Honestly, if you ask any fan in the Bronx about the last jays and yankees score that actually mattered, they’ll probably just stare at the floor and mumble something about 2025. It’s January 2026 now. The snow is piling up outside Yankee Stadium, and we’re months away from the 2026 Opening Day clash in San Francisco. But the ghost of that 5-2 loss in Game 4 of the ALDS still haunts the city. It was the first time these two ever met in the postseason. Ever. And the Jays didn't just win; they embarrassed a 94-win Yankees squad in their own backyard.
Baseball is weird like that. You play 162 games just to have your entire legacy decided by a few nights in October.
The Jays and Yankees Score That Changed Everything
The final jays and yankees score of the 2025 season was 5-2, Toronto. That sounds like a boring, mid-week Tuesday game in May, right? It wasn't. It was the series-clincher. Jeff Hoffman, who has been a revelation for the Jays' pen, came in and slammed the door. He threw a slider that basically made the Yankees' season evaporate.
Toronto moved on to the ALCS for the first time since 2016. The Yankees? They moved on to the golf course.
💡 You might also like: Kevin Durant Stats Career: Why He Is Still Scaring Defenses in 2026
People forget how dominant the Jays were in that series. Game 1 was a 10-1 bloodbath. Kevin Gausman looked like he was throwing a wiffle ball while the Yankees' bats looked like they were swinging toothpicks. Then Game 2 was a 13-7 slugfest. It felt more like a slow-pitch softball game than a divisional series. The Yankees tried to make it a series in Game 3 with a 9-6 win—thanks to Aaron Judge playing like a literal superhero—but it was too little, too late.
Why the 2025 Season Series Was a Disaster for New York
If you look back at the regular season jays and yankees score history from last year, the writing was on the wall. New York went 1-8 in Toronto. Think about that for a second. One win in nine tries at Rogers Centre. It’s hard to win a division when a rival treats your home field like their personal vacation spot.
- The July Sweep: Toronto swept a four-game set from June 30 to July 3.
- The Error Bug: The Yankees made 11 errors in seven games at Rogers Centre in July.
- The Tiebreaker: Both teams finished 94-68, but the Jays took the AL East crown because they owned the head-to-head.
What’s Next for This Rivalry in 2026?
We’re staring down the barrel of a massive 2026 season. MLB recently dropped the schedule, and while the Yankees start their year against the Giants on March 25, the real date everyone is circling is May 24. That's when Toronto visits the Bronx for the first time in the new season.
There’s a lot of talk about roster changes. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is coming off an ALCS MVP performance, and he seems to enjoy hitting home runs in New York more than anyone since Babe Ruth. The Yankees have some soul-searching to do. Aaron Boone is back, for better or worse, and the pressure is already at a boiling point.
Usually, the jays and yankees score is just a data point. In 2026, it’s going to be a statement. Every time these two teams meet this year, it’s going to feel like a Game 7. The bad blood is real. The Sportsnet vs. YES Network banter is already starting up, and the fans are ready to lose their minds.
Your Move: How to Track the Rivalry This Year
If you're trying to stay ahead of the curve for the 2026 season, don't just look at the box scores. Follow the pitching rotations. The Jays' depth in the bullpen was the secret sauce that killed the Yankees' rally in Game 4. If New York doesn't find a way to stabilize their middle relief, we're going to see the same 4-3 and 5-2 scores going Toronto's way all summer.
Check the secondary market for that May 24th series early. Tickets are going to be a nightmare. Keep an eye on the "Rivalry Weekend" updates too, as MLB is leaning hard into the regional drama this year. It's not just about the score anymore; it's about who actually survives the AL East gauntlet.