When we talk about a Jeffree Star ex boyfriend, the name that immediately floods everyone’s mind is Nathan Schwandt. For five years, they were the "it" couple of the beauty world. It’s kinda wild to look back at the 2015-2020 era of YouTube. You couldn't scroll through a feed without seeing them in a neon pink Lamborghini or inside a literal "Hidden Hills" vault. But when the glitter settled, the reality was a lot more complicated than a 17-minute apology video could ever show.
Honestly, the fascination with Jeffree’s dating life isn’t just about the drama. It’s about the shift from a very public, seemingly untouchable relationship to a series of chaotic, short-lived flings and "NFL boo" trolls.
The Nathan Schwandt Era: More Than Just a "Wifey"
Nathan wasn't just another guy in a video. He was the backbone of the Jeffree Star Cosmetics empire during its biggest growth spurt. When they met, Jeffree wasn't the billionaire-adjacent mogul he is now. He was a former Myspace star trying to make a makeup line work. Nathan met him when he had "nothing," or at least, a lot less than the $14 million mansion they eventually shared.
Why did they break up?
It wasn't one single thing. Jeffree eventually sat down in front of a camera—no makeup, looking genuinely exhausted—to tell his fans that they had split in early 2020. He cited the weight of the spotlight. Nathan, a guy from Michigan who supposedly never wanted to be famous, was being torn apart by the internet. People accused him of being "gay for pay" or staying just for the perks.
✨ Don't miss: Melania Trump Wedding Photos: What Most People Get Wrong
Then there was the tragedy. They lost their dogs, including Daddy Star, and Jeffree admitted they never actually took the time to grieve. They were too busy being "Jeffree and Nathan" for the cameras. By the time 2020 rolled around, the relationship was a shell of itself.
The Andre Marhold Debacle
After Nathan, things got messy. Fast.
In August 2020, Jeffree posted a photo straddling a mystery man. The internet, being the unpaid FBI it is, identified him within hours by his tattoos. Enter Andre Marhold, a professional basketball player.
This wasn't the "wholesome" vibe fans were used to with Nathan. It was pure chaos. Marhold’s ex-girlfriend, a woman named Lauren, went on a scorched-earth Twitter spree. She claimed Andre had left his family to be with Jeffree and accused Jeffree of literally "buying" him.
🔗 Read more: Erika Kirk Married Before: What Really Happened With the Rumors
Jeffree, never one to stay quiet, hit back. He claimed he doesn't "give money to anyone" he's dating. But the "vibe," as Andre later called it in an interview with Hollywood Unlocked, didn't last. By the end of the year, it was over, with Jeffree even hinting at a robbery, though details remained murky and mostly lived in the land of Instagram Story rants.
The "NFL Boo" and the Art of Trolling
Fast forward to 2023. Jeffree started teasing a new man again. He dubbed him his "NFL boo." He posted photos of a 6’6” man’s back on a private jet.
The NFL community went into a literal tailspin.
Wives of players were actually messaging Jeffree, begging him to clear their husbands' names because fans were harassing them. It turned out to be one of the most successful marketing stunts in recent memory. The "boo" was Taylor Lewan, an offensive lineman for the Tennessee Titans. But they weren't dating. They were just filming a podcast episode for Bussin' With The Boys.
💡 You might also like: Bobbie Gentry Today Photo: Why You Won't Find One (And Why That Matters)
Why We Still Care in 2026
You've probably noticed that Jeffree doesn't live in LA anymore. He’s out in Casper, Wyoming, living on a yak ranch. The days of the high-glam "wifey" are mostly over.
But people still search for a Jeffree Star ex boyfriend because those relationships were the last time we saw a "vulnerable" side of the mogul. Nathan Schwandt represented a time when the drama was about the products, not just the personality.
What You Should Know About the Current Status
If you're looking for a definitive list of where everyone is now, here’s the reality:
- Nathan Schwandt: He’s moved back to a much more private life. He occasionally pops up on social media, often focusing on his own interests like skateboarding or his dogs, far away from the Jeffree Star Cosmetics warehouse.
- Andre Marhold: He’s continued his basketball career and talent agency work, mostly distancing himself from the YouTube beauty community after the 2020 fallout.
- Jeffree Star: He remains largely single or very private about his actual romantic interests. He’s traded the "boyfriend reveals" for yak meat sales and Star Lounge openings.
The takeaway? Jeffree Star’s relationships were always a mirror of his brand: loud, expensive, and polarizing. But behind the scenes, the pressure of maintaining a public persona while dating someone who wants privacy—like Nathan did—is almost always a recipe for a breakup.
If you're following the latest rumors, always check for the "reveal." As we saw with the Taylor Lewan situation, Jeffree is a master of using his dating life as a tool for engagement. Don't believe every hand-holding photo you see on a private jet until there's a tag attached.
Actionable Insights:
- Check the Date: When looking up rumors, always check if the "reveal" happened on a podcast. Most of Jeffree's recent "boyfriends" have been promotional guests.
- Follow the Real Nathan: If you're looking for Nathan Schwandt, avoid the dozens of fake "fan accounts" on Instagram. He has historically deleted and restarted accounts to escape the spam.
- Watch the Vlogs: For the most "honest" (as far as YouTube goes) look at these breakups, Jeffree’s "We Broke Up" video from January 2020 remains the most cited source for what went wrong with his longest relationship.