If you were around in the mid-90s, you probably remember the sheer media saturation of the Alec Baldwin and Kim Basinger romance. It was everywhere. Their remake of The Getaway was supposed to be this massive, steaming-hot action noir that cemented them as the ultimate Hollywood power couple. Instead, the movie kinda tanked. Critics weren't kind, the box office was lukewarm, and Alec Baldwin later famously called the film "a bomb."
But honestly? If you revisit the 1994 version of The Getaway today, the leads aren't actually the most memorable part of the chaos. That honor goes to Michael Madsen and Jennifer Tilly. Specifically, the absolutely bizarre, dark, and deeply uncomfortable subplot involving their characters, Rudy Travis and Fran Carvey.
While Baldwin and Basinger were busy smoldering in the desert, Tilly was busy delivering a performance so polarizing that people are still arguing about it on Reddit threads thirty years later.
The Role Most People Forget
In the original 1972 Sam Peckinpah film, the role of Fran (the veterinarian's wife) was played by Sally Struthers. It was a secondary plot point—a hostage situation that turns into a strange case of Stockholm Syndrome. When Roger Donaldson took the reins for the '94 remake, he didn't just keep the subplot; he dialed the sleaze up to eleven.
Jennifer Tilly plays Fran Carvey, the wife of a mild-mannered veterinarian named Harold. Their lives are upended when an injured, sociopathic criminal named Rudy (Madsen) takes them hostage. What follows isn't just a kidnapping. It’s a psychological breakdown that ends with Fran essentially joining her captor and watching as her husband is systematically humiliated until he reaches a breaking point.
It’s a tough watch.
Tilly’s Fran isn't a typical victim. She’s written—and played—as someone who is almost pathologically bored. When the danger arrives, she doesn't just cower; she adapts in a way that feels genuinely disturbing. She brings that signature breathy voice and wide-eyed innocence, but she weaponizes it. It's a "honeypot" performance that makes you feel greasy just watching it.
✨ Don't miss: Why Everyone Is Still Talking About Wizards Beyond Waverly Place Season 2 Episode 6
Why Jennifer Tilly in The Getaway Was So Controversial
Most of the hate directed at the film back in the day focused on how "vile" the Rudy/Fran storyline felt. Even the late, great Roger Ebert was pretty vocal about his distaste for it. He called the movie "mean-spirited" and "nasty," specifically pointing out that Tilly’s character seemed to fall in love with her kidnapper the more sadistically he treated her.
Ebert’s take was that Tilly threw herself into the role with "an excess of zeal."
Is that a bad thing? Maybe not.
In a movie where the two main stars often feel like they’re posing for a perfume ad, Tilly and Madsen are actually acting. They are creating characters that provoke a visceral reaction. Sure, the reaction is "I want to look away from the screen," but in a neo-noir crime thriller, isn't that kind of the point?
Tilly has since talked about the experience of filming those scenes. On her first day on set, she was basically told, "Meet Michael Madsen, now take off your clothes." No rehearsal. No icebreaker. Just straight into the deep end of a very physical, very revealing role. She’s mentioned in interviews that she felt she should have lost weight before the nude scenes, but the directors told her she was fine. The result is a performance that feels raw and unpolished in a way that 90s studio movies rarely allowed.
Breaking Down the "Cuckold" Subplot
We have to talk about the veterinarian, Harold. Played by James Stephens, Harold is the moral compass that gets absolutely shattered. The dynamic between Rudy, Fran, and Harold is what gives the 1994 Getaway its "sleaze-noir" reputation.
Rudy doesn't just take them along for the ride; he makes Harold watch as he seduces Fran. It’s a power move. And Fran? She goes along with it. There’s a scene involving a kitten (which, fun fact, had its role expanded because it was so photogenic on set) where they’re all in a hotel room, and the tension is just thick.
Eventually, Harold can’t take the humiliation of being "cuckolded" by a madman while his wife giggles in the next room. He takes his own life in a hotel bathroom.
This is where the movie loses a lot of people. It’s a grim, depressing turn in what is otherwise a high-octane heist movie. But for Tilly fans, this is peak "90s Jennifer." She manages to play Fran as someone who is both a victim of circumstance and a willing participant in her own moral decay. It’s a level of nuance that the script probably didn't even intend.
🔗 Read more: Angus & Julia Stone Songs: What Most People Get Wrong About the Sibling Duo
The "Press Pause" Legacy
Let’s be real for a second. A huge reason Jennifer Tilly The Getaway is a frequent search term isn't just because of the acting. It was the 90s. The film was marketed heavily on its sexuality.
The "unrated" cut of the film became a staple of the "press pause" era of home video. It featured more nudity from both Basinger and Tilly than the theatrical version. For a lot of young viewers in 1994, this was their introduction to Jennifer Tilly before she became an Oscar nominee for Bullets Over Broadway later that same year.
It’s a weird bit of timing. In a single year, she went from playing a "road slut" (as some harsh Reddit reviews call her) in a box-office bomb to being an Academy Award-nominated actress for Woody Allen. That speaks volumes about her range. She can do the "dim-witted moll" routine, but she adds a layer of intelligence and self-awareness that makes the character stick in your brain.
Is It Actually a Good Movie?
If you're looking for a faithful adaptation of the Jim Thompson novel, neither movie quite gets it right (the book’s ending is way darker and involves literal cannibals). But if you want a snapshot of 90s excess, the 1994 Getaway is a fascinating relic.
It’s got:
- Alec Baldwin at his most "movie star."
- Philip Seymour Hoffman in a very early, very sweaty supporting role.
- James Woods being James Woods.
- Michael Madsen at his peak "terrifying guy who might cut your ear off" energy.
And then there’s Tilly. She’s the wild card. Without her and Madsen, the movie would just be a boring, stylish chase. They provide the "ick factor" that keeps the film grounded in the grimy reality of the crime genre.
Final Verdict for the Modern Viewer
If you’re a fan of Jennifer Tilly’s later work—like her iconic turn as Tiffany in Bride of Chucky or her voice work as Bonnie on Family Guy—watching her in The Getaway is a trip. It’s a reminder that she’s always been willing to take risks on characters that aren't necessarily "likable."
Fran Carvey is not a hero. She’s not even a particularly good person by the end of the film. But she is interesting.
The movie is currently a cult favorite for people who miss the era of "erotic thrillers" that didn't feel like they were scrubbed clean by a corporate committee. It’s messy, it’s violent, and it’s occasionally very uncomfortable.
Actionable Next Steps
If you're planning to revisit this 90s classic, keep these things in mind:
- Seek out the Unrated Cut: If you want the full experience Roger Donaldson intended, the theatrical version feels a bit choppy. The unrated version restores the pacing (and the intensity) of the Rudy/Fran subplot.
- Watch it as a Double Feature: Watch the 1972 Steve McQueen version first. It’s a better "movie," but the 1994 version is a better "90s experience." Comparing Sally Struthers' Fran to Jennifer Tilly’s Fran is a masterclass in how different eras viewed female "villainy" in noir.
- Pay Attention to the Score: Mark Isham’s bluesy, saxophone-heavy soundtrack is quintessential 90s noir. It sets a mood that the script sometimes fails to reach.
Jennifer Tilly's career has been long and varied, but The Getaway remains one of her most visceral performances. It’s the kind of role that modern Hollywood is often too scared to write—a woman who finds her power in the middle of a nightmare, even if that power is used for all the wrong reasons.