If you look at a modern map of American politics, it’s all red and blue. It's a constant, noisy tug-of-war. But there was this one weird, brief moment in the early 1800s where the map basically turned one color.
Honestly, it sounds like a fever dream now. Imagine a president running for re-election and winning every single state. Imagine a country where the "other guys" just sort of stopped existing. That was the reality for the James Monroe political party experience.
But here’s the thing: Monroe didn't just happen to be popular. He actually hated the idea of parties. He thought they were a "disease" in a free government. He spent eight years trying to smoke them out, and for a second there, he actually pulled it off.
The Democratic-Republican Identity
Basically, James Monroe was a Democratic-Republican through and through. He was the last of the "Virginia Dynasty," following in the footsteps of Jefferson and Madison. If you’ve heard of the "Era of Good Feelings," that’s his era.
When Monroe took office in 1817, the Federalist Party—the party of Alexander Hamilton—was circling the drain. They had messed up big time by opposing the War of 1812. People saw them as unpatriotic, maybe even treasonous.
So, Monroe walks into the White House with almost no competition. But instead of gloating, he did something kind of radical. He decided he wasn't going to be a "party leader." He wanted to be the head of the whole nation.
Why the "Democratic-Republican" Label is Confusing
Today, we hear "Democratic-Republican" and we think it's a typo. It wasn't. Back then, they were often just called "Republicans," but they are the direct ancestors of today’s Democratic Party.
📖 Related: The Galveston Hurricane 1900 Orphanage Story Is More Tragic Than You Realized
They believed in:
- Strong state governments (mostly).
- A strict reading of the Constitution.
- An economy built on farming and land expansion.
- Keeping European empires out of the Americas (The Monroe Doctrine).
The 1820 Election: A Total Lockdown
You’ve got to see the numbers from 1820 to believe them. Monroe ran for his second term, and the Federalists didn't even bother to nominate a candidate. Not one.
He won every single electoral vote except for one.
Legend says an elector from New Hampshire, William Plumer, cast a vote for John Quincy Adams just so George Washington would remain the only president ever elected unanimously. Historians today think Plumer actually just didn't like Monroe’s spending habits, but the "Washington's legacy" story is way more dramatic.
Was the "Era of Good Feelings" Actually Good?
The name was coined by a Boston newspaper during Monroe’s "Goodwill Tour" in 1817. He was traveling through New England—the heart of Federalist territory—and people were losing their minds. They loved him.
But "Good Feelings" is a bit of a marketing spin.
👉 See also: Why the Air France Crash Toronto Miracle Still Changes How We Fly
Underneath the surface, the James Monroe political party was starting to crack. Because there was no outside enemy (the Federalists), the Democratic-Republicans started fighting each other. It was like a family dinner that goes on too long.
You had the "Old Republicans" who wanted tiny government. Then you had "National Republicans" like Henry Clay who wanted big roads, canals, and a national bank.
The Real Conflicts
- The Panic of 1819: The first major financial crash. Banks closed, people lost their homes, and everyone started pointing fingers.
- The Missouri Compromise (1820): This was the big one. The argument over whether new states should allow slavery. Monroe signed it to keep the peace, but he knew it was just a "band-aid." Thomas Jefferson called it a "fire bell in the night."
- Internal Rivalries: His own cabinet was a shark tank. John Quincy Adams, William Crawford, and John C. Calhoun were all eyeing his job.
Monroe’s "Partyless" Strategy
Monroe’s big move was "de-federalization." He didn't fire Federalists just to be mean; he just ignored them. He wouldn't give them jobs or appointments. He figured if he ignored them long enough, they’d just go away.
He was right. By the end of his second term, the Federalist Party was functionally dead.
But he also stopped holding "caucuses"—basically big meetings where party leaders picked the next candidate. He thought it was "anti-democratic." This actually backfired. Without a central party meeting to pick a successor, the 1824 election turned into a four-way car crash that ended the Era of Good Feelings forever.
What Most People Get Wrong
Most people think Monroe was just a "placeholder" between the geniuses of Jefferson and the fire of Andrew Jackson.
✨ Don't miss: Robert Hanssen: What Most People Get Wrong About the FBI's Most Damaging Spy
That’s wrong.
Monroe was a tough-as-nails soldier who took a bullet in the shoulder at the Battle of Trenton. He was a diplomat who helped buy Louisiana. As president, he managed to acquire Florida from Spain without starting a massive war. He wasn't just "there"; he was the architect of the borders we have today.
Why It Matters Today
The James Monroe political party story is a cautionary tale. It shows that even when you "win" and the other side disappears, conflict doesn't stop. It just moves inside.
Monroe’s dream of a country without parties was noble, but probably impossible. As soon as he left office, the Democratic-Republicans split into the Democrats (Jackson) and the Whigs (Clay). The two-party system came roaring back.
Your Next Steps to Understand the Era
If you want to really "get" why this period shaped America, here is what you should do next:
- Look up the Adams-Onís Treaty. It’s the reason Florida is part of the U.S. and it happened because Monroe was a master of playing "good cop, bad cop" with Spain.
- Read the 1823 Monroe Doctrine speech. Don't read a summary; read the actual text. It’s surprisingly short and explains why the U.S. felt it had the right to "police" the Western Hemisphere.
- Check out a map of the "National Road." Monroe wrestled with whether the federal government had the legal right to build roads. It sounds boring, but it’s the origin of the "Big Government vs. Small Government" debate we’re still having today.
Monroe was the last of the wig-wearing, knee-breeches-sporting founders. When he stepped down in 1825, that old world of "gentlemanly" politics died with him. The Era of Good Feelings was over, and the era of modern, messy, loud-mouthed politics was born.
Actionable Insights for History Buffs:
To see Monroe’s legacy in person, visit Ash Lawn-Highland (now called Highland) in Virginia. It’s right next door to Jefferson’s Monticello. Seeing how much smaller and more "working-class" his estate was compared to Jefferson’s gives you a real sense of his personality. He was the "people’s" revolutionary, even if he did want to get rid of their political parties.