If you’ve ever rostered Jerry Jeudy, you probably have some strong opinions. Most of them involve yelling at your television. He’s the ultimate "what if" player of our era. One week he looks like the route-running savant we saw at Alabama, and the next, he’s basically a cardio specialist running deep posts into oblivion.
Looking at jerry jeudy fantasy points from the 2024 and 2025 seasons tells a story of a guy trapped between "league-winner" volume and "roster-clogger" efficiency. Honestly, his 2024 season with the Cleveland Browns was a total fever dream. He cleared 1,200 yards. Seriously. He finished as the WR21 overall in standard leagues, which is wild considering how much people complained about him.
But here is the thing: the points don't come easy. They never do with Jeudy.
The 2024 Breakthrough and the Jameis Effect
In 2024, Jeudy finally did what we all waited five years for—he stayed healthy and saw massive volume. He ended the year with 144 targets. That is elite, top-tier usage. He turned that into 90 catches for 1,229 yards.
But if you look closer at those jerry jeudy fantasy points, the splits are hilarious. When Deshaun Watson was under center, Jeudy was barely a flex play. Then Jameis Winston took over.
Suddenly, Jeudy was a monster.
🔗 Read more: Saint Benedict's Prep Soccer: Why the Gray Bees Keep Winning Everything
There was a Week 13 game against his old team, the Denver Broncos, that still haunts some managers. He put up 31.5 fantasy points. He had 9 catches for 235 yards and a score. In those seven games with Winston, he was pacing for over 1,900 yards. It was arguably the greatest "I told you so" stretch in recent fantasy history.
A Brutal 2025 Regression
If 2024 was the peak, 2025 felt like a long, slow slide back down the mountain. The Browns' QB room became a revolving door again. We saw Joe Flacco, Kenny Pickett, and even some rookie looks.
The targets dropped from 144 down to 106.
The yards cratered from 1,229 to just 602.
He only found the end zone twice all year.
When you're chasing jerry jeudy fantasy points, you’re basically betting on the environment, not just the talent. In 2025, he finished as the WR61. That's the kind of performance that gets you dropped for a waiver wire tight end by Week 6.
What the Advanced Metrics Actually Tell Us
People love to say Jeudy can't catch. That’s a bit of a myth. His 2024 success rate was 54%, which was actually a career-high. The issue is more about where he catches the ball and what happens after.
💡 You might also like: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
- Air Yards: In 2024, he had 1,587 air yards. That was top-10 in the league.
- Target Share: He hovered around 20-25%. Solid, but not "Alpha WR1" territory.
- Red Zone Woes: This is the killer. In 2025, he only had a 16.7% red zone target share.
Basically, Jeudy is a "between the twenties" guy. He will get you those 12-yard outs all day. But when the field shrinks, his fantasy value evaporates. He has never scored more than six touchdowns in a single season. If you're waiting for a double-digit TD year, you're going to be waiting a long time.
Why His Value Varies So Much by League Type
If you’re in a Standard league, Jeudy is almost unstartable most weeks. He doesn’t score enough. But in Full PPR (Point Per Reception), he’s a different beast—at least he was in '24.
| Scoring Event | Impact on Jeudy's Value |
|---|---|
| Receptions | High. He’s a volume sponge when the QB is aggressive. |
| Yardage | High. He can break a long one, like his 89-yarder in 2024. |
| Touchdowns | Very Low. He’s allergic to the paint. |
In 2025, his weekly floor was terrifying. Look at Week 8 against the Patriots: 0.0 points. Two targets, zero catches. Then look at Week 10 against the Jets: 19.8 points. He’s a volatility engine. You start him when you’re a 20-point underdog and need a miracle. You bench him when you just need a safe 8 points.
The "Jeudy Truthers" vs. Reality
There is still a segment of the fantasy community that believes a truly elite QB would turn him into Stefon Diggs. Maybe. But we've seen him with a lot of different guys now. Bridewater, Lock, Wilson, Watson, Winston, Flacco.
The pattern is clear. Jeudy is a Tier 2 wideout who needs a high-volume passing offense to be relevant. He isn't a guy who creates his own luck. He's a route runner who needs the ball delivered on time and frequently.
📖 Related: Red Sox vs Yankees: What Most People Get Wrong About Baseball's Biggest Feud
When the Browns brought in Diontae Johnson in 2025, it squeezed Jeudy’s target share just enough to make him irrelevant. If he isn't the clear #1 or #1b, the jerry jeudy fantasy points just aren't there. He doesn't have the physical profile to win on "my ball" contested catches.
Actionable Strategy for the Next Draft
Don't pay for the 2024 name value. That 1,200-yard season was the outlier, not the new norm.
If you're looking at Jeudy in a draft, he's a WR4. You take him as a bench piece with upside. You absolutely do not count on him as your WR2.
- Check the QB: If the starter is a "check-down Charlie," fade Jeudy hard. If it's a "YOLO" thrower like Winston or a late-career Flacco, his ceiling rises.
- Watch the Slot Snaps: Jeudy is better when he’s moved around. In 2025, his slot rate was only about 13%. When he’s stuck on the outside against press coverage, he struggles more.
- Sell the Peaks: If he has a 100-yard game in Week 2, trade him immediately. Someone in your league will believe the breakout is finally here. It usually isn't.
Stop chasing the "talent" and start chasing the situation. Jerry Jeudy is a great real-life receiver who is a headache for fantasy. Treat him like a high-stakes lottery ticket, and you'll sleep much better on Sunday nights.