The Dallas Cowboys are basically the world's longest-running reality show, and lately, the plot has been circling one question: is Mike McCarthy actually going anywhere? Honestly, if you've followed the team for more than five minutes, you know Jerry Jones loves to keep everyone guessing. But the latest noise out of Frisco is different. Even after a season that felt like a slow-motion car crash at times, Jerry Jones says he doesn't want to fire Mike McCarthy.
He’s serious.
Most owners would have cleaned house months ago. Not Jerry. He’s spent the better part of the last year doubling down on his "big picture" view of McCarthy, even when the fan base was ready to drive the coach to the airport themselves. It's a weird situation. We’re talking about a coach who delivered three straight 12-win seasons before the wheels fell off in 2024, largely due to a Dak Prescott injury and a roster that looked thinner than a training camp jersey.
Why Jerry Jones is Sticking With McCarthy (For Now)
Jerry doesn't like being told what to do. Especially by the media. During one of his now-infamous radio hits on 105.3 The Fan, he basically told the hosts it wasn't their job to question his coaching decisions. He’s been very vocal about his "regret" over firing coaches like Wade Phillips or Chan Gailey too early. He thinks those moves were impulsive.
In Jerry's mind, Mike McCarthy is still an "outstanding coach." He points to the Super Bowl ring from Green Bay. He points to the way players like Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb have flourished—at least statistically—under this system.
💡 You might also like: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
"I don't think that's crazy at all," Jones said when asked about potentially extending McCarthy rather than firing him. To Jerry, McCarthy isn't the problem; the circumstances are. He’s been protective of Mike, calling the idea that McCarthy "lost the locker room" total nonsense. He remembers a call from John Madden and Al Davis back in 1989 after a one-win season. They told him that as long as you don't lose the players' respect, you have a chance. Jerry believes McCarthy still has that respect.
The Contract Deadlock That Changed Everything
Here is where the story gets kinda messy.
By early 2025, everyone thought a deal was a sure thing. McCarthy wanted to stay. Jerry wanted him back. But then the actual negotiations started. Reports from insiders like Tom Pelissero and Jonathan Jones suggest the "breakup" wasn't actually a firing. It was a failure to agree on the future.
The sticking point? The length of the contract.
📖 Related: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
- Jerry wanted a short-term, "prove it" deal.
- McCarthy, at 61, wanted long-term security.
- Neither side would budge.
It’s a classic power struggle. Jerry wants the flexibility to pivot if things go south again, but McCarthy knows that being a "lame duck" coach makes it impossible to hire top-tier assistants or keep the locker room focused. When they couldn't find a middle ground, they decided to "head in a different direction."
The 2026 Comeback Trail
So, where does that leave us now in early 2026?
Mike McCarthy didn't coach in 2025. He took a page out of his old playbook—literally—and went back to his "coaching barn" to study film and analytics. He's currently positioning himself as one of the top candidates for the 2026 hiring cycle. He’s already been linked to a few openings, with teams looking for a "floor raiser" who can stabilize a franchise.
Meanwhile, Jerry Jones is still defending the era. Even after they parted ways, he’s been complimentary. He called McCarthy a "tremendous human being" and a "builder of programs."
👉 See also: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
But the Cowboys are still the Cowboys. The "all-in" mantra Jerry preached hasn't resulted in a Super Bowl parade. If the next regime struggles, you can bet Jerry will be on the radio talking about how much he valued Mike's 12-win consistency.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Drama
People think Jerry is just being stubborn. It’s deeper than that.
Jerry Jones views the Cowboys as a family business, and Mike McCarthy fit the family dynamic perfectly. He didn't push back on Jerry’s GM duties. He didn't complain about the roster construction in public. He took the hits for the front office. That’s a rare trait in a head coach, and it’s why Jerry fought so hard to keep him around until the contract math simply stopped making sense.
Actionable Insights for Cowboys Fans
If you're trying to make sense of the coaching carousel in Dallas, keep these three things in mind:
- Watch the "Coaching Barn" Narrative: McCarthy is going to use the same PR strategy he used after Green Bay. Expect to hear a lot about how he’s "reinvented" his offensive scheme for the 2026 season.
- Jerry’s Regret Factor: Jerry Jones is haunted by his past firings. He will always lean toward keeping a coach a year too long rather than a year too short. This affects every coaching search the Cowboys will ever have.
- The GM Problem: As long as Jerry remains the General Manager, the head coach is only half the battle. Any new coach coming in will have to deal with the same roster constraints that eventually frustrated McCarthy.
The McCarthy era ended not with a scream, but with a series of polite press releases and a disagreement over a two-year extension. It’s the most "Dallas Cowboys" ending possible. McCarthy is now waiting for his next shot in 2026, and Jerry is still looking for the man who can finally bring a trophy back to Arlington without requiring a long-term commitment.