Music is weird. One year a song is a massive hit, and the next, it’s basically background noise for a CVS pharmacy. But then you’ve got the It Had to Be You original version from 1924, a song that refuses to die. It’s been over a century. Think about that. Most things from 1924 are literally dust, yet this melody is still the go-to for every wedding, rom-com, and late-night jazz session. Honestly, if you’ve ever felt like someone was "the one" despite them being kind of a pain in the neck, you understand why this song works.
It wasn’t born in a vacuum. It came from the minds of Isham Jones and Gus Kahn. Jones did the music, and Kahn handled the lyrics. They weren’t trying to change the world; they were just writing a pop song for the 1920s. But they accidentally stumbled onto a psychological truth about love that we’re still obsessed with today.
The Men Who Made the It Had to Be You Original
Isham Jones was a big deal. He led one of the most popular dance bands in the United States during the early twenties. He wasn't some avant-garde experimentalist; he knew how to make people move their feet. When he sat down to write the music for the It Had to Be You original track, he used a structural trick that musicologists still talk about. It’s got this chromatic movement—a sort of "sliding" feel—that makes the melody feel both inevitable and surprising.
Gus Kahn was the word guy. If you’ve seen the movie I'll See You in My Dreams, you know his story. He wrote "Dream a Little Dream of Me" and "Ain't We Got Fun." He had this knack for writing lyrics that sounded like something a real person would actually say while they were slightly drunk or very in love. He didn't use flowery, poetic metaphors about Greek gods. He wrote about "others I've seen" who might be better looking or nicer, but ultimately, they just didn't "do."
It’s that honesty that sticks.
👉 See also: Josh and Maddie: What Really Happened on Liv and Maddie
The first person to actually record it was Sam Lanin and his Orchestra for the Okeh label in March 1924. But the version that really blew the doors off the hinges was Isham Jones's own recording with his orchestra later that same year. It stayed at number one on the charts for five weeks. In 1924, that was an eternity. It was the "Old Town Road" of the roaring twenties, just with more saxophones and fewer horses.
Why the Lyrics Still Feel Relatable (and Kinda Brutal)
Most love songs are about how perfect the other person is. They’re "angelic" or "divine." The It Had to Be You original lyrics take a totally different path. They’re actually kind of mean if you think about it too hard.
"With all your faults, I love you still."
That’s the core of the song. It’s an admission that the person you love is probably a little bit of a disaster. They might be "mean" or "cross," as the lyrics suggest. They might be "bossy." But the singer concludes that "it had to be you." There’s a sense of fate involved, but not the shiny, Hallmark kind. It’s more of a "I'm stuck with you and I'm okay with that" kind of fate.
This vibe is exactly why it was the centerpiece of When Harry Met Sally. Harry and Sally are both objectively difficult people. They argue about everything from the death of a character in a book to how long it takes to order a salad. When Harry finally runs through the streets of New York on New Year's Eve, the song playing in the background—performed by Harry Connick Jr.—is a direct descendant of that 1924 original energy. It acknowledges that love is often an inconvenient choice.
The Evolution of the Sound
When you listen to the It Had to Be You original 1924 recording, it sounds thin. That’s because of the technology. They were using acoustic recording methods back then. You played into a giant horn. No microphones. No digital mixing. The balance was achieved by moving the louder instruments further away from the horn.
- The drums were usually tucked in the back so they wouldn't drown out the melody.
- The singer had to belt it out.
- The arrangements were "tight" because you couldn't fix a mistake in post-production.
If someone messed up a note, you started the whole take over. It was high-pressure.
The Best Covers That Kept the Original Spirit Alive
Over the years, hundreds of artists have tackled this. Some made it a ballad. Some made it swing. But the best ones always remember that the song is supposed to be a conversation.
Ruth Etting (1924)
She was known as the "Sweetheart of Columbia Records." Her version came out shortly after the original and gave it a feminine perspective that was just as gritty and honest. She didn't over-sing it.
