When the news first broke in late July 2024 that two promising young talents were missing from the Penn State roster, the "personal reasons" tag felt like a placeholder. We’ve seen it before. Usually, it’s a grades issue or a minor team violation. But the reality for Jameial Lyons and Kaveion Keys was exponentially more serious. By the time the legal documents were unsealed in October, the college football world realized this wasn't just about football. It was a total collapse of two promising athletic careers.
Most fans remember Jameial Lyons as the defensive end from Philly who actually got onto the field as a true freshman. He played in eight games. He had a sack. People were excited about him. Kaveion Keys, a linebacker from Virginia, hadn't seen as much action yet, but the scouting reports were high on his ceiling.
Then came the morning of July 7, 2024.
The Incident at Nittany Apartments
According to the criminal complaints filed by the Penn State police, the situation began at an off-campus gathering before moving to an apartment on campus. A 17-year-old student, referred to in court docs as Victim 1, reportedly went back to the residence shared by Lyons and Keys with two other females.
The details are, honestly, harrowing.
💡 You might also like: Por qué los partidos de Primera B de Chile son más entretenidos que la división de honor
Police reports allege the girls were provided alcohol. Victim 1 told investigators that while she was in a bedroom, the two players sexually assaulted and raped her. She described being physically restrained and strangled to the point of being unable to breathe. There’s a specific, chilling detail in the affidavit where she recalls seeing a "flash," leading her to believe the encounter was being recorded.
Police eventually found a short video on Kaveion Keys' phone. It documented what they called "indecent contact."
The Second Accusation
It didn't stop with one person. A second student present that night told police she woke up in Lyons' bedroom to find her pants removed and Lyons touching her. When the authorities arrived with a search warrant just a day later, on July 8, the narrative from the players began to shift.
Kaveion Keys initially denied even knowing the 17-year-old or having any sexual contact with the women. Lyons, on the other hand, admitted to having sex with her but claimed he thought it was consensual. However, he also reportedly told police he had an "awareness" that she would likely report the situation to the authorities.
📖 Related: South Carolina women's basketball schedule: What Most People Get Wrong
That’s a heavy admission.
Legal Reality and Team Dismissal
By August 3, 2024, both players were officially scrubbed from the team. Gone. Not just suspended—removed from the university entirely.
The legal charges are a massive list of felonies:
- Jameial Lyons faces counts of felony rape, involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, and aggravated indecent assault, plus misdemeanors for invasion of privacy.
- Kaveion Keys is charged with felony rape, sexual assault, and aggravated indecent assault.
Bail was set high. $500,000 for Lyons and $400,000 for Keys. They were released on unsecured bonds, meaning they didn't have to put up the cash upfront but are on the hook for it if they miss court or violate conditions.
👉 See also: Scores of the NBA games tonight: Why the London Game changed everything
James Franklin's handling of the situation became a secondary news story. During an October press conference, he initially refused to answer questions, stepping away from the mic and letting a spokesperson read a pre-written statement. It looked bad. It felt cold. He eventually apologized for that specific behavior, admitting he didn't represent the program the right way in that moment.
Why This Still Matters in 2026
We are looking at a permanent shift in how programs handle these cases. In the past, there might have been a "wait and see" approach while the legal system played out. Not here. Penn State moved with a speed that signaled they knew exactly how damaging the evidence was.
The video evidence is a huge hurdle for the defense. In most "he-said, she-said" cases, there’s room for interpretation. But when there is digital documentation found on a device belonging to the accused, the legal strategy has to change completely.
The case is still winding through the Pennsylvania court system as of early 2026. For those following the Nittany Lions, the names Jameial Lyons and Kaveion Keys serve as a grim reminder of how quickly a life-changing opportunity can be thrown away.
What to Watch for Next
If you're following the legal updates, you need to keep an eye on the pre-trial motions regarding the cell phone evidence. The defense will almost certainly try to challenge how that video was obtained or its admissibility in court.
- Check the Centre County court dockets for trial date updates.
- Monitor university safety reports; this case triggered a major re-evaluation of campus security protocols at Nittany Apartments.
- Understand the distinction: this isn't a "football scandal" in the sense of a cover-up—it's a criminal case where the university chose immediate severance over athletic protection.
The path forward for both men is now entirely in the hands of the judicial system, far away from the bright lights of Beaver Stadium.