History has a funny way of burying the people who actually changed the world. If you walk through lower Manhattan today, you won’t see many monuments to James McCune Smith, but honestly, you should. We’re talking about the first African American to ever hold a medical degree. Not just a "first" for the sake of a trivia night, but a man who used his stethoscope and his pen to dismantle the pseudo-scientific garbage used to justify slavery in the 1800s.
He was brilliant. Like, scary brilliant.
Imagine being born in New York City in 1813 to a mother who had achieved her own freedom. You grow up attending the African Free School, where you realize you’re smarter than basically everyone around you. You want to be a doctor. But every single medical school in the United States looks at your skin color and says "no." They don't even look at your grades. They just shut the door.
So what does James McCune Smith do? He goes to Scotland.
The University of Glasgow and the Making of a Legend
He didn't just go to Scotland to get a degree; he went there to dominate. At the University of Glasgow, Smith wasn't just a student; he was a standout. He earned his bachelor's, his master's, and eventually his medical degree by 1837. This wasn't some honorary title. This was a full-blown MD from one of the most prestigious institutions in the world at the time.
While he was over there, he wasn't just hitting the books. He was getting radicalized—in a good way. He joined the Glasgow Emancipation Society. He saw a world where he was treated as an intellectual equal, which made the reality back home in America seem even more insane. When he returned to New York, he wasn't just Dr. Smith; he was a weapon against the status quo.
He opened a pharmacy on West Broadway. It was the first black-owned pharmacy in the United States. Think about that for a second. People of all races came to him for help. He was a black man in the 1830s and 40s treating white patients in a city that was still deeply segregated and incredibly dangerous for people of color.
🔗 Read more: How to Eat Chia Seeds Water: What Most People Get Wrong
James McCune Smith and the Fight Against "Bad Science"
This is where things get really interesting from a health and data perspective. In the mid-19th century, pro-slavery advocates loved to use "science" to claim that black people were biologically inferior. They used the 1840 Census to try and prove that free black people in the North were more prone to "insanity" than enslaved people in the South. It was a total lie, obviously, but they had the numbers to back it up—or so they thought.
Smith destroyed them.
He was a pioneer in statistics. He looked at the 1840 Census data and found massive errors. He pointed out that in many Northern towns, the number of "insane" black people listed was actually higher than the total number of black people living there. Basically, the census takers were just making stuff up to fit a political narrative. Smith published his findings, using cold, hard math to prove that freedom didn't cause mental illness—racism and bad data did.
He didn't stop there. He wrote about everything from the effects of climate on the human body to the way the "nasal index" was being used by racists to categorize humans. He was essentially an epidemiologist before that was even a cool thing to be.
A Partnership with Frederick Douglass
You’ve definitely heard of Frederick Douglass. But did you know Smith was his "intellectual physician"? That’s how Douglass described him. They were close. Really close. Smith wrote the introduction to Douglass’s second autobiography, My Bondage and My Freedom.
While Douglass was the orator, the man who could move crowds with his voice, Smith was the guy in the background providing the intellectual ammunition. He helped Douglass understand that the fight for abolition wasn't just about morality; it was about science and truth. Smith argued that "the black man" was a New Man in America, someone who was uniquely adapted to the land and essential to its future.
💡 You might also like: Why the 45 degree angle bench is the missing link for your upper chest
Why We Still Need to Talk About Him
The medical field still struggles with the ghosts that Smith was fighting. We talk about "race-based medicine" today and the biases in algorithms that often hurt minority patients. Smith saw this coming nearly 200 years ago. He knew that if you bake bias into the data, you get biased results.
He served as the physician at the Colored Orphan Asylum in New York for twenty years. He wasn't just a theorist; he was on the ground, treating kids, dealing with smallpox outbreaks, and trying to keep a marginalized community alive during a time when the government barely acknowledged their humanity.
When the Draft Riots broke out in 1863, the asylum was burned to the ground by a white mob. Smith had to move his family to Brooklyn for safety. Even after everything he had achieved, he was still a target. He died in 1865, just weeks before the 13th Amendment was ratified. He saw the end of slavery coming, but he didn't get to live in the world he helped build.
Actionable Insights from the Life of James McCune Smith
Understanding Smith isn't just about a history lesson. It’s about how we handle information today. Here is how you can apply his "expert" mindset to your own life:
Question the "Expert" Data
If a statistic seems too perfect or aligns too neatly with a certain political agenda, do what Smith did. Look at the source. Smith didn't just accept the 1840 Census; he tore it apart. In an era of AI-generated "facts," being a skeptic is a superpower.
Cross-Train Your Brain
Smith was a doctor, a pharmacist, a statistician, and a journalist. He didn't stay in one lane. If you want to solve big problems, you have to look at them through multiple lenses. Medicine told him how to heal a body; statistics told him how to heal a society.
📖 Related: The Truth Behind RFK Autism Destroys Families Claims and the Science of Neurodiversity
Focus on the Under-Served
Whatever your "practice" is—whether you're in tech, healthcare, or education—look at who is being left out. Smith's work at the Colored Orphan Asylum was arguably his most important work. Impact is measured by who you help when no one is watching.
Use Logic Over Emotion in Arguments
Smith was living in an incredibly emotional and violent time. Yet, his best work was clinical. He won arguments by being more prepared and more logical than his opponents. When you’re fighting for a cause, bring the data.
Document the Truth
Smith wrote constantly. He knew that if he didn't write his own story and his own findings, someone else would write a false version of them. If you’re doing something important, keep a record.
Further Reading for the Truly Curious
If you want to go deeper, check out The Works of James McCune Smith: Black Intellectual and Abolitionist edited by John Stauffer. It's a heavy read, but it's where you'll find his actual voice. Also, look into the history of the New York African Free School; it was basically a factory for geniuses.
James McCune Smith wasn't just a "black doctor." He was a world-class intellectual who happened to be black in a country that wasn't ready for him. We're still catching up to his vision of a science-based, fact-driven, and equitable world.