If you follow the Washington Commanders, you know Jeremy Reaves is basically the heart and soul of that locker room. He’s the guy who fought through years of practice squads to become an All-Pro. He's the guy who made us all cry when Ron Rivera told him he made the Pro Bowl, thinking of his late mother, Rose.
But late in 2024, the vibe shifted. Suddenly, the search terms weren't just about his bone-jarring special teams tackles. People started whispering about a jeremy reaves side piece and social media drama that threatened to overshadow one of the most romantic moments in Commanders history.
Honestly, it’s a classic case of how fast the internet can turn a "win" into a "wait, what?"
The Proposal and the "OnlyKiaaaaa" Allegations
On December 29, 2024, the Commanders beat the Falcons to clinch a playoff spot. It was electric. Right there on the turf of Northwest Stadium, Reaves dropped to one knee and proposed to his longtime girlfriend, Mikaela Worley.
Mikaela, a physician assistant from their hometown of Pensacola, said yes. The team's social media accounts posted the video. It was perfect. Until it wasn't.
Almost immediately, a social media user with the handle OnlyKiaaaaa reshared the NFL’s post. She didn't offer congratulations. Instead, she claimed Reaves had been in her DMs just months prior, allegedly trying to "fly her out."
The term jeremy reaves side piece started trending as people scrambled to figure out if there was any truth to the "receipts" or if this was just a clout-chasing attempt during a high-profile moment.
👉 See also: NY Giants vs Seahawks: What Really Happened at Lumen Field
Is There Any Proof?
When these things happen, fans usually go one of two ways. You have the "burn it all down" crowd and the "where is the evidence?" crowd.
In this case, the evidence remained... thin. While the user made the claim publicly, no actual screenshots of the alleged DMs were ever verified or widely circulated. In the world of NFL gossip, "he was in my DMs" is a common refrain that often disappears as quickly as it arrives.
Reaves himself didn't give it much oxygen. He focused on his fiancée and the upcoming playoffs. Mikaela didn't seem fazed either. They’ve been friends for over eight years and together for a significant chunk of that. She was the one who literally held him up when he tore his ACL in 2023. You don't throw away a decade of history for a tweet without some serious proof.
Why the Jeremy Reaves Side Piece Rumor Stuck
Why did people care so much? It's because Jeremy Reaves is the "good guy."
He’s the underdog. When you have a reputation for being the most wholesome, hardworking guy in the NFL, any hint of a jeremy reaves side piece feels like a personal betrayal to the fans. It’s the "Main Character" syndrome of sports—we want our heroes to be perfect.
There was also a bit of a "wrong place, wrong time" element. The proposal happened right after a massive win. The spotlight was at its absolute brightest. If you want to make a claim for attention, that is the exact window to do it.
✨ Don't miss: D. Wayne Lukas Auction: Why the Legend’s Dispersal Still Matters
A Quick Look at Reaves and Mikaela’s Timeline
- Hometown Roots: Both are from Pensacola, Florida. They attended Milton High School together.
- Long-Term Connection: They’ve been friends for 8+ years.
- The Injury Bond: Mikaela was his "crutch" (his words) during his 2023 ACL recovery.
- The Big Moment: Proposed December 29, 2024.
The Reality of Being an NFL Safety
Look, life in the NFL is messy. You’ve got money, fame, and a lot of people looking for a way in. Does that mean the jeremy reaves side piece rumors were true? Probably not.
Most veteran reporters and Commanders insiders treated the situation as a social media blip. In the age of 2026, where "clout" is a currency, high-profile athletes are constantly targets for unverified claims. Unless someone drops a screen-recorded video of a conversation, it's usually just noise.
Jeremy Reaves has built his career on integrity. He speaks often about the lessons his military parents taught him: "Treat all people with love and integrity." It’s hard to reconcile that man with the one being accused in a random tweet.
Navigating the Noise
If you're following this story, the best thing to do is look at the source. The "side piece" narrative relies entirely on a single social media post that lacked follow-up. Meanwhile, Reaves continues to show up for the Commanders and for Mikaela.
👉 See also: Why AP Top 25 Results Still Drive the College Basketball Hype Train
The couple is currently planning their wedding, and Reaves is coming off a 2025 season where he remained a defensive staple. If there was a real "side piece" controversy, it certainly hasn't broken the foundation of his actual relationship.
To get the real story on Jeremy Reaves, you’re better off watching his highlights or his mic'd up segments. The man’s life is an open book of grit and family values. The rest? It’s basically just off-season filler.
If you want to support Jeremy, keep an eye on his work with the "Salute to Service" initiatives. That’s where his heart actually is—not in some disputed DMs. Check the official Commanders roster updates for the latest on his 2026 season status.