The lights at the Crypto.com Arena in Los Angeles finally dimmed, and honestly, the collective sigh of relief from NHL scouts was almost audible. For two years, everyone pegged James Hagens as the definitive crown jewel of this class. Usually, when a kid gets that much hype that early, someone finds a way to poke holes in his game. They didn't. When the 2025 NHL Draft results started rolling in, it became clear that while Hagens was the prize, the real story was the sheer depth of the Centermen available in the top ten. It wasn't just a "one-player draft" like some cynical analysts predicted back in 2023.
Draft day is chaos. Pure, unadulterated chaos. You have GMs sweating through expensive suits and teenagers trying to look cool while their entire lives change in forty-five seconds. This year felt different because the talent gap between pick three and pick twelve was razor-thin. If you were a team looking for a franchise pillar, you got one. If you were looking for a safe, bottom-six grinder, you probably overreached.
The Hagens Era Begins in Style
James Hagens didn't just go first overall; he went first overall with an exclamation point. After tearing it up with the U.S. National Team Development Program and following that up with a dominant stint at Boston College, his vision was just too much for any team to pass up. He’s got this weird way of slowing the game down. You know how some players look like they’re panicking when the forecheck closes in? Hagens looks like he’s having a coffee. He finds lanes that don't exist yet. Scouts from various NHL teams had been comparing him to Jack Hughes, but with a slightly more refined defensive conscience.
It’s easy to look at the 2025 NHL Draft results and just see a list of names. But look closer. The top of the board was dominated by "high-motor" players. Porter Martone, the powerhouse winger from the Brampton Steelheads, didn't slide. He went right where people expected because NHL GMs are still obsessed with size and "snarl" when it’s paired with elite hands. Martone is basically a throwback to the power forwards of the 90s but with 2025 skating mechanics. It’s a terrifying combo for defenders.
Surprises and the "Russian Factor" Revisited
Every year, people talk about the "Russian Factor." Will they come over? Will they get stuck? In the 2025 cycle, Ivan Ryabkin was the name on everyone's lips. He’s a playmaker who plays with a bit of a chip on his shoulder, which is exactly what teams like Montreal or Chicago look for to complement their existing young cores. Despite the geopolitical noise, the talent was too high for him to drop out of the top five.
👉 See also: Sammy Sosa Before and After Steroids: What Really Happened
Anton Frondell out of Sweden was another fascinating case study in how draft boards shift. Early in the season, some had him pushing for the top three. Then, a few nagging injuries slowed his momentum. By the time the actual 2025 NHL Draft results were finalized, he’d settled into a spot that arguably makes him the "steal" of the first round. If he stays healthy, he’s a top-line center. If he doesn't, he’s a very expensive "what if." That’s the gamble of the draft. It’s essentially high-stakes gambling with teenage athletes.
The middle of the first round was where things got weird. We saw a run on defensemen that nobody saw coming. Matthew Schaefer and Logan Hensler didn't stay on the board long. It’s a copycat league. After seeing how mobile, puck-moving blueliners dominated the playoffs recently, every GM wanted their own version of a "Swiss Army Knife" on the back end.
Why the OHL Dominated the First Round
If you looked at the jersey logos on stage, the Ontario Hockey League was everywhere. It felt like the glory days of the OHL. Between Martone, Michael Misa—who, let’s be honest, has lived under a microscope since getting exceptional status—and Malcolm Spence, the "O" proved it’s still the premier factory for NHL-ready talent.
Misa is a particularly interesting case. People wanted him to be the next McDavid. That was never fair. He’s Michael Misa. He’s an incredibly smart, efficient, and productive winger who is going to play 1,000 games in the NHL. He might not win three Art Ross trophies, but he’s the kind of player who wins you Stanley Cups. The teams that passed on him because he wasn't "flashy" enough might regret that when he’s scoring 30 goals a year on a rookie contract.
✨ Don't miss: Saint Benedict's Prep Soccer: Why the Gray Bees Keep Winning Everything
Breaking Down the Late First-Round Value
The back half of the first round is where the real scouting happens. Anyone can pick the best kid in the world at number one. Finding a contributor at pick 24? That’s where you keep your job as a Head Scout. We saw a lot of teams leaning into "high-floor" players this year. Kids like Roger McQueen, who has the frame that makes scouts drool, went to teams that are looking to get heavier for playoff runs.
It's sorta funny how the narrative changes. Five years ago, everyone wanted the 5'9" wizard who could skate circles around people. Now, the 2025 NHL Draft results show a shift back toward "functional size." You still have to be able to skate, obviously. If you can't skate, you're toast. But if you're 6'3" and can skate? You're getting drafted in the first round, even if your point totals aren't eye-popping.
Evaluating the Goalies: A Ghost Town?
If you were looking for a franchise savior in the crease, 2025 wasn't necessarily your year. The trend of not taking goalies in the first round continued, with most teams opting to wait until the third or fourth round to take a flier on a project. It makes sense. Goalie development is basically voodoo. Why waste a first-round pick on a guy who might not be ready for six years when you can get a winger who can help you next season?
There were a few names like Joshua Ravensbergen who generated buzz, but the consensus was clear: use the premium picks on skaters. The ROI on first-round goalies just hasn't been there lately, and the 2025 results reflected that cold, hard reality.
🔗 Read more: Ryan Suter: What Most People Get Wrong About the NHL's Ultimate Survivor
Real-World Impact for Fantasy Owners and Fans
If you're a fan of a team that walked away with a top-ten pick this year, you should be genuinely stoked. This wasn't a "weak" class. The high-end talent is comparable to 2023, even if it lacked a generational "Bedard-level" talent at the very top. Hagens is elite, but he’s a tier just below the "generational" tag, which honestly might be better for his development. Less pressure, more room to breathe.
For those of you looking at your keeper leagues, the 2025 NHL Draft results suggest you should be targeting the playmakers. This class was heavy on guys who can pass through a needle's eye. The goal scorers are there, sure, but the primary assists are going to be through the roof for this cohort in about three years.
What to Watch Next
Now that the hats have been worn and the photos taken, the real work starts. Development camps in July are the first time these kids actually feel the speed of the pro game. Most of the top ten will head back to their junior teams or college programs for one more year of seasoning.
Keep a close eye on the NCAA transition for the Americans. The gap between college hockey and the NHL has shrunk significantly, and guys like Hagens are going to be tested every single Friday and Saturday night against 23-year-old men. That’s the best barometer for whether they can jump into an NHL lineup in 2026.
Actionable Insights for Hockey Fans
- Track the NCAA players: Several top picks from 2025 are staying in college. Watch their "points per game" metrics. If a freshman or sophomore is hovering around 1.2 PPG, they are likely ready for a pro jump.
- Don't overreact to World Juniors: The WJC is a short tournament. A kid can have a bad week and still be a superstar. Look at their full season body of work in the OHL, WHL, or SHL instead.
- Watch the waiver wire: Teams that "won" the draft often move older assets shortly after. If your team drafted a stud center, look for them to trade a veteran middle-six guy for picks or defensive depth in the coming months.
- Scout the "Late Bloomers": Pay attention to the players drafted in rounds 4-7 who had late-season growth spurts. Those are the guys who often become the "hidden gems" of the 2025 NHL Draft results five years down the line.
The 2025 class is officially in the books. It provided exactly what we expected: a blue-chip superstar at the top, a massive run on Canadian junior talent, and enough surprises in the middle rounds to keep the "experts" guessing. Now we just wait for the first whistle of the preseason to see who actually belongs.