Jarret Stoll Erin Andrews Wedding: What Most People Get Wrong

When Jarret Stoll and Erin Andrews finally said "I do" back in 2017, the internet basically exploded with sunset photos and dress details. But honestly, if you think this was just another cookie-cutter celebrity blowout in a ballroom, you’ve got it all wrong. It wasn't just a party. It was a massive sigh of relief after a year that frankly sounded like a nightmare for the Fox Sports reporter.

We're talking about a wedding that took place on a mountain, on a birthday, and right on the heels of a terrifying health battle. Most people see the shiny photos and think "Pinterest goals." They miss the part where this Jarret Stoll Erin Andrews wedding was actually a masterclass in how to handle life when it decides to throw every possible curveball at your relationship.

The Montana Backdrop Nobody Can Forget

They didn't pick some flashy Los Angeles hotel. Instead, they dragged their inner circle to the Yellowstone Club in Big Sky, Montana. If you aren't familiar, it’s this incredibly exclusive private residential club where the air is thin and the views make you feel like you’re inside a screensaver.

The ceremony happened right at sunset on June 24, 2017.

That date wasn't random. It was Jarret’s 35th birthday. Imagine being so confident in your marriage that you’re willing to share your birthday with your anniversary for the rest of your life. Bold move, Stoll.

The vibe was "mountain chic" but like, the expensive version. The sunset was so intense that Erin actually posted a photo of the sky with the caption "Stop." because, well, what else do you say when the atmosphere is doing most of the decorating for you?

✨ Don't miss: Are Sugar Bear and Jennifer Still Married: What Really Happened

That Carolina Herrera Gown and the Secret Blue Bow

Let’s talk about the dress because everyone else was. Erin went with a custom Carolina Herrera. It was off-the-shoulder, mermaid-cut, and a classic ivory satin. It looked simple from a distance, but the construction was insane.

Here’s the detail most people missed: Herrera herself hand-sewed a tiny blue bow into the lining of the dress.

That was her "something blue."

She paired it with a sheer veil by Patricia Lansing and enough Neil Lane diamonds to probably fund a small startup. Later on, for the reception, she ditched the heavy satin for a custom Daniel Wingate jumpsuit. It had a "cigarette look" with shorter pants and a slit to "jazz it up." It was the ultimate move for a woman who spent her life on sidelines and wanted to actually move her legs at her own party.

Why This Wedding Almost Didn’t Happen

It’s easy to look at the photos and see perfection. But 2016—the year leading up to the engagement—was absolute hell for them.

🔗 Read more: Amy Slaton Now and Then: Why the TLC Star is Finally "Growing Up"

Erin was dealing with the fallout of a massive civil trial involving a stalker. Then, she got hit with a cervical cancer diagnosis.

She’s been very open about this lately. She was terrified. She actually wondered if Jarret would want to stay with her. Who wants to date someone who is constantly at doctor appointments? Turns out, Jarret Stoll did. He didn't just stay; he proposed at Disneyland’s Club 33 in December 2016, right in the middle of her treatment.

She said she was "bawling like a child." Can you blame her?

The wedding in Montana wasn't just a celebration of a marriage; it was a celebration of surviving a year that would have broken most couples.

The Guest List: Larry David and the "Curb" Connection

It was an intimate affair, but the guest list was heavy on the talent. Michael Strahan was there. Joe Buck made the trip. Even Larry David showed up.

💡 You might also like: Akon Age and Birthday: What Most People Get Wrong

Actually, Larry David apparently found the whole experience so interesting that he ended up using storylines from the wedding for Curb Your Enthusiasm. When you have Larry David taking notes at your nuptials, you know it’s a good time.

The reception was designed by Yifat Oren, a celebrity planner who specializes in making things look effortless even though they cost a fortune. They had a golden retriever named Howie who was basically the guest of honor, and the whole thing felt more like a family reunion than a PR event.

Actionable Takeaways from the Stoll-Andrews Playbook

If you’re planning your own event or just looking at theirs for inspiration, there are a few things they did right that actually matter:

1. Pick a Meaningful Date: Combining a birthday and an anniversary makes the day impossible to forget. It also keeps the focus on "us" rather than just a random Saturday.
2. The Reception Pivot: If you're wearing a heavy gown for the ceremony, have a jumpsuit or a "movement-friendly" outfit ready for the party. You shouldn't spend your wedding feeling like a statue.
3. Privacy is Luxury: By choosing a private club in Montana, they kept the paparazzi at bay. It allowed them to actually be present without worrying about a drone hovering over the "I dos."
4. Lean into the Support: Erin credited Jarret’s support during her cancer battle as the reason they grew so close. If you can handle the "sickness" part before the "health" part, the wedding is just the victory lap.

The Jarret Stoll Erin Andrews wedding remains a touchstone for celebrity weddings not because it was the most expensive, but because it felt the most earned. They went from the hospital to the world series to a mountaintop in Big Sky.

To recreate this kind of vibe, focus on texture over flash. Use the natural landscape (whether that's a beach or a forest) as your primary decor. Keep the guest list tight to people who actually know your "real" story—not just your Instagram feed. Use a custom element, like that hidden blue bow, to keep a piece of the day just for yourself.