Cliff Edwards (1924)
You might know him as the voice of Jiminy Cricket ("When You Wish Upon a Star"). He recorded it under the name "Ukelele Ike." It’s a stripped-down, jaunty version that reminds you the song was meant to be fun. It wasn't always a "serious" jazz standard.
Frank Sinatra (1960)
Sinatra took the song and turned it into a swaggering anthem of confidence. He recorded it with the Billy May Orchestra. By this point, the song had shifted from a pop hit to a "standard." It was part of the Great American Songbook. Sinatra’s phrasing—the way he hangs behind the beat—gives the lyrics a whole new layer of meaning.
Ray Charles (1959)
If you want to hear the soul in these chords, listen to Ray. He slows it down. He makes the "faults" mentioned in the lyrics sound like something he’s genuinely lived through. It’s less of a dance hall tune and more of a 2:00 AM confession.
Technical Nuances: Why Musicians Love It
Ask any jazz guitarist or pianist about this song, and they’ll probably mention the "turnaround."
The chord progression of the It Had to Be You original is a masterclass in tension and release. It starts on the tonic (the "home" chord), but quickly moves to chords that feel a bit unstable. This mimics the lyrics. The music feels "uncertain" just as the singer is talking about the "others" they've seen. Then, it resolves perfectly back to the home key when the singer admits it had to be "you."
It’s a perfect marriage of theory and emotion. Most people don't realize they're being manipulated by a circle of fifths, but they are. That’s why the song feels so satisfying. It creates a "problem" musically and then solves it right at the end of the phrase.
Cultural Impact: Beyond the Sheet Music
The song didn't just stay on records. it invaded every part of pop culture. It’s been in Annie Hall. It’s been in The Roaring Twenties (1939) performed by Priscilla Lane. It’s been used in cartoons, commercials, and even Looney Tunes shorts.
Why? Because it’s a shorthand.
👉 See also: Seth Rogen Glasses: The Studio and the Real Story Behind His Eyewear
Directors use the It Had to Be You original melody when they want the audience to know, "Okay, these two people are finally realizing they belong together." It’s a musical trope. But it only works because the original song was so well-constructed that it became the definitive "realization of love" anthem.
Interestingly, Isham Jones actually walked away from his band at the height of his fame to focus on songwriting. He realized that while performing was lucrative, owning the rights to a song like this was the real prize. He was right. The royalties from this single track probably outearned everything else he did in his career combined.
Common Misconceptions
People often think Frank Sinatra wrote it. He didn't.
Others think it was written specifically for When Harry Met Sally. Nope. It was already 65 years old when that movie came out in 1989.
There’s also a myth that it was written about a specific "mean" woman in Gus Kahn's life. While he certainly drew on his marriage for inspiration, Kahn was a professional songwriter. He was writing for a market. He knew that "perfect love" songs were a dime a dozen, but "real love" songs were rare.
Actionable Takeaways for Music Lovers
If you're a fan of the "Great American Songbook" or just curious about how music history works, here is how you can actually engage with the It Had to Be You original legacy today:
- Listen to the 1924 Isham Jones Recording: You can find it on archives like the Library of Congress or YouTube. Listen for the lack of a "lead singer" in the modern sense; it’s an orchestral arrangement where the instruments tell the story.
- Compare the Tempos: Play the 1924 version side-by-side with the 1989 Harry Connick Jr. version. Notice how the original is much faster. It was a dance track for the Charleston era, not a slow-dance ballad for a wedding.
- Learn the "B" Section: If you play an instrument, look at the bridge of the song. Most modern pop songs use a very simple I-IV-V progression. This song uses "secondary dominants." Learning how it's built will actually make you a better musician.
- Watch 'I'll See You in My Dreams' (1951): This is the biopic about Gus Kahn. It’s a bit "Hollywood-ized," but it gives you a great look at the songwriting industry in the early 20th century and how these hits were crafted.
The It Had to Be You original version reminds us that human emotions haven't changed much in a hundred years. We’re still falling for people who are "bossy" and "mean" because they have a certain something we can't find elsewhere. The technology changes—from wax cylinders to Spotify—but the feeling of finding "the one" is exactly the same as it was in 1924.