You’re standing in a two-hour security line at JFK. Your shoes are off, your belt is in a plastic bin, and you’re wondering why on earth you didn't just drive to Ronkonkoma. If you live on Long Island, the "big" airports are usually a trap. They’re loud, they’re expensive to park at, and the traffic on the Van Wyck is enough to ruin a vacation before it starts.
That’s why islip to orlando flights are basically the best-kept secret for anyone who hates the typical New York travel hustle. Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP) is small. Like, "you can see the exit from the gate" small. For a trip to Orlando, it’s often the difference between a stressful ordeal and a relaxed Tuesday morning.
Why the "Big Airports" Usually Fail You
Most people default to JFK or LGA because they think they’ll save fifty bucks. Honestly? By the time you pay for the Long Island Railroad, a $100 Uber, or $40-a-day parking, that "cheap" flight is suddenly costing you a fortune.
MacArthur is different. You pull up, you park, and you’re at the gate in twenty minutes. Sometimes ten if the TSA guy is having a fast day. It’s located right in the heart of Suffolk County, making it a no-brainer for anyone east of the Queens border.
🔗 Read more: The Eloise Room at The Plaza: What Most People Get Wrong
The Airlines Making the Islip to Orlando Run
You’ve actually got options now, which wasn't always the case. For a long time, it was just Southwest or bust. Now? The competition is heating up, and that’s great for your wallet.
- Southwest Airlines: They are the kings of ISP. They usually run daily nonstops to Orlando International (MCO). The best part? Two free checked bags. If you’re a family of four heading to Disney, those bag fees at other airlines can add up to $240 round-trip. Southwest just lets you bring the suitcases.
- Frontier Airlines: If you want dirt-cheap, this is it. I’ve seen one-way fares as low as $29. Just be careful. Frontier is "unbundled," which is a fancy way of saying they’ll charge you for a carry-on, a seat assignment, and probably even a smile if they could. If you can fit everything in a backpack, you’ll win.
- JetBlue: They recently jumped back into the Islip game, and people are pumped. It’s that middle-ground experience—decent legroom, free snacks, and high-speed Wi-Fi.
- Breeze Airways: These guys are the newcomers. They fly newer planes (Airbus A220s) and offer a "nicer" experience without the legacy airline price tag. They don't always fly every single day, so you have to check their specific schedule.
MCO vs. SFB: Don't Land in the Wrong Spot
When booking islip to orlando flights, most land at Orlando International Airport (MCO). That’s the big one. It’s about 20-30 minutes from Disney and Universal.
However, some budget routes (mostly Allegiant, though they primarily serve other NY airports) use Orlando Sanford (SFB). SFB is way further north. If you land there thinking you’re "in" Orlando, you’re looking at a 60-minute Uber ride that might cost more than your flight did. Stick to MCO if you’re doing the theme park thing. It’s just easier.
💡 You might also like: TSA PreCheck Look Up Number: What Most People Get Wrong
The Money Talk: Parking and Timing
Parking at ISP is roughly $18-$20 a day for the economy lots. Compare that to the $35-$60 you’ll find at the "major" hubs. It adds up.
Pro tip: The "sweet spot" for booking