It was 2017. A fan walks up to James Charles at a meet-and-greet, asks for a photo, and clicks. The flash goes off. Suddenly, the most famous "CoverBoy" in the world looks like he’s been haunting an abandoned Victorian mansion for three centuries.
The james charles white face meme was born.
In the photo, his face is a stark, chalky, glowing white that stops abruptly at his neck. It’s jarring. It’s legendary. And honestly, it’s one of the few internet moments that actually managed to bridge the gap between niche makeup enthusiasts and the "normie" meme world. Most people just call it the "Flashback Mary" incident now.
The Night Flashback Mary Was Born
You've probably seen the side-by-side comparison. On the left, a "normal" photo where James looks like his usual glam self. On the right? Total Casper energy.
This didn't happen because he bought the wrong foundation shade. James isn't that amateur. The culprit was a technical phenomenon called makeup flashback.
🔗 Read more: Jeremy Renner Accident Recovery: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Basically, certain ingredients used in "HD" powders and sunscreens—specifically silica, zinc oxide, and titanium dioxide—are designed to reflect light. In person, they make your skin look blurred and airbrushed. But when a camera flash hits them directly? They act like a billion tiny mirrors, bouncing that light straight back at the lens.
James was reportedly using Coty Airspun or a similar silica-heavy setting powder that night. He "baked" his makeup (letting a thick layer of powder sit on the skin to set it), and while it looked flawless under the event lights, the fan's camera flash turned him into a literal ghost.
Was the photo fake?
Sorta. The original image was definitely bad, but once it hit Twitter, the internet did what the internet does.
Trolls and meme creators took the already-ghostly photo and pushed the contrast to the moon. They edited him into scenes from It, made him the face of urban legends, and compared him to Poot Lovato (Demi Lovato’s equally iconic "secret twin" meme).
💡 You might also like: Kendra Wilkinson Photos: Why Her Latest Career Pivot Changes Everything
Why This Meme Actually Mattered
Before 2017, "flashback" was something only professional makeup artists really worried about. James Charles, by being the face of this fail, turned a technical error into a mainstream beauty lesson.
- The "Beauty Guru" Myth: It proved that even the "experts" with millions of followers make basic mistakes.
- The Rise of Anti-SPF Makeup: Suddenly, everyone was checking their foundation for SPF before a night out.
- The Power of Self-Deprecation: James didn't hide. He leaned in.
How James Charles Flipped the Script
Most influencers would have deleted the photo or sent a cease-and-desist to the meme accounts. James did the opposite.
He renamed his Twitter account to Flashback Mary. He filmed a YouTube tutorial titled "RECREATING THE FLASHBACK MARY MEME," where he intentionally applied white face paint and heavy powder to look like the cursed image.
It was a brilliant PR move. By making himself the biggest fan of the meme, he took the power away from the bullies. You can't really make fun of someone who’s already laughing at themselves louder than you are. He even sold "Flashback Mary" merchandise, proving that in the creator economy, even a humiliating mistake is a business opportunity.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With the Brittany Snow Divorce
How to Avoid Having Your Own James Charles Moment
If you're worried about looking like a Victorian ghost in your next Instagram post, here is the expert advice you actually need to follow.
- Check for "HD" in the name. If a powder says it’s "High Definition" or 100% Silica, do NOT use it for flash photography. These are meant for video or natural light.
- Ditch the SPF at night. Sunscreens containing zinc or titanium are physical blockers. They reflect light by design. If you're going to a party, use a chemical-based sunscreen or skip it entirely if you'll be indoors.
- Test before you leave. Take a selfie in a dark room with the flash on. If you look like a ghost, you have too much powder on. Dust it off with a clean brush or use a setting spray to melt the powder into the skin.
The james charles white face meme eventually faded as newer scandals took over the headlines, but its impact on the beauty industry remains. It served as a massive "buyer beware" for the era of social media photography.
If you want to ensure your own makeup stays in place without the ghostly glow, start by swapping your silica-based "HD" powders for a tinted setting powder that matches your skin tone. This provides the same blurring effect without the light-reflecting properties that caused the 2017 internet meltdown.
Next Step: Check the ingredient list on your favorite setting powder for "Silica" or "Methicone." If those are in the top three ingredients, save that powder for daytime use and look for a talc-based or tinted alternative for your next night out.