing a bit of a resurgence because crafters are desperate for quality.
Lastly, there's the online gamble. Wawak is great for thread and notions, but buying fabric online is a nightmare if you need to feel the drape or match a specific color.
Actionable Next Steps for Displaced Crafters:
- Check Local Quilt Shops: Small boutiques often carry higher-quality "quilt shop quality" cottons that won't disintegrate in the wash.
- Inventory Your Stash: If you were a regular at the Berlin Turnpike store, you likely have a "stash." Now is the time to actually use it instead of hunting for new bolts.
- Monitor the Plaza: Keep an eye on the 3105 Berlin Tpke site. Developers in Newington are eyeing these large-scale vacancies for "experiential retail" or fitness centers, like the GF Fitness that took over the old LA Fitness nearby.
The loss of the Newington Joann is a bummer, but the crafting community in Connecticut is nothing if not resilient. You just have to drive a little further for your zippers now.