You’ve probably heard the legend by now. It’s the kind of story that feels too "Philly" to be true, but it actually is. Before the Super Bowl rings, the massive New Heights podcast, and the world-famous brother dating a global pop star, Jason Kelce was just a guy on a dating app.
Honestly, the Jason Kelce Tinder saga is the ultimate proof that sometimes, a total disaster of a first impression can lead to a lifetime of happiness.
The Profile That Almost Didn’t Work
Back in 2014, Jason was already a center for the Philadelphia Eagles. But if you looked at his profile, you wouldn't necessarily know it. Kylie McDevitt, a Cabrini University student at the time, was just hanging out with her friends swiping when she saw a guy who looked, well, like Jason.
The bio was a trip. It was sarcastic, bordering on weirdly specific. It mentioned wanting to have "intimate conversations" and "women who want babies."
Kylie thought it was a catfish. Why would a starting NFL player be on Tinder looking for "cuddles" and "deep talks"?
His photos didn't help much either. One was a shot of him in a Philadelphia Flyers winter hat. Another was actually a picture of a TV screen showing him on the sidelines of a game, but because of how Tinder cropped photos back then, the jersey and the "Eagles" logo were totally cut out. All she saw was a guy with a beard.
✨ Don't miss: Melania Trump Wedding Photos: What Most People Get Wrong
She swiped right anyway. Why? Basically because he was tall. At 5'11", Kylie wanted someone who could, in her words, "actually pick her up." Jason, at 6'3" and offensive lineman weight, definitely fit the bill.
The First Date Disaster at Buffalo Billiards
They agreed to meet at Buffalo Billiards in Old City, Philadelphia. Jason didn't come alone—he brought a few teammates, including Beau Allen. This wasn't exactly a candlelit dinner.
It was the Eagles' holiday party night.
Jason had been "pre-gaming" pretty hard. By the time he actually met Kylie face-to-face, he was, to put it lightly, over-served. About 45 minutes into the date, the legendary Philadelphia Eagle fell fast asleep. At the bar.
Just snoozing.
🔗 Read more: Erika Kirk Married Before: What Really Happened With the Rumors
Beau Allen ended up having to fireman-carry Jason out of the bar and back to his apartment, which was about a half-mile walk. Jason wasn't just dead weight; he was apparently "wiggling free" and trying to fight Beau the whole way home. Not exactly the rom-com moment most people dream of.
Kylie stood there watching her potential boyfriend get hauled away like a sack of potatoes. Most people would have deleted the number and blocked the account.
Why a Second Date Actually Happened
So, how do you go from "passed out at the bar" to "married with four kids"?
Jason called her the next day. He apologized. He was humble. He asked for a do-over.
Kylie, being a "ride-or-die" person, decided to give him one more shot. She later admitted that even though he was a mess that first night, there was something about him. Jason, on the other hand, describes seeing her walk through the door as "love at first sight." He says it was like she was "gliding" with an aura around her.
💡 You might also like: Bobbie Gentry Today Photo: Why You Won't Find One (And Why That Matters)
The second date was at an ice skating rink. It was much better, though Jason did admit on his podcast that he accidentally let a "fart squeeze out" while tying his skates. Apparently, Kylie just laughed. That’s when he knew she was the one.
The Legacy of the Kelce Tinder Match
It’s been over a decade since that fateful swipe. Today, they are one of the most beloved couples in sports.
- Marriage: They tied the knot in April 2018 in Philadelphia.
- Family: They now have four daughters: Wyatt, Elliotte, Bennett, and their newest arrival, Finnley.
- The Documentary: The 2023 Kelce documentary on Prime Video gave fans a front-row seat to their dynamic, making the Jason Kelce Tinder story a piece of NFL folklore.
Kylie recently joked on her own podcast, Not Gonna Lie, that she "won Tinder." She was the only person she ever actually met up with from the app. Talk about a high success rate.
What This Means for Your Own Dating Life
If you're currently scrolling through apps and feeling hopeless, the Kelce story offers a few "expert" takeaways that are actually useful:
- Don't over-curate your bio: Jason's weird, sarcastic bio about wanting babies was "ironic" at the time, but it ended up being his literal future. Authenticity (even the weird kind) attracts the right person.
- The "Catfish" Test: If someone looks too good to be true, they might just be a professional athlete who doesn't know how to crop a photo.
- Grace for a bad night: Everyone has a "Buffalo Billiards" moment. If the person is genuinely apologetic and shows character the next day, they might be worth the second chance.
If you're looking to find your own "Jason" or "Kylie," focus on being yourself rather than being perfect. The most successful relationships often start with a story you'd be embarrassed to tell your parents—until you're ten years deep and realize it's the best thing that ever happened to you.
Start by auditing your own profile. Is it too polished? Maybe throw in a photo of you in a winter hat and see who swiped right for the real you. If Jason Kelce can land a wife while asleep at a bar, there is hope for the rest of us.
Next Steps for Your Search:
To dig deeper into the Kelce family dynamic, you can check out the Kelce documentary on Amazon Prime or listen to Episode 52 of the New Heights podcast, where Kylie gives her full, unfiltered version of the Tinder bio that started it all.