Honestly, being a fan of the Italian men's national soccer team lately feels like being in a long-distance relationship with someone who keeps "finding themselves" at your expense. One minute you're on top of the world at Wembley, and the next, you’re watching the World Cup from your couch for the second—now potentially third—time in a row. It's exhausting.
But here’s the thing: while the headlines are all about the "chaos" and the coaching changes, something weirdly interesting is actually happening behind the scenes.
The Post-Spalletti Identity Crisis
Let’s talk about the elephant in the room. Luciano Spalletti is gone. After that mess of a Euro 2024 exit against Switzerland and a rocky start to the 2026 World Cup qualifiers, the FIGC pulled the plug. It was messy.
Spalletti, the tactical genius who brought the Scudetto back to Naples, just couldn't make the Azzurri click. He banned PlayStations, he talked about "Italianness," but on the pitch? It was flat. Now, we've got Gennaro Gattuso at the helm.
Yes, that Gattuso. The man who looks like he lives on espresso and pure spite.
It’s a massive gamble. People think Gattuso is just a "grit and grind" guy because of how he played, but his coaching is surprisingly technical. He wants the ball. He wants high pressing. Whether he can actually get this specific group of players to do that without losing their minds is the $6 million question.
What’s Actually Going Wrong on the Pitch?
If you look at the 2026 World Cup qualifying table, it's enough to make you want to hide under the covers. Italy is currently sitting in second place in Group I, trailing Norway by a decent margin.
💡 You might also like: NFL Pick 'em Predictions: Why You're Probably Overthinking the Divisional Round
Losing 3-0 to Norway in the opener was a wake-up call that apparently nobody heard. Erling Haaland basically treated the Italian defense like a set of training cones. It wasn't just a loss; it was an embarrassment.
The stats tell a grim story:
- Goal Difference: We’re struggling to put away "easy" teams like Estonia and Moldova with any real authority.
- Defense: We’ve only kept one clean sheet in the last several competitive matches. For a country that practically invented Catenaccio, that’s a sin.
- Consistency: One week we beat Israel 3-0, the next we’re losing 4-1 at home to Norway. It’s a rollercoaster no one asked to ride.
The "Norway Problem" is real. We have to host them in the final group game, and with our inferior goal difference, it’s basically a must-win or we’re headed back to the playoffs. And we all know what happens to Italy in the playoffs. Flashbacks to North Macedonia intensified.
The "Icon" Gap: Where Are the Superstars?
In 2006, you had Buffon, Cannavaro, Pirlo, Totti, and Del Piero. You could walk into any sports bar in the world, say those names, and everyone knew you were talking about the best.
Now? We have "solid" players.
Gianluigi Donnarumma is still world-class, even if his club form at PSG fluctuates. But he can't score the goals. Up front, we’re leaning heavily on Mateo Retegui and Moise Kean. Retegui has been a godsend—nine goal contributions recently is nothing to sniff at—but he’s not prime Christian Vieri. Not yet, anyway.
📖 Related: Why the Marlins Won World Series Titles Twice and Then Disappeared
Then there’s the midfield. Sandro Tonali is back and looks hungry, and Nicolò Barella is still the heartbeat of the team. But there’s a lack of "fear factor." Teams don’t show up to the San Siro or the Olimpico shaking in their boots anymore. They show up thinking they can nick a point, and lately, they’re right.
The Youth Movement (The Only Reason to Stay Hopeful)
If you want a reason to not give up on the Italian men's national soccer team just yet, look at the kids.
Gattuso has been forced to integrate younger talent faster than Spalletti did. Pio Esposito is only 20 but looks like he belongs. Riccardo Calafiori is a ball-playing center-back that actually fits the modern game. We’re finally stoping the obsession with "experience" and actually letting the fast, technical kids play.
It’s risky. They make mistakes. But watching Calafiori carry the ball out of defense is a lot more exciting than watching a 35-year-old veteran hoof it into the stands.
What Most People Get Wrong About the "Azzurri"
The common narrative is that "Italian soccer is dead."
It’s not. Inter Milan, AC Milan, and Juventus are still deep in European competitions. The talent is there. The problem is the bridge between the clubs and the national setup.
👉 See also: Why Funny Fantasy Football Names Actually Win Leagues
The FIGC has been under fire for years about grassroots development. While France and Spain have clear "pipelines" from U-16 to the senior team, Italy’s path is more like a maze. We rely too much on "episodes" or individual moments of brilliance rather than a sustainable system.
Gattuso’s job isn't just to win games; it’s to fix the culture. He’s already started by being brutally honest in press conferences. No more excuses about the grass or the referee. He’s putting it on the players.
What Really Happens Next?
The roadmap to the 2026 World Cup is incredibly narrow. Here is the reality of the situation:
- The Norway Finale: Everything hinges on the home game against Norway. If Italy wins, they likely top the group on points. If they draw or lose, it’s the playoffs.
- The Playoff Nightmare: The new playoff format is a gauntlet. One bad night, one deflected shot, and Italy misses a third straight World Cup. The psychological weight of that would be catastrophic for the sport in Italy.
- The Tactical Shift: Keep an eye on the 4-3-3. Gattuso is moving away from the back-three experiments. He wants width. He wants Zaccagni and Raspadori to actually take players on.
Actionable Steps for the "Tifosi"
If you’re following the Italian men's national soccer team, stop looking at the FIFA rankings. They’re a lie. Instead, watch the development of the individual components.
- Track the Retegui-Kean partnership: If these two can actually form a chemistry, Italy has a chance. We haven't had a consistent strike duo in a decade.
- Monitor the injury list: Our depth is paper-thin. If Barella or Bastoni goes down, the house of cards starts to wobble.
- Watch the March friendlies: These aren't just "meaningless" games. These are the only times Gattuso gets to drill his "no-nonsense" philosophy into a squad that has looked mentally fragile for three years.
The Italian men's national soccer team is at a crossroads. It’s not just about qualifying for a tournament; it’s about proving that the four stars on the jersey still mean something. We’re in for a very stressful 2026.
Check the upcoming match schedule for the qualifiers and make sure your heart medication is up to date. This is going to be a bumpy ride.