Honestly, if you’re looking at Jennifer Lopez engagement rings, you aren't just looking at jewelry. You’re looking at a literal timeline of pop culture history and the evolution of the diamond market over three decades. People love to joke about how many times she’s been engaged, but let’s get real—most of us would trade places for just one of those stones.
Six rings. That’s the count. From the relatively "modest" $100,000 diamond from Ojani Noa to the eye-watering $5 million green diamond from Ben Affleck’s second proposal, the sheer scale of this collection is hard to wrap your head around. It’s estimated to be worth north of $17 million total.
But here’s the thing: everyone focuses on the price tags. What’s more interesting is how JLo basically single-handedly changed what people want in an engagement ring. Before her, everyone wanted a clear, white diamond. After her? The world went crazy for color.
The Pink Diamond That Changed Everything
Back in 2002, the world was obsessed with "Bennifer." When Ben Affleck first proposed, he didn’t go the traditional route. He went to Harry Winston and picked out a 6.1-carat radiant-cut pink diamond.
At the time, pink diamonds were mostly for serious collectors. They weren't "mainstream." But then JLo did an interview with Diane Sawyer, showed off that rosy sparkler, and suddenly every bride-to-be was asking for colored stones. It was worth about $2.5 million back then. If you tried to buy that same stone today? You’d be looking at a much higher price because the Argyle mine in Australia, where most pink diamonds came from, has since closed.
Interestingly, Barbra Streisand once approached Jennifer at a party just to ask to see the ring. Even the legends were starstruck by that rock.
💡 You might also like: Finding the Perfect Donny Osmond Birthday Card: What Fans Often Get Wrong
That Rare Blue Beauty from Marc Anthony
After the first breakup with Ben, JLo moved on with Marc Anthony. He clearly felt the pressure to top the pink diamond. His choice? An 8.5-carat blue diamond, also from Harry Winston.
Blue diamonds are exceptionally rare. Like, "one in a million" rare. This one was a radiant cut, set in platinum with trapezoid side stones. Experts at the time valued it around $4 million, though some estimates now push it closer to $6.5 million. It’s arguably the most sophisticated ring she’s ever owned. It wasn’t just big; it was a museum-quality gem.
The 15-Carat "Ice Skating Rink" from Alex Rodriguez
By the time A-Rod came along in 2019, the trend had shifted toward "the bigger, the better." He proposed on a beach in the Bahamas with a massive emerald-cut diamond.
Depending on who you ask, this stone was anywhere from 12 to 20 carats. Most appraisers settled on 15 carats. It’s a "hall of mirrors" cut—very clear, very architectural. It cost at least $1 million, though if it’s an internally flawless D-color stone (which, let’s be honest, it probably is), it’s easily $5 million.
It was huge. It was blinding. It was also very different from her previous colored stones, signaling a return to classic, icy white glamour.
📖 Related: Martha Stewart Young Modeling: What Most People Get Wrong
The Lucky Green Diamond (Bennifer 2.0)
When Ben Affleck returned for round two in 2022, he knew he had to do something personal. Jennifer has famously said that green is her lucky color. She’s worn it at some of her biggest moments (remember that Versace dress?).
Ben found an 8.5-carat natural green diamond.
Natural green diamonds are even rarer than pink or blue ones. Their color comes from exposure to radiation deep in the earth over millions of years. This ring was estimated to cost between $5 million and $10 million. Inside the band, Ben had "not. going. anywhere." engraved.
Even though they filed for divorce in 2024, reports indicate Jennifer is keeping the ring. And honestly? Good for her. You don’t just give back a green diamond like that.
A Quick Look Back: Where It All Started
Before the multi-million dollar stones, there were the "starter" rings.
👉 See also: Ethan Slater and Frankie Grande: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
- Ojani Noa (1997): A $100,000 marquise-cut diamond on a gold band. Very 90s.
- Cris Judd (2001): An emerald-cut diamond, also on a gold band, rumored to be worth in the low six figures.
It’s wild to see the progression. She went from a $100k marquise to a $10 million green diamond. It’s a visual representation of her becoming a global mogul.
Why These Rings Matter for Your Own Search
You might not have $5 million to drop on a green diamond (if you do, call me), but JLo's collection offers some real-world "insider" tips for anyone looking at engagement rings:
- Color adds value and personality: If you want something that stands out, look at "fancy" colors. Even sapphires or morganite can give you that "JLo pink" look without the $2 million price tag.
- The "Radiant" and "Emerald" cuts are king: Jennifer clearly prefers rectangular, step-cut or radiant-cut stones. These cuts show off the clarity of a diamond. If you get a high-quality stone, these shapes make it look incredibly expensive.
- Metals matter: Notice how she transitioned from yellow gold in the 90s to platinum and white gold for her most expensive pieces. White metals make high-quality diamonds look whiter and brighter.
- Engravings are everything: A 15-carat diamond is a rock, but an engraving like "not. going. anywhere." makes it a story.
If you're inspired by the Jennifer Lopez engagement rings saga, the best move is to look at your "lucky" elements. Maybe it’s not a $10 million green diamond, but choosing a stone or an engraving that actually means something to you—rather than just following a trend—is what makes a ring iconic.
Start by looking into "fancy" cuts like the radiant or emerald if you want that celebrity presence on your hand. Just make sure you prioritize clarity for those shapes, as they don't hide inclusions as well as a round brilliant cut does.
Next steps for your jewelry search:
Check the GIA (Gemological Institute of America) reports if you’re looking at colored stones. Natural color is vastly more expensive than "treated" color, and you want to know exactly what you're paying for before you sign any paperwork.