People are still weirdly obsessed with the Jeff Baena wedding date, mostly because it was one of the best-kept secrets in Hollywood for a long time. Honestly, if you follow Aubrey Plaza at all, you know she isn’t exactly the type to sell her wedding photos to People magazine for a seven-figure check. She’s way too cool—and maybe a little too chaotic—for that.
For a long time, fans just assumed they were forever-partners. They started dating way back in 2011. They worked together. They lived together. They were the ultimate indie-darling power couple. But then, out of nowhere in May 2021, Aubrey dropped the "husband" bomb on Instagram, and the internet collectively lost its mind.
When was the Jeff Baena wedding date exactly?
Here’s the thing: there isn’t just one date that people point to, and that’s where the confusion starts.
If you're looking for the official public "reveal," that happened on May 7, 2021. Aubrey posted a photo with Jeff and casually called him her "darling husband" while promoting their movie Spin Me Round. But they didn’t actually get married that day. They had already been married for months.
Actually, the real Jeff Baena wedding date happened in 2021, during their tenth anniversary together. Aubrey eventually went on The Ellen DeGeneres Show and spilled the tea. She basically said they were bored at home during the pandemic, realized it was their 10-year anniversary, and decided to just... do it.
🔗 Read more: Ethan Slater and Frankie Grande: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
A backyard, tie-dye, and a "Love Altar"
The ceremony wasn't some black-tie affair at a Vineyard. It was basically a fever dream in a backyard. Around 5:00 p.m. that day, Aubrey Googled "OneHourMarriage.com" (yes, really) and found someone who could come to their house by 8:30 p.m.
They didn't wear a tuxedo or a white gown. They wore tie-dye pajamas that Jeff had made himself. Aubrey even built what she called a "love altar" in the yard using random objects that meant something to them. It was spontaneous, weird, and perfectly matched their energy.
Why the secrecy mattered
In an industry where every relationship is "content," Jeff and Aubrey were outliers. They were together for a decade before the Jeff Baena wedding date even existed.
Think about it. Ten years.
💡 You might also like: Leonardo DiCaprio Met Gala: What Really Happened with His Secret Debut
They survived the transition from Aubrey being the deadpan star of Parks and Recreation to becoming a genuine A-list powerhouse. Through all that, they kept their private life private. When they did finally tie the knot, it wasn't for the cameras. It was for them.
The tragic turn of 2025
It’s impossible to talk about their marriage now without acknowledging the tragedy that followed. On January 3, 2025, the world learned that Jeff Baena had passed away. It was a massive shock to the film community and fans alike.
Reports later surfaced from the Los Angeles Medical Examiner’s office suggesting that the couple had actually separated a few months prior, in September 2024. This happens in real life, even to the couples we think are "perfect." Marriage is hard. High-pressure careers are harder.
Aubrey has since spoken about the "ocean of awfulness" that is grief. She even paid tribute to Jeff during the SNL 50 celebration in early 2025, wearing a tie-dye shirt that felt like a direct nod to their wedding night.
📖 Related: Mia Khalifa New Sex Research: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessed With Her 2014 Career
What we can learn from their story
The Jeff Baena wedding date reminds us that celebrity relationships aren't just headlines; they're lived experiences with real ups and downs.
- Don't believe everything you see on Instagram. They looked solid for years, but even they hit rough patches that the public didn't see until much later.
- Privacy is a choice. You don't owe the world your milestones.
- Meaning matters more than optics. A backyard wedding in pajamas is just as valid as a million-dollar gala.
If you’re looking to honor Jeff Baena’s legacy, the best way is to actually watch the work they created together. Life After Beth and The Little Hours are weird, specific, and brilliant—much like the relationship they shared.
You should start by streaming The Little Hours. It’s probably the best example of their creative synergy and shows why they were such a formidable team in the indie film world for over a decade.