You've heard the phrase a thousand times. Maybe a coworker is "total Jekyll and Hyde" because they’re a peach in the morning and a monster by 3 PM. Or perhaps you’ve seen it on a dating app profile. But honestly? Most people have the actual story backwards.
We tend to think of it as a "split personality" thing where a good guy is haunted by a bad guy. In reality, Robert Louis Stevenson’s 1886 novella, The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, is way darker than that. It’s not about a man who is two different people. It’s about a man who is one person and chooses to let the worst version of himself out of the cage.
The Gist of the Story (No Spoilers, Sorta)
Basically, we follow a very stiff, very "correct" lawyer named Gabriel Utterson. He’s worried about his friend, Dr. Henry Jekyll. Jekyll is a brilliant scientist, a pillar of the community, and—for some reason—is hanging out with a "troglodytic" little creep named Edward Hyde.
Hyde is pure malice. He tramples a kid in the street. He beats an old man to death with a cane just because he can.
The twist that everyone knows by now (but was a genuine shocker in 1886) is that they are the same guy. Jekyll didn’t "catch" Hyde like a cold. He brewed a tincture in his lab to separate his "good" side from his "evil" side. He wanted to indulge in his weirdest, darkest vices without ruining his reputation.
It worked. At first.
👉 See also: Who Voiced Who? The Franklin the Turtle Cast Through the Years
But soon, the transformations started happening without the drug. Jekyll would go to sleep as the doctor and wake up as the murderer.
The Real Inspiration: A Cabinet Maker and a Murderer
Stevenson didn't just pull this out of thin air. He was a sick man—constantly battling tuberculosis—and supposedly wrote the first draft in a three-day, cocaine-fueled fever dream. His wife, Fanny, thought the first version was too much of a "shocker" and not enough of an allegory, so he burned it and wrote the whole thing again.
But the real-life "Jekyll" was a guy named Deacon Brodie.
📖 Related: Are You Gonna Be My Girl: Why That One Riff Still Rules Every Bar and Wedding 20 Years Later
Brodie was an Edinburgh city councilor and a master cabinet maker. He was rich. He was respected. He even had the keys to the city's finest homes because he installed their locks.
At night? He used those keys to rob them.
Brodie had two mistresses, five kids no one knew about, and a gambling debt that could sink a ship. He was eventually hanged on a gallows he had helped design. Talk about irony. Stevenson actually grew up with a bookcase in his room made by Brodie. Imagine looking at your furniture and wondering if the guy who made it was secretly a thief.
Why We’re Still Obsessed With It
Why does this story still rank? Because we all have a "Hyde."
In the Victorian era, everything was about repression. You had to look perfect, talk perfect, and hide any "impure" thoughts. Stevenson was calling out the hypocrisy.
The Psychology of the Split
- The Id vs. The Superego: Freud would have had a field day with this. Jekyll is the Superego—the moral compass. Hyde is the Id—the primal, "I want it now" part of the brain.
- The Shadow Self: Carl Jung talked about the "Shadow," the parts of ourselves we reject. If you don't acknowledge your shadow, it doesn't go away. It just grows teeth.
- Addiction: Many modern readers see the potion as a metaphor for substance abuse. Jekyll thinks he can control the drug. Eventually, the drug controls him.
Common Misconceptions (The "Actually" Section)
- Hyde isn't a giant monster. In the movies, he's often a hulking brute. In the book, he’s actually smaller and younger than Jekyll. Why? Because Jekyll’s evil side hadn't been "exercised" as much as his good side. He was stunted.
- It’s not "Jackal and Hyde." Despite what your voice-to-text thinks, it's Jekyll. (Rhymes with "heckle," though Stevenson actually wanted it pronounced "Gee-kill").
- Jekyll isn't the victim. He’s the one who wanted the freedom to be bad. He’s a "composite" of both, but he’s the one who opened the door.
How to Spot a "Jekyll and Hyde" Situation Today
If you’re dealing with someone who seems to have a totally different persona depending on who is watching, you’re looking at the modern equivalent.
- The "Public" vs. "Private" Persona: Watch how they treat people who can’t do anything for them (waitstaff, etc.) versus how they treat their boss.
- The Social Media Mask: We all curate a "Jekyll" version of our lives online while our "Hyde" (the messy, angry, unfiltered side) stays hidden—or comes out in anonymous comments.
Actionable Takeaway: Don't Be a Jekyll
The lesson of the book isn't "don't drink weird green chemicals." It's that you can't split yourself in two.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Running with Scissors Memoir Still Makes People Uncomfortable Twenty Years Later
If you try to be 100% perfect all the time, your "Hyde" will eventually come out in toxic ways. Real mental health—and real character—comes from integration. Own your dark moods. Admit your mistakes. Don't try to brew a "potion" (or a lie) that lets you pretend you're something you're not.
Read the original novella if you haven't. It’s short, it’s creepy, and it’s way more relevant to our "filter-obsessed" culture than you might think.