When you think of 80s cinema, you think of powerhouses. You think of heavy hitters. Jack Nicholson and Meryl Streep are the absolute peak of that mountain. People often assume they must have a dozen films together, a long-running rivalry, or a shared mantle of Oscars for a decade of collaboration.
Honestly? They only made two movies together.
Just two. Both arrived in a tiny window between 1986 and 1987. It was a weird, lightning-fast blip where the most "serious" actress in the world met the most "unpredictable" actor in Hollywood. They haven't shared a frame since. If you're looking for Jack Nicholson movies with Meryl Streep, you aren't looking for a franchise. You're looking at a very specific, very intense era of American filmmaking that produced two radically different projects: a biting Manhattan comedy and a bleak, freezing drama about life on the streets.
The messy brilliance of Heartburn (1986)
The first time they teamed up was for Heartburn. This wasn't just any movie; it was Nora Ephron essentially venting about the collapse of her marriage to Carl Bernstein. Mike Nichols directed it. On paper, this was a "can't miss" situation.
Jack wasn't even the first choice. Mandy Patinkin was originally cast as the philandering husband, Mark Forman. But after a few days of shooting, Mike Nichols realized the chemistry wasn't hitting. He fired Patinkin and called Jack.
👉 See also: Ted Nugent State of Shock: Why This 1979 Album Divides Fans Today
Why the movie is kind of a fever dream
The plot is pretty straightforward. Rachel (Streep) is a food writer. Mark (Nicholson) is a political columnist. They meet at a wedding, fall in love, buy a fixer-upper in D.C., and then—predictably—everything goes south. Mark starts sleeping around while Rachel is pregnant with their second child.
- The Vibe: It’s sharp. It’s funny in a way that hurts.
- The Famous Scene: Meryl Streep smashing a key lime pie into Jack Nicholson’s face.
- The Realism: Streep actually used her own toddler, Mamie Gummer, in the film to make the maternal scenes feel authentic.
Critics at the time were... let’s say "mixed." Roger Ebert famously called it a "bitter, sour movie." He felt like these two actors had too much chemistry to play people who had no chemistry. It’s a paradox. You’ve got Jack being charmingly sleazy and Meryl being dowdy and vulnerable. It shouldn't work, but it captures that specific 80s New York media-elite anxiety perfectly.
The freezing reality of Ironweed (1987)
If Heartburn was about rich people with problems, Ironweed was the complete opposite. It’s a heavy, gray, soul-crushing adaptation of William Kennedy’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel.
They play Francis and Helen, two homeless drifters in Depression-era Albany. Jack is a man haunted by the literal ghosts of his past—including an infant son he accidentally dropped years prior. Meryl is a former singer, now terminally ill and living in a fantasy world of her former glory.
✨ Don't miss: Mike Judge Presents: Tales from the Tour Bus Explained (Simply)
The intensity on set
This wasn't a "glamorous" shoot. They filmed in Albany in the dead of winter. It was brutal.
To prepare for a scene where her character is a corpse in a hotel room, Meryl Streep reportedly hugged a massive bag of ice for half an hour. She wanted her skin to be gray and her body to be physically cold to the touch. That’s the level of commitment we're talking about here.
Jack, meanwhile, turned down his "Jack-ness." He’s quiet. He’s stoic. He lets the grief sit in his eyes rather than shouting it from the rooftops. It earned both of them Oscar nominations, though the movie itself bombed at the box office. People in 1987 apparently weren't lining up to see two hours of crushing poverty and alcoholic despair during the Christmas season. Go figure.
Why haven't they worked together since?
It’s the question everyone asks. After two back-to-back movies where they clearly respected each other’s craft, why the silence?
🔗 Read more: Big Brother 27 Morgan: What Really Happened Behind the Scenes
Part of it is just the trajectory of their careers. Jack started taking fewer roles as the 90s rolled on, leaning into more "Jack" performances in movies like As Good as It Gets or The Departed. Meryl, conversely, entered a phase of extreme transformation and eventually became the most nominated actor in history.
There's also the "oxygen" factor. When you put two stars of this magnitude in one room, they can sometimes cancel each other out. In Heartburn, they were almost too big for the small, domestic story. In Ironweed, they were so submerged in the characters that the "star power" was deliberately muffled.
Where to start with their collaboration
If you haven't seen either, don't start with Ironweed on a rainy Tuesday unless you want to feel miserable for a week.
- Watch Heartburn first. It’s a great time capsule. The dialogue is snappy (it's Nora Ephron, after all), and seeing Jack Nicholson try to navigate a kitchen is objectively funny.
- Move to Ironweed for the "Masterclass." This is where you see why they are considered the best. Meryl’s scene singing "He's My Pal" in a dive bar—where the lighting shifts to show her fantasy vs. her reality—is one of the best single minutes of acting in the 20th century.
Your next steps:
To really appreciate the range Jack and Meryl showed during this two-year stint, watch Heartburn followed by Postcards from the Edge. It shows how Streep took that Ephron-style energy and evolved it. For Jack, pair Ironweed with The Witches of Eastwick (released the same year). It’s wild to see him play a broken vagrant and the literal Devil in the same twelve-month span. Both films are currently available on most major VOD platforms for rent or purchase.