Ever been watching a movie and thought, "Oh, I love Jaime Pressly in this," only to realize fifteen minutes later it's actually Margot Robbie? Don't worry. You're definitely not alone. It’s one of those Hollywood glitches in the matrix that people just can't stop talking about.
Honestly, the jaime pressly margot robbie look alike phenomenon is so strong it feels like they were built from the same DNA blueprint. They have the same razor-sharp jawline, those piercing blue eyes, and a specific "don't mess with me" energy that works just as well in a trailer park comedy as it does on a high-fashion red carpet.
But even though they look like they were separated at birth, their lives are worlds apart.
The Internet's Favorite Doppelgängers
Social media basically explodes every time a side-by-side photo of these two pops up. It's wild. One's from a small town in North Carolina, and the other grew up on a farm in Queensland, Australia. Yet, if you put them in the same room, you'd swear you were seeing double.
Most people first noticed the resemblance when Margot Robbie blew up in The Wolf of Wall Street. Everyone was like, "Wait, is that Joy from My Name Is Earl?"
It wasn't.
👉 See also: Patricia Neal and Gary Cooper: The Affair That Nearly Broke Hollywood
Jaime Pressly has been a household name since the late '90s. She’s an Emmy winner with a massive career in sitcoms like Mom. Margot, meanwhile, is the blockbuster queen who brought Barbie to life.
What’s the actual age difference?
This is where it gets interesting. Jaime was born in 1977. Margot was born in 1990.
That’s a 13-year gap.
When Jaime was winning awards for playing the iconic, high-heeled spitfire Joy Turner, Margot was still a teenager in Australia. The reason they look so similar isn't just the blonde hair or the blue eyes; it's the bone structure. They both have that classic, "Golden Age of Hollywood" face that looks expensive and timeless.
That time they finally met
For years, fans begged for a photo of them together. They finally got it at a 2018 awards season party. Jaime actually posted about it, and the internet nearly broke.
✨ Don't miss: What Really Happened With the Death of John Candy: A Legacy of Laughter and Heartbreak
Jaime is totally cool with the comparison, too. When a photographer once asked her about looking like Margot, she joked, "Right, right, well that would be she looks like me!"
Technically, she's right. Jaime was the original.
It’s not just them: The "Margot Multiverse"
The crazy thing is that the jaime pressly margot robbie look alike debate is just the tip of the iceberg. Hollywood apparently has a "type." There’s a whole group of actresses that people constantly mix up with these two.
- Emma Mackey: The Sex Education star looks so much like Margot that they actually cast her in the Barbie movie as a meta-joke.
- Samara Weaving: Another Australian blonde powerhouse. She gets mistaken for Margot so often she's admitted she sometimes just stops correcting people at the airport because it's easier.
- Jaime King: People often confuse the two "Jaimes" first, then loop Margot into the mix.
It's like a family tree where everyone is a different version of the same person.
How to actually tell them apart
If you want to win the next trivia night or just stop looking silly in front of the TV, here are the "tells."
🔗 Read more: Is There Actually a Wife of Tiger Shroff? Sorting Fact from Viral Fiction
The Voice
This is the easiest one. Margot Robbie is Australian. Even when she’s doing a perfect Brooklyn accent for Harley Quinn, her natural voice is pure Aussie. Jaime Pressly has a distinct, soulful Southern lilt. Even when she’s not playing a "Southern belle," you can hear North Carolina in her vowels.
The Eyebrows
Look closely at the brows. Margot tends to keep hers a bit fuller and more "modern fashion." Jaime’s are often arched a bit higher, giving her that classic comedic "expressive" look that made her so good in sitcoms.
The Roles
If the character is a bit of a "hot mess" with a heart of gold in a 30-minute comedy, it’s probably Jaime. If it’s a high-stakes drama or a massive superhero flick, you’re likely looking at Margot.
Why this matters for their careers
Resemblance in Hollywood can be a double-edged sword. Sometimes it helps you get a foot in the door because you have a "bankable" look. Other times, it can be annoying to be constantly compared to someone else.
But for Jaime and Margot, it’s mostly just a fun piece of pop culture trivia. Jaime is a legend in the TV world, and Margot is a powerhouse producer and movie star. They’ve both carved out totally unique paths despite sharing the same face.
One thing is for sure: if a studio ever needs to cast a movie about sisters who haven't seen each other in twenty years, the casting director only needs to make two phone calls.
Practical Next Steps
- Watch the "Original": If you only know Margot, go back and watch My Name Is Earl. Jaime Pressly’s comedic timing is world-class and shows why she’s an Emmy winner in her own right.
- Check out the "Multiverse": Watch Ready or Not starring Samara Weaving. You’ll spend the first ten minutes convinced it’s a Margot Robbie horror movie.
- Compare the Styles: Look at their red carpet history. While they share a face, their fashion senses are totally different—Margot leans into high-fashion Chanel, while Jaime often goes for more classic, sleek Hollywood glam.