You know that feeling when a song just stops being a song and starts being a moment? That's what happened. When Jamal Roberts first time performance hit the American Idol stage during the Season 23 finale in May 2025, it wasn't just another TV slot. It was the sound of 22 years of history shifting.
Honestly, the room felt different. You could see it in Lionel Richie's eyes—a mix of "I've been here before" and "I've never seen this." Jamal, a P.E. teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, stood there in a lilac suit, no shirt underneath, looking like he’d already won before he even opened his mouth.
The Performance That Broke the Internet
Let's talk about the song choice. Most finalists go for the big, screaming power ballads. Not Jamal. He chose "First Time" by Teeks. It’s a soul record that requires a level of restraint most singers his age just don't have.
Basically, the track is a masterclass in "less is more."
Jelly Roll, who was the artist-in-residence at the time, actually hand-picked this for him. Why? Because Jelly had seen Jamal’s TikTok cover of the same song months before. Talk about a full-circle moment. When Jamal hit those low notes in the first verse, the audience at Disney’s Aulani Resort went completely silent.
Why the "First Time" cover worked:
- Vulnerability: He didn't hide behind a choir or a massive band.
- Tone: His voice has this smoky, church-hewn texture that felt like 1960s Motown but in 2025.
- The "Stare": If you watch the replay, he barely blinks. He was singing to his wife and daughters, and you felt like an intruder watching something private.
It wasn’t perfect. His voice cracked slightly toward the end. But Carrie Underwood—who knows a thing or two about winning this show—pointed out that the imperfection was the point. It felt human.
The 22-Year Weight on His Shoulders
We have to address the elephant in the room. Before Jamal Roberts first time winning moment, it had been over two decades since a Black man won American Idol. You have to go all the way back to Ruben Studdard in 2003.
📖 Related: Gwendoline Butler Dead in a Row: Why This 1957 Mystery Still Packs a Punch
That’s a long time.
Twenty-two years of "almosts" and "close calls." When Ryan Seacrest announced that 26 million votes had been cast—a record for the ABC era—it became clear that Jamal hadn't just reached the gospel crowd or the soul fans. He had reached everybody.
Behind the Scenes: The "Secret" Baby
Most people don't realize how close Jamal came to walking away from the competition entirely.
Just days before the Top 8 round, his wife gave birth to their third daughter, Gianna Grace. Imagine the stress. You’re in Hollywood, your family is in Mississippi, and you’re trying to remember lyrics to a Lionel Richie song while your wife is in labor.
He kept it a secret from the producers for 48 hours.
"I didn't want it to be a 'story,'" he later told Portia in his first post-win interview. "I wanted the music to be enough." That kind of grit is rare in reality TV. Most contestants would have been screaming it from the rooftops for "sympathy votes." Jamal just showed up and sang.
👉 See also: Why ASAP Rocky F kin Problems Still Runs the Club Over a Decade Later
From Crestwood Elementary to the Grammys
If you walked into Crestwood Elementary in Meridian a year ago, you would’ve seen Jamal Roberts blowing a whistle and organizing kickball games.
Now? He’s a Grammy nominee.
His coronation single, "Heal," which he also performed during that finale night, shot to No. 1 on the Billboard Hot Gospel Songs chart. But the real shocker came in late 2025 when the 68th Grammy nominations were announced. Jamal landed a nod for Best Gospel Performance/Song for a live version of "Still," a collaboration with Jonathan McReynolds.
He is the first Idol winner since Jordin Sparks to get a Grammy nod so quickly after their season.
Jamal's 2025-2026 Milestone Tracker
- May 18, 2025: Wins American Idol Season 23 with 26M votes.
- October 2025: Releases "Nothing Compares," his first post-show original.
- December 2025: Receives his first Grammy nomination.
- January 19, 2026: Scheduled to sing the National Anthem at the College Football Playoff National Championship in Miami.
What Most People Get Wrong About His "Overnight" Success
People love the "P.E. teacher turned superstar" narrative. It's clean. It's easy. But it’s also sorta wrong.
This wasn't his first rodeo. Jamal actually auditioned for Idol twice before. Once as a teenager where he was told he was too "green," and another time where he didn't even make it past the producers because he didn't have a backup song ready.
✨ Don't miss: Ashley My 600 Pound Life Now: What Really Happened to the Show’s Most Memorable Ashleys
He also placed in the top three on BET’s Sunday Best in 2020.
He’s been grinding in the church circuit for years. He’s the grandson of a bishop and a deacon. He was "in church every time the door opened," as he told Billboard. That "first time" we saw him on national TV wasn't his beginning; it was his harvest.
Actionable Insights for Aspiring Artists
Looking at Jamal’s trajectory, there are a few things you can actually apply if you're trying to break into the industry today.
Master the Pivot
Jamal didn't stay in the gospel box. He sang Rick James ("Mary Jane") for his audition. He sang Carrie Underwood. He sang Sam Cooke. If you want to win a mass-market audience, you have to show them you can speak their musical language without losing your own accent.
Feedback is a Gift, Not an Insult
When the Idol judges told him "no" years ago, he didn't post a rant on X (Twitter). He went back to Mississippi, taught gym, and practiced. He used the "no" as a roadmap.
Authenticity Over Polish
In a world of Auto-Tune and AI-generated tracks, Jamal’s appeal is his raw, sometimes "un-perfect" delivery. Don't over-edit your art. People crave the cracks in the voice because that’s where the soul lives.
Next Steps for Fans:
If you want to keep up with his journey, watch his upcoming National Anthem performance at the Hard Rock Stadium on January 19, 2026. It’s being arranged by Adam Blackstone, the same guy who does the Super Bowl shows, so expect something massive. Also, keep an eye on the Grammy Awards in February; a win there would make him the first Idol winner to take home a trophy in their debut year since the early 2000s.