Twenty-five years is a long time to wait for a whisper of justice. For the family of Janet Acosta, that wait finally ended on a Tuesday evening in April 2025 at the Florida State Prison in Starke.
The name Janet Acosta Miami Herald often pops up in local crime lore or legal journals, but if you look at the old headlines, there’s a common mistake people make. Many think she was a reporter chasing a dangerous lead. She wasn't. Janet was a production worker—a layout supervisor who had spent 25 years helping put the paper together. She was part of the backbone of the newsroom, not the byline.
On April 25, 2000, she was just a woman enjoying a book during her lunch break. She was sitting in her van under a shade tree at the Japanese Rock Gardens on Watson Island. It was a normal Tuesday until Michael Anthony Tanzi approached her, asking for a cigarette.
The Reality of the Janet Acosta Miami Herald Tragedy
What happened next wasn't a quick crime. It was a grueling, multi-county nightmare. Tanzi, a 23-year-old drifter from Massachusetts, punched her, forced his way into the van, and threatened her with a razor blade.
He didn't just take her money and run. He drove her south.
He stopped in Homestead to bind and gag her with rope and a towel. He stole about $53. Then, he kept driving her toward the Florida Keys. Along the way, he used her ATM card to pull cash from her account. It’s the kind of detail that makes your stomach turn—stopping at a hardware store in Tavernier to buy duct tape and more razor blades while your victim is trapped in the back.
💡 You might also like: What Really Happened With the Menendez Brothers: The Crime, the Trial, and the 2026 Truth
A Cold, Calculated Path to Cudjoe Key
By the time they reached an isolated stretch of Cudjoe Key, Tanzi had decided he couldn't let her go. He later told police, "If I let her go, then I'm gonna be in a lot of trouble."
He strangled her.
He even paused during the act to put duct tape over her face because she was making too much noise. Honestly, the level of detachment is hard to wrap your head around. After leaving her body in the brush, he didn't flee the state. He went to Key West. He bought marijuana. He hung out with friends. He used her van like it was his own.
The police caught him two days later because Janet’s coworkers at the Miami Herald knew something was wrong immediately. She wasn't the type to just not show up after lunch. When cops found the van in downtown Key West, Tanzi was literally walking up to it with ATM receipts in his pocket.
Why This Case Stayed in the Headlines for Decades
You might wonder why we are still talking about a crime from 2000. It’s because the legal battle lasted nearly a quarter-century.
Tanzi confessed. He even led police to her body. Usually, that speeds things up, but the Florida death penalty system is a slow-moving beast. He was sentenced to death in 2003 after a 12-0 jury recommendation. Then came the appeals. Decades of them.
- The "Serial Killer" Label: Investigators eventually linked Tanzi to the 1999 murder of Caroline Holder in Massachusetts. He was never tried for that because he was already on Florida's death row.
- The Health Appeals: Toward the end, his lawyers tried to argue that his morbid obesity would make the lethal injection "cruel and unusual." They claimed the drugs wouldn't work right.
- The Final Statement: In April 2025, Tanzi finally faced execution. His last words were an apology to the family and a Bible verse.
Justice is a heavy word. For Janet’s sister, Julie Andrew, the execution meant she could finally "breathe again." For the rest of Miami, it was a reminder of a woman who was simply living her life, reading a book on her break, when she crossed paths with the absolute worst of humanity.
Essential Takeaways and Facts
If you’re looking into the Janet Acosta Miami Herald case for research or out of a sense of local history, keep these specific points in mind:
📖 Related: Fire in Raleigh NC Today: What’s Actually Happening Downtown
- Her Role: She was a production supervisor, not a journalist. This distinction matters because it highlights that she was a private citizen targeted at random.
- The Timeline: The crime occurred in April 2000; the execution didn't happen until April 8, 2025.
- The Location: The abduction happened on Watson Island (Miami), but the murder took place 140 miles away in Cudjoe Key.
- The Evidence: Tanzi’s own confession and the ATM receipts were the primary nails in the coffin for his defense.
To truly honor the memory of victims like Janet, it’s helpful to support organizations that assist the families of violent crime victims. You can look into the Florida Network of Victim Assistance (FNOVA) or local South Florida charities that provide resources for families navigating the long, often exhausting decades of the appeals process. Understanding the sheer length of time these families wait for a resolution is the first step in advocating for a more efficient judicial system.