When 20th Century Fox announced they were making a prequel to the X-Men movies back in 2010, the collective internet groaned. It felt like a cash grab. How do you replace Sir Patrick Stewart? He was Charles Xavier. He had the voice, the gravitas, and let's be honest, the perfect head for it.
Then came James McAvoy.
He didn't walk onto the set of X-Men: First Class trying to do a Stewart impression. Instead, he showed up with a full head of hair, a drink in his hand, and a vibe that was more "charming flirt at a bar" than "world-class civil rights leader." It was jarring. It was also exactly what the franchise needed.
The "Finger" Debate and Making Charles Human
There is a funny bit of trivia McAvoy shared recently during a panel at New York Comic Con 2025. He spent a lot of time worrying about what to do with his hands when Xavier used his telepathy. In the original 1992 animated series, Charles would often put two fingers to his temple.
McAvoy wanted to do that.
Fox, apparently, had a "finger conversation" with him because they weren't sure. It sounds silly, but he fought for it because he realized his eyebrows—expressive as they are—weren't enough to convey "I'm currently inside your mind."
He eventually won that battle. But beyond the gestures, McAvoy brought a specific kind of ego to the role. In First Class, his Charles is a bit of a know-it-all. He’s brilliant, sure, but he’s also naive. He thinks he can solve the world's deep-seated hatred with a few clever speeches and a training montage. Watching that ego get bruised when Mystique leaves him for Magneto at the end of the film is what makes his version of the character feel real. He wasn't born a saint; he was a guy who had to lose everything to become a leader.
🔗 Read more: The Pixels Movie Ashley Benson Role: What Most People Get Wrong
Why Days of Future Past was the Peak
If you ask McAvoy which film he’s most proud of, he usually points to X-Men: Days of Future Past. He’s gone on record with GQ and Agents of Fandom saying it was his hardest acting workout.
It’s easy to see why.
By the time 1973 rolls around in that movie, Charles is a wreck. He’s addicted to a serum that lets him walk but kills his powers. He’s basically a junkie hiding in a mansion. This is the "lost" Xavier that most fans never expected to see.
The scene where he meets his future self (Patrick Stewart) through a telepathic bridge is peak superhero cinema. You have the older, wiser version telling the broken younger man, "I don't want your suffering! I don't want your future!" It’s heavy stuff for a movie about people in spandex. Stewart himself apparently told McAvoy he was impressed by the performance. It wasn't just a passing of the torch; it was a collision of two different ways to play the same soul.
The One Major Flaw (According to McAvoy)
Despite his love for the experience, James McAvoy has one big gripe with how the series ended. He thinks they wasted the relationship between Charles and Magneto.
In First Class, the chemistry between McAvoy and Michael Fassbender was the "massive weapon," as he calls it. They were brothers. But as the sequels rolled on—especially Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix—the movies got distracted by world-ending threats and blue aliens.
The quiet moments of two friends arguing over the future of their race got buried under CGI explosions. "Why did we just eject that massive weapon?" he asked in a 2022 interview. Honestly? He's right. The best parts of those movies were always the chess games and the ideological debates, not the collapsing stadiums.
The Timeline Mess and the MCU Question
We have to address the elephant in the room: the X-Men timeline is a disaster.
- First Class is 1962.
- Days of Future Past is 1973.
- Apocalypse is 1983.
- Dark Phoenix is 1992.
In the span of 30 years, McAvoy’s Charles barely ages. He goes from 30 to 60 without getting a single wrinkle, then suddenly turns into Patrick Stewart in the space of about ten "movie years." It makes no sense. Fans have mostly just agreed to ignore it because the performances were good enough to carry the absurdity.
So, will he come back for the Marvel Cinematic Universe?
Right now, he's being very "actor-y" about it. He told BuzzFeed UK in late 2024 that he suspects Marvel will simply recast the role for the reboot. He’s also said he won't say "yes" to a script unless it’s actually good. But he always adds a caveat: "If I did get the call, I wouldn't tell you anyway."
He didn't show up in Deadpool & Wolverine, even though his sister (Cassandra Nova, played by Emma Corrin) was the villain. That felt like a missed opportunity to many, but McAvoy joked that he just demanded a shoutout in the credits instead.
How to Revisit the McAvoy Era
If you’re looking to dive back into his performance, don't just watch the movies in order. Look at the specific evolution of his Charles:
✨ Don't miss: Fantastic Four 2025 end credit scene: What Marvel is Actually Hiding
- First Class: Watch for the arrogance. He’s a guy who thinks he’s already won.
- Days of Future Past: This is the emotional core. Look at how he uses his voice when he’s at his lowest point.
- Dark Phoenix: Even though the movie is a bit of a mess, McAvoy plays Charles as someone whose ego has finally become a liability. He’s gaslighting his students "for their own good," and it’s a fascinating, darker take on the character.
Ultimately, James McAvoy did the impossible. He took a character defined by a legend and made us care about the man Charles Xavier was before he became the monument. Whether or not we see him in the MCU, he’s already left a permanent mark on the X-Men legacy.
If you want to understand the character better, go back and watch the "mind-bridge" scene in Days of Future Past. It’s the perfect distillation of what both McAvoy and Stewart brought to the chair—hope and pain, two sides of the same coin.