If you’ve lived in New York City long enough, you know the specific, frantic energy of a Jack’s. It’s that "Jack’s World" vibe. You walk in for a pack of AA batteries and walk out with a 10-pound bag of pistachios, a designer shower curtain, and a specific brand of British cookies you haven't seen since 2004. But lately, finding Jack's 99 cent store locations feels like a high-stakes game of hide-and-seek.
People get confused. They hear "99 cent store" and think of the massive California-based "99 Cents Only" chain that went bankrupt and closed all its doors in 2024. That’s not this. Jack’s is a New York beast. It’s an institution that has survived skyrocketing Manhattan rents and the "retail apocalypse" by being weirder and faster than its competition.
Where Are the Jack's Locations Now?
Right now, the footprint has shifted. You can't just stumble into the old massive multi-floor spots like you used to. As of early 2026, the brand has consolidated. They’ve moved. They've evolved.
The heart of the operation is still near the transit hubs. If you're looking for the flagship experience, you’re heading to 110 West 32nd Street. It’s right there by Penn Station. It stays busy. Honestly, the foot traffic alone is enough to make a suburban mall manager weep. It’s open 7:30 AM to 8:00 PM most weekdays, though they lean into "Winter Hours" sometimes, so don't be shocked if they close at 7:00 PM on a random rainy Tuesday.
Then there’s the Midtown presence. For a while, everyone went to the East 40th Street spot. That’s 16 East 40th Street, near the New York Public Library. It’s still a staple. But the real news lately has been the West Side move. The "New" Jack’s is at 223 West 40th Street. This is the one people miss because they’re still walking toward the old storefronts that have been papered over for months.
The Weird Truth About the 99 Cent Name
Here’s the thing: calling it a 99 cent store is basically a lie now. A nostalgic one, but a lie. You’ll find things for a dollar, sure. But you’ll also find $40 air fryers and $15 bed sheets.
Ira Steinberg, the guy behind the curtain for years, once basically admitted the business model is "buy what others can't sell." When a big-box retailer overorders or a brand changes its packaging, Jack’s swoops in. That’s why you see name brands—Black & Decker, Hormel, Revlon—at prices that feel like they fell off the back of a truck. They didn't. It’s just "closeout" magic.
The secret sauce is turnover. They don't want a pallet of cookies sitting there for a month. They want it gone in 72 hours. If a lipstick doesn't move at 99 cents, they’ll literally bundle them ten for a dollar just to clear the shelf space. It’s ruthless efficiency masked by a bit of chaotic shelving.
Why Some Locations Vanished
You might remember the one on 45th Street. Or the sprawling Annexes. Why did they go?
Manhattan real estate is a bloodbath. Even a store making $30 million a year—which Jack's has done historically across its small fleet—can get squeezed by a triple-net lease renewal. When the 31st Street location profile changed to "Rented" or "Available" on commercial real estate sites, a lot of locals thought the brand was dying.
It wasn't. It was just trimming the fat.
In the discount world, if a store isn't pulling its weight per square foot, you kill it. You move the inventory to the high-performers. That’s why the 32nd Street and 40th Street corridors are the survivors. They capture the commuters. They capture the office workers who need a cheap lunch or a last-minute umbrella.
Survival in the Age of Dollar Tree
You've probably noticed Dollar Tree taking over the husks of other discount chains. They bought up a huge chunk of those 99 Cents Only leases out west. But Jack’s stays independent. It’s a family-run vibe, even if it’s a big business.
They also jumped into the 21st century—kinda. You can actually order from the 40th Street Jack’s on Mercato now. Seeing "99 cent" items available for delivery in a Manhattan high-rise is the ultimate 2026 irony, but it’s how they stay relevant.
What You Should Actually Do
If you’re planning a trip to hit up these Jack's 99 cent store locations, don't just wing it.
- Check the West 40th spot first. It’s the newest and usually has the cleanest layout.
- Go early. The 32nd Street location gets absolutely mobbed by commuters between 4:30 PM and 6:00 PM. If you want to actually see the "hidden" designer deals, 10:00 AM on a Wednesday is your golden window.
- Ignore the signs. The signs might say "Everything 99 Cents" in the window. Look at the price tags. Inflation hit everyone, even Jack.
- Bring a bag. NYC’s bag laws are strict, and while they’ll sell you a reusable one, it’ll eat into your savings.
The landscape of discount shopping in New York is always changing. One day a storefront is a Jack's, the next it's a weed dispensary or a bank. But for now, the 32nd and 40th Street anchors are holding the line. If you need cheap groceries, weird European snacks, or a random hammer, you know where to go.
Just don't expect to actually spend only 99 cents.
💡 You might also like: Duracell in Fairburn GA: What You Need to Know About the CopperTop Logistics Hub
Next Steps
You should verify the specific "Winter Hours" for the 32nd Street location before heading out, as they often shift their closing times based on seasonal foot traffic. If you're looking for specific grocery items, checking their Mercato listing can give you a real-time look at what's actually on the shelves today.