When people talk about John F. Kennedy’s love life, the name that usually pops up is Marilyn Monroe. It’s the flashy choice, right? The dress, the song, the Hollywood glam. But if you really want to understand the man who was sitting in the Oval Office during the Cuban Missile Crisis, you have to look past the starlets. You have to look at Mary Pinchot Meyer.
Mary wasn't a starlet. She was an artist, a divorcee, and a high-society rebel who lived just down the street in Georgetown. Honestly, her connection to JFK was probably the most intellectually intense relationship of his life. It wasn't just some casual fling. It was something that, quite frankly, scared the living daylights out of the CIA.
The Woman Who Wasn’t Just Another Conquest
Most of the women in JFK's orbit were treated like temporary distractions. He was a man of high appetites and a very short attention span. But Mary Meyer was different. They had known each other since they were teenagers. They met at a dance at Choate in 1938. She was the one who didn't just fall at his feet.
By the time their affair really kicked into high gear around 1962, Mary was a sophisticated abstract painter. She was also the ex-wife of Cord Meyer, a very high-level CIA official. Think about that for a second. The President of the United States was sleeping with the ex-wife of one of the most powerful men in the intelligence community. That is a recipe for disaster.
Why She Mattered More Than Marilyn
Mary didn't just bring romance to the White House; she brought ideas.
She was deeply into the "counterculture" before it was even called that. She was friends with Timothy Leary—yes, that Timothy Leary, the LSD guru.
According to Leary’s own memoirs, Mary came to him specifically to learn how to "guide" an acid trip. Why? Because she allegedly wanted to use psychedelics to help world leaders see past the Cold War.
📖 Related: Harry Enten Net Worth: What the CNN Data Whiz Actually Earns
Now, did she actually give JFK acid in the White House?
Some biographers, like Peter Janney in Mary’s Mosaic, say yes.
Others are way more skeptical.
But the mere fact that the CIA thought she might be influencing the President’s views on nuclear disarmament or rapprochement with Cuba was enough to put a giant target on her back.
The Murder on the Towpath
JFK was assassinated in November 1963.
Less than a year later, on October 12, 1964, Mary Meyer was out for her daily walk along the Chesapeake and Ohio Canal towpath in Georgetown. It was broad daylight.
She was shot twice—once in the head and once in the heart.
Execution style.
The police arrested a guy named Ray Crump Jr., a Black man found nearby. But the case was a mess. No gun was ever found. No forensic evidence linked him to the scene. His lawyer, the legendary Dovey Roundtree, tore the prosecution’s case to shreds. Crump was acquitted, and to this day, the murder is officially unsolved.
The Bizarre Mystery of the Diary
Here is where things get really "movie-script" weird.
Within hours of Mary’s death, her brother-in-law, Ben Bradlee (who later became the famous editor of The Washington Post), went to her studio to find her diary.
Who did he find already there, trying to pick the lock?
James Jesus Angleton. The Chief of Counterintelligence for the CIA.
👉 See also: Hank Siemers Married Life: What Most People Get Wrong
Angleton wasn't there for the art. He was there because Mary kept a record of her life. Bradlee and his wife eventually found the diary and, in a move that still baffles historians, they ended up handing it over to Angleton. He claimed he burned it. Then he claimed he didn't. Some say it was eventually destroyed by Mary’s family to "protect her reputation."
Whatever was in those pages, it was clearly explosive enough to make the most powerful spy in America personally break into a dead woman’s house.
Why We Still Talk About JFK and Mary Meyer
We love the "Camelot" myth because it feels perfect, but the story of Mary Meyer makes it human—and dark. It suggests that JFK was looking for something more than just a distraction. He was looking for a partner who challenged his worldview.
If you want to dig deeper into this, don't just stick to the tabloid stuff.
Look at the timing of Mary's death. It happened just weeks after the Warren Commission report was released.
Read Nina Burleigh’s biography, A Very Private Woman. It's probably the most balanced look at her life without leaning too hard into the wilder conspiracy theories.
✨ Don't miss: Gordon Ramsay Kids: What Most People Get Wrong About Raising Six Mini-Chefs
What You Can Do Next
If this era of history fascinates you, your next step is to look at the declassified documents regarding Operation Mockingbird. It explains the world Mary’s husband lived in—a world where the CIA actively influenced the American media. Understanding that context makes the disappearance of her diary and the silence of the press at the time make a lot more sense.
The truth about Mary Meyer might be buried in a burned diary or a dusty CIA file, but her influence on the man who navigated the 13 days of the Cuban Missile Crisis is a part of the JFK story that we can't just ignore anymore. Basically, she was the secret heart of a presidency that ended in blood, and her own end was just as tragic and twice as mysterious.
Actionable Insight: To get a real feel for Mary's world, visit the C&O Canal towpath in Georgetown if you're ever in D.C. Walking that path makes you realize how ballsy—and targeted—that hit really was. It wasn't a dark alley; it was a public stage.