If you were watching the draft back in 2016, you knew Jalen Ramsey was going to be a problem. He didn't just walk into the league; he strutted. Since being picked fifth overall by the Jaguars, he has basically lived in the Pro Bowl and locked down every WR1 from Hopkins to Jefferson. But here is the thing about the jalen ramsey rookie card market: it’s weirdly undervalued compared to guys who haven’t won half as much as he has.
He’s a Super Bowl champion. He has been a First-team All-Pro three times. Honestly, if you're looking for a defensive cornerstone for your collection, his cards are the literal definition of "underrated." Most people chase quarterbacks until they're broke, but smart collectors are quietly stashing high-grade Ramsey parallels while the prices are still reasonable.
The 2016 Panini Prizm Jalen Ramsey Rookie Card Hierarchy
When people talk about a "true" rookie, they usually mean Prizm. It’s the gold standard. For Ramsey, card #291 is the one you’ll see most often. The base card is fine for a starter, but if you want something that actually holds value, you've gotta look at the Silver Prizms.
Silvers are the lifeblood of this hobby. They have that clean, refractive shine that collectors obsess over. A PSA 10 Silver Jalen Ramsey is basically a blue-chip stock at this point. But it goes deeper. Panini went crazy with parallels in 2016. You have the Red White & Blue Discos, the Orange Prizms numbered to /299, and the super-short-print stuff like the Camo /25 or the Gold /10.
I actually saw a Camo Prizm PSA 10 sell for over $300 recently. That might sound like a lot for a defensive back, but compare that to a mediocre quarterback’s rookie card, and it’s a steal.
Why the Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Hits Different
Donruss Optic is Prizm’s cooler, slightly more vintage-feeling cousin. The jalen ramsey rookie card in this set (#171) features that iconic "Rated Rookie" logo in the corner. For a lot of us, that logo just feels right.
📖 Related: Vince Carter Meme I Got One More: The Story Behind the Internet's Favorite Comeback
The Optic Holos are the equivalent of Prizm Silvers. They’re shiny, they’re tough to grade because of surface scratches, and they look incredible in a slab. If you're really hunting for the big fish, you're looking for the Blue (/149), Red (/99), or the Gold (/10). These aren't just cards; they're low-population assets.
The 2016 Donruss Optic Silver Holo Rated Rookie is particularly sought after. It’s got a lower pop count in high grades than you’d expect. This makes it a prime target for anyone betting on Ramsey’s eventual Hall of Fame induction.
High-End Hits: National Treasures and Contenders
If you have a bigger budget, you stop looking at plastic and start looking at cardboard with ink on it. Panini Contenders is where the "Rookie Ticket" lives. Ramsey’s card #102 is the one. It’s an on-card autograph, which is a huge deal for serious collectors.
There is just something about the design of a Contenders Ticket. It’s classic. You've got the base autograph, but then you get into the Cracked Ice versions. Cracked Ice is arguably the most beautiful parallel in the entire hobby. They are numbered to /24 or /25 depending on the year, and they are notoriously hard to find.
- National Treasures: This is the "luxury" tier. We're talking patches the size of a postage stamp—sometimes with a piece of the NFL shield or a jersey swatch.
- Select: People sleep on Select. Card #189 (Premier Level) or #44 (Concourse) offer different tiers of rarity. The "XRC" cards from the year prior are also a thing, but the 2016 Select Silver Prizms are the ones that actually move.
- Limited: You might find some cool booklet cards or "Draft Day" signatures here. They’re niche, but the Nike Swoosh 1/1 versions are the holy grail for Ramsey fans.
Grading: Is It Worth the Wait?
Look, grading a jalen ramsey rookie card is a gamble, but usually a necessary one. If you have a raw card sitting in a shoebox, it might be worth $20. If that same card comes back from PSA or BGS as a 10, that price could triple or quadruple.
👉 See also: Finding the Best Texas Longhorns iPhone Wallpaper Without the Low-Res Junk
Corners and centering are the killers on 2016 Prizm. Those cards were notorious for being cut slightly off-center. If you look at the back of a Ramsey Prizm and the "Prizm" logo is hugging the edge, don't bother sending it in. You’re looking for a 50/50 or 60/40 split at worst.
Honestly, even a PSA 9 is a solid "hold" for a player of his caliber. Defensive players don't get the same "10 or bust" treatment that QBs do, which is kinda nice for the average collector's wallet.
Market Outlook for 2026 and Beyond
Ramsey has moved around a bit—Jacksonville, LA, Miami, and now his stint with the Pittsburgh Steelers. Normally, trades hurt a player's card value. Fans get bitter. But Ramsey is different because he wins everywhere he goes.
His move to Pittsburgh actually gave his market a little "Steel Curtain" bump. Collectors in Pittsburgh are intense. They love defense. Seeing Ramsey in a black and gold jersey has sparked renewed interest in his Jaguars-era rookie cards.
The biggest catalyst for his card prices will be his retirement and subsequent Hall of Fame eligibility. He’s basically a lock. When a player gets that gold jacket, their rookie cards usually see a 25-50% jump in interest as the "Legacy" collectors move in.
✨ Don't miss: Why Isn't Mbappe Playing Today: The Real Madrid Crisis Explained
Spotting Fakes and What to Avoid
You’ve gotta be careful on eBay. People will list cards as "RP" (Reprint) in tiny text at the bottom of the description. If a 2016 Prizm Silver Jalen Ramsey looks too good to be true for $10, it’s a fake.
Check the "P" in the Prizm logo on the back. On authentic cards, the font is crisp and the gloss has a specific feel. If the card feels like a playing card from a cheap deck, run away. Also, watch out for "trimmed" cards. Some people will shave the edges to make them look sharper for grading. Only buy high-value raw cards from sellers with thousands of positive reviews.
Actionable Strategy for Collectors
If you want to get into the jalen ramsey rookie card game right now, don't just buy the first thing you see.
Start by targeting 2016 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Holos. They are currently priced lower than Prizm Silvers but have a very similar long-term upside. If you find one with good centering, buy it raw and send it to PSA.
For those with a bit more cash, look for 2016 Panini Prizm Orange /299. These are rare enough to be "special" but common enough that you can actually find them for sale. Avoid the lower-end sets like Score or Prestige if you're looking for an investment. They’re great for a personal collection, but they don't have the "legs" that Prizm, Optic, or Select have in the secondary market.
Keep an eye on the population reports. A "low pop" card (meaning few have been graded a 10) is always going to be more valuable than a "high pop" base card. Focus on quality over quantity, and you'll likely be very happy with your Ramsey stash in five years.