Hollywood is weird. One day you’re swinging a barbed-wire baseball bat at a camera in Georgia, and the next, you’re elbow-deep in alpaca manure in upstate New York. That’s the reality for Jeffrey Dean Morgan. While most A-listers retreat to gated mansions in Beverly Hills or sleek penthouses in Manhattan, the man best known as Negan chose a radically different path. He traded the red carpet for a 100-acre working farm in Rhinebeck, New York.
It’s called Mischief Farm.
If you think this is just some "hobby farm" where a celebrity pays people to do the dirty work while they sip wine, you're dead wrong. This place is loud, smelly, and chaotic. It’s a legitimate, dirt-under-the-fingernails operation that Morgan shares with his wife, actress Hilarie Burton Morgan, and their two kids, Gus and George.
The Real Story Behind the Jeffrey Dean Morgan Farm
The move wasn’t exactly planned as a grand lifestyle statement. It started with a cabin. Back when they first had their son, Gus, they realized the frantic pace of Los Angeles was kind of sucking the soul out of them. They wanted space. They wanted a place where their kids could grow up without being hounded by the industry.
They eventually upgraded from that small cabin to the sprawling acreage now known as Mischief Farm. It’s located in the Hudson Valley, specifically in the quaint town of Rhinebeck. The name "Mischief Farm" isn't just a cute branding exercise, either. It reflects the personality of the place—unpredictable, a little wild, and definitely not corporate.
📖 Related: Bunnie XO: How Old Is Jelly Roll's Wife Really?
Why Rhinebeck?
Rhinebeck isn't your typical celebrity enclave. It’s a town that values privacy and community over status. When the Morgans moved in, they didn't just hide behind a fence. They actually joined the community. You might see Jeffrey Dean Morgan at the local hardware store or Hilarie Burton Morgan volunteering at a town event.
The Animals of Mischief Farm (It’s a Zoo, Basically)
The Jeffrey Dean Morgan farm is home to a literal menagerie. This isn't just a few horses and a dog. We’re talking about a diverse crew of animals that often have more personality than the humans.
- Jack and Diane: Perhaps the most famous residents. Jack is a donkey and Diane is an emu. They are famously in love. Seriously. They were rescued together from a farm in North Carolina where they had bonded, and the Morgans refused to let them be separated.
- The Alpaca Crew: They have a herd of alpacas, including one named Alexander Hamilton. Fun fact: Alpacas use a "communal dung pile," which Jeffrey has noted makes for incredible fertilizer.
- Cows, Ducks, and Chickens: It’s a working farm, so there’s constant maintenance. Jeffrey has talked about the "dead of winter" laying seasons and the daily chores of feeding and mucking out stalls.
Honestly, the farm sounds exhausting. Jeffrey has described his "morning commute" as walking out to the barn in the freezing cold. It’s a far cry from a climate-controlled trailer on a movie set.
Saving Samuel’s Sweet Shop
You can’t talk about the Jeffrey Dean Morgan farm without mentioning the candy store. It’s a huge part of their life in Rhinebeck.
In 2014, the owner of a local staple called Samuel’s of Rhinebeck, Ira Gutner, passed away suddenly. Ira was the first person Jeffrey met when he moved to town. To prevent the shop from closing or becoming a generic chain, Jeffrey and Hilarie teamed up with their friend Paul Rudd (yes, Ant-Man) and his wife Julie to buy it.
They renamed it Samuel’s Sweet Shop.
They don’t just own it on paper. They are active partners. If you visit, you’ll see photos of them, but you might also see them behind the counter. They’ve even sold farm-grown products and "Mischief Farm" branded coffee (created with Brooklyn Roasting Company) through the shop.
Living the "Rural Diaries" Lifestyle
Hilarie Burton Morgan actually wrote a book about this whole transition called The Rural Diaries. It’s not a glossy celebrity memoir. It’s a gritty, honest look at how hard it is to actually run a farm.
She writes about:
- The learning curve: Learning how to chop wood and build chicken coops from scratch.
- The community: How they found a sense of belonging that Hollywood never gave them.
- The reality of loss: Dealing with the death of livestock and the harsh winters of the Hudson Valley.
The book really highlights that they chose lifestyle over career. While they still act—Jeffrey is still a massive part of the Walking Dead universe and recently joined The Boys—the farm is the anchor. Everything else is just a job that funds the hay and the vet bills.
Misconceptions About the Celebrity Farmer Life
People often assume celebrity farms are just backdrop for Instagram photos. While the Morgans do post beautiful shots of the Hudson Valley mist, the reality is much more "blue collar."
Jeffrey has been very vocal about the fact that they live in a rural, working-class community. They don't want to talk about "the biz" with their neighbors. They want to talk about the weather, the crops, and who’s got the best tractor parts.
✨ Don't miss: Robert De Niro Height: What Most People Get Wrong
The Financial Reality
Running a 100-acre farm isn't a money-making venture for most people. It’s a money-pit. The Morgans have used their platform to launch "MF Libations," a spirits brand that ties back to their farm identity. This kind of diversification is how they make the "mischief" sustainable.
How to Experience a Bit of Mischief Yourself
If you’re a fan and find yourself in the Hudson Valley, don't go looking for the farm. It’s their private home, and they value that peace. However, you can definitely get the vibe by visiting the town they love.
- Visit Samuel’s Sweet Shop: Located at 42 East Market Street in Rhinebeck. Try the "Clodhoppers"—Paul Rudd’s favorite.
- Support Local: The Morgans are big on local agriculture. Visit the Rhinebeck Farmers Market to see the kind of community they are protecting.
- Read the Book: If you want the deep dive into how they built the fences and survived the first few years, The Rural Diaries is the definitive source.
The Jeffrey Dean Morgan farm represents something a lot of people are craving right now: a return to something real. It’s about mending fences, both literal and metaphorical. It’s messy, it’s expensive, and it’s clearly the best thing that ever happened to them.
Actionable Insights for the Aspiring Ruralist
If the story of Mischief Farm makes you want to pack your bags and buy a goat, keep these realities in mind:
- Start Small: The Morgans started with a cabin and a few acres before jumping into a 100-acre operation. Don't buy the "big farm" until you know you can handle the "small barn."
- Community is Everything: You can't survive in a rural area without your neighbors. Be the person who helps, not just the person who moved in from the city.
- Prepare for "Un-glamour": Farming is 90% cleaning up things you'd rather not touch. If you can't handle the smell of a communal dung pile, stick to the suburbs.