Jessica Fletcher has seen some weird stuff. She's survived dozens of trips to New York, international espionage plots, and the high-stakes world of Cabot Cove real estate, but It's a Dog's Life Murder She Wrote is in a league of its own. It’s the episode where a dog becomes a millionaire. Seriously.
If you grew up watching Angela Lansbury solve crimes between commercials for Werther's Original, you probably remember this one. It’s Season 6, Episode 1. It aired in September 1989. It was a weird time for the show. The writers were experimenting with "bookend" episodes where Jessica barely appeared, but this specific hour was a full-on Jessica mystery. It just happened to involve a Bassett Hound named Teddy.
Honestly, it’s one of the most polarizing episodes in the entire twelve-season run. You either love the campy absurdity of a canine beneficiary, or you think the show jumped the shark right here.
The Absurd Setup of It's a Dog's Life Murder She Wrote
The plot is peak 80s TV. Jessica is visiting a wealthy friend, Abigail Austin, played by the legendary June Havoc. Abigail is one of those eccentric rich women who populate the Murder, She Wrote universe—people who have more money than sense and a house full of relatives who want them dead.
Abigail decides to leave her massive fortune to her dog, Teddy. Naturally, the human relatives are livid. They’re basically circling like vultures before the poor woman is even cold. When Abigail eventually dies—seemingly of natural causes at first—things get messy fast.
The "will" isn't just a quirk; it's the engine of the entire mystery. People often forget that the dog wasn't just a mascot; he was the legal wall between the heirs and their inheritance. If Teddy died, the money went to the kids. You can guess what happens next. Someone tries to poison the dog. It’s dark, but in that cozy, sanitized CBS way.
Why This Episode Felt Different
Most Murder, She Wrote episodes follow a strict formula. Jessica arrives, someone she knows (usually a nephew or a distant cousin) gets framed, and she finds a loose thread in a sweater or a misplaced glass of sherry to solve it.
👉 See also: The Entire History of You: What Most People Get Wrong About the Grain
But in It's a Dog's Life Murder She Wrote, the stakes feel strangely low and high at the same time. We aren't just looking for a killer; we’re watching a satirical takedown of greedy families. The guest cast is a "who’s who" of character actors. You’ve got Bill Maher—yes, that Bill Maher—playing Rick Selby. Seeing a young Maher in a 1980s mystery procedural is a fever dream on its own. He’s smarmy, he’s biting, and he fits the "disgruntled heir" vibe perfectly.
Then there’s the dog.
Teddy the Bassett Hound is actually a great actor. His soulful eyes and droopy ears do a lot of the heavy lifting in scenes where the human actors are chewing the scenery. The episode leans heavily into the "dog's eye view," which was a bold choice for a show that usually focused on forensic details and high-society gossip.
The Mystery Mechanics: How Jessica Solves It
The murder method in this episode is classic Peter S. Fischer (the show's co-creator and frequent writer). It involves digitalis. It involves a "fixed" medical report. It involves the kind of subtle clue that you’d miss if you were getting up to make tea.
What’s interesting about the solution in It's a Dog's Life Murder She Wrote is how Jessica uses the dog's behavior to suss out the truth. Dogs don’t lie. Humans do. Jessica realizes that the dog's reaction—or lack thereof—to certain people and events points toward the real culprit.
The actual killer is [SPOILER] the family doctor, Dr. Alan Erhardt. His motive? It wasn't just the money; it was the manipulation of the estate. He thought he could outsmart a mystery writer and a hound. He was wrong.
✨ Don't miss: Shamea Morton and the Real Housewives of Atlanta: What Really Happened to Her Peach
Key Players in the Episode
- Angela Lansbury as Jessica Fletcher (obviously).
- June Havoc as Abigail Austin (the eccentric dog lover).
- Bill Maher as Rick Selby (the sarcastic relative).
- Dan O'Herlihy as Alexander (the butler/loyal friend).
- Teddy as himself (the millionaire dog).
The Legacy of the "Dog Episode"
Why do we still talk about this? Because it’s emblematic of the "Cozy Mystery" genre’s willingness to go absolutely off the rails. It’s a Dog's Life Murder She Wrote isn't just an episode; it’s a time capsule. It represents the era of television where a plot about a dog inheriting millions was considered a solid Sunday night lead-in.
Critics at the time were mixed. Some felt the show was losing its edge by focusing on "stunt" plots. Others loved the humor. Today, it ranks high on "weirdest episode" lists. It’s a fan favorite for "Watch Parties" because the dialogue is so wonderfully dramatic for a story about a Bassett Hound's trust fund.
It also highlights the E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) of the show’s production. Even with a goofy premise, the technical aspects—the lighting, the pacing, and Lansbury's grounded performance—keep it from becoming a total farce. Lansbury treats the dog with the same respect she gives a Scotland Yard detective. That’s why it works.
Debunking the Myths
There are a few things people get wrong about this episode.
First, people often think this was a "Bookend" episode. It wasn't. Those were the episodes where Jessica only appeared in the intro and outro to tell a story about someone else. This was a full Jessica Fletcher investigation.
Second, some fans confuse this with the other "animal" episodes. There was one with a horse, and another with a cat, but the Bassett Hound in It's a Dog's Life Murder She Wrote is the only one that was a primary heir to a fortune.
🔗 Read more: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
Third, the "Bill Maher" factor. People think he was just a cameo. He actually has a significant role. It’s one of his best early acting gigs, showing off the cynical persona he’d eventually ride to fame on HBO.
How to Watch and What to Look For
If you’re going back to rewatch this on Peacock or Freevee, keep your eyes on the background. The Austin estate is a masterclass in 80s set design. It’s all brass, floral wallpaper, and heavy drapes.
Pay attention to:
- The Dog’s Cues: Notice how the camera lingers on Teddy. The director clearly wanted the dog to be a "character" with internal thoughts.
- The Wardrobe: Jessica’s outfits in this episode are particularly sharp. The 1989 shoulder pads are in full effect.
- The Red Herrings: The script does a great job of making you hate every single family member, which makes the reveal of the doctor even more satisfying.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Writers
If you’re a fan of the genre or a writer looking to capture that Murder, She Wrote magic, there are a few takeaways from this specific episode.
- Embrace the Absurd: Don't be afraid of a "gimmick" if the core mystery is solid. A dog heir is silly, but a murder over money is universal.
- Character is King: The mystery works because Jessica stays in character. She doesn't treat the situation as a joke, even if the audience does.
- The Power of the Guest Star: A strong ensemble can elevate a thin plot. The chemistry between Lansbury and the "heirs" makes the stakes feel real.
The best way to appreciate this piece of TV history is to view it as a bridge between the classic whodunit and the more experimental television of the 90s. It’s a Dog's Life Murder She Wrote might be campy, but it’s executed with a level of professionalism that modern procedurals often lack.
To dive deeper into the world of Cabot Cove, start by tracking the Season 6 transition. This was the year the show moved Jessica to New York for part of the time, changing the visual language of the series forever. Compare the "mansion mysteries" like this one to the "urban mysteries" later in the season. You'll see a clear shift in how the writers handled Jessica's fish-out-of-water status. Also, look for the recurring theme of "unconventional wills" throughout the series; this episode wasn't the last time a legal document caused a body count.