Let's be real for a second. Walking into a theater to see Jenna Ortega in a movie titled Miller’s Girl, you probably expected something either very "Wednesday-coded" or a standard, run-of-the-mill psychological thriller. What we actually got was a Southern Gothic fever dream that left half the audience screaming at their screens and the other half scratching their heads in the lobby.
It’s been a bit since it dropped, but the discourse hasn't really died down. If anything, the controversy surrounding the Jenna Ortega Miller's Girl era has only matured into a deeper conversation about power, "perfect victims," and why we’re so uncomfortable when a young woman on screen isn't just a passive prize or a helpless target.
The Story Nobody Actually Prepared For
Cairo Sweet isn't your average high school senior. She lives alone in a massive Tennessee mansion while her lawyer parents are off being rich and absent. She's brilliant—like, "reads the entire syllabus before the first bell rings" brilliant. When she walks into Jonathan Miller’s (Martin Freeman) creative writing class, she doesn't just want an A. She wants a legacy.
The core of the movie centers on a "creative odyssey" gone wrong. Miller, a failed novelist who hasn't written a word since he got married, becomes instantly obsessed with Cairo’s intellect. It’s not just about her looks; it’s about her mind. He sees her as a protege, a peer, and eventually, a muse. But here’s where the lines get blurry.
Cairo’s best friend, Winnie, basically dares her to seduce Miller to get something "real" to write about for her Yale admission essay. What follows is a slow-burn disaster. There’s a rain-soaked kiss, a deeply graphic short story that Cairo submits as an assignment, and a fallout that ruins lives.
✨ Don't miss: Cómo salvar a tu favorito: La verdad sobre la votación de La Casa de los Famosos Colombia
The 31-Year Age Gap: Why It Matters (And Why It Doesn't)
You couldn't go five minutes on X (formerly Twitter) without seeing someone lose their mind over the age gap. Martin Freeman is 52. Jenna Ortega was 21 during filming, playing 18. That 31-year difference is wide.
Honestly, that’s the point.
Freeman himself defended the film, telling The Times that the movie is "grown-up and nuanced" and not exactly a "rah-rah" for student-teacher flings. He compared it to playing a villain or being in a movie about the Holocaust—just because you're depicting something terrible doesn't mean you're endorsing it.
The film's intimacy coordinator, Kristina Arjona, made it clear that Jenna was "very determined and very sure" of what she wanted to do on set. There were modesty barriers, constant check-ins, and a lot of professional distance. But for the audience, that discomfort is a feature, not a bug. If you weren't squirming when Miller masturbates while reading Cairo's "smutty" assignment, the movie wouldn't be doing its job.
🔗 Read more: Cliff Richard and The Young Ones: The Weirdest Bromance in TV History Explained
What People Get Wrong About Cairo Sweet
Most critics slammed the film for being "shallow" or "hollow," but they often missed the subtext of Cairo’s agency. Is she a victim? Technically, yes—the power dynamic is always skewed toward the adult teacher. But Cairo doesn't want to be a victim.
She wants to be a villain.
Writer/director Jade Halley Bartlett has been vocal about this. In early drafts, Cairo was written as a straight-up antagonist. After the MeToo movement, the script shifted to acknowledge the reality of grooming, but the "villainous" spark remained. Ortega plays her with this ancient, almost vampiric quality.
When Miller eventually rejects her—calling her story "unacceptable"—it’s not because he’s taking the moral high ground. It’s because he’s a coward. He can’t handle the reality of what he’s engaged in. Cairo’s revenge isn't just a temper tantrum; it’s a calculated strike. She hands the story to the vice principal not because she’s hurt, but because she wants to "win."
💡 You might also like: Christopher McDonald in Lemonade Mouth: Why This Villain Still Works
The Ending: "My Greatest Achievement to Date"
The final scene is where everything clicks—or falls apart, depending on your vibe. Miller is suspended, his marriage is in shreds, and his reputation is toast. Cairo, meanwhile, is heading to Yale.
She calls his downfall her "greatest achievement."
It’s a bleak, cynical ending. Usually, these movies end with the teacher going to jail and the girl finding healing, or the girl being exposed as a "crazy" temptress. Miller's Girl refuses both. It gives us two people who are both "ghosts" in their own lives, clinging to each other to feel something—anything—even if it’s destructive.
Actionable Takeaways for Your Next Rewatch
If you’re planning to dive back into the Jenna Ortega Miller's Girl rabbit hole, keep these things in mind to see the film in a new light:
- Watch the Mirroring: Notice how Cairo begins to adopt Miller's own writing style. By the end, she isn't just his student; she has effectively "consumed" his identity to build her own.
- Ignore the "Erotic Thriller" Tag: Marketing sold this as a sexy romp. It isn't. It’s a Southern Gothic tragedy. If you approach it like a horror movie where the "monster" is a toxic power dynamic, it makes way more sense.
- Focus on the Wife: Beatrice (played by Dagmara Domińczyk) is the only one speaking the truth. Her disdain for her husband’s weakness is the moral compass of the film, even if she’s "unlikeable."
- Evaluate the "Writing": The dialogue is intentionally flowery and pretentious. They are two people who think they are in a literary masterpiece, while everyone around them sees a sad, creepy mess.
Ultimately, the movie didn't set the box office on fire—it made roughly $1.8 million worldwide—but it cemented Ortega as an actress willing to take massive, "uncomfortable" risks. She isn't interested in being the "Disney girl" anymore, and Cairo Sweet was the loudest possible way to say that.
Whether you love it or hate it, the film forces a conversation about the "perfect victim" that most Hollywood movies are too scared to have. It’s messy, it’s loud, and it’s definitely not going to make you feel good. But then again, as Jenna said herself, art isn't always meant to be pleasant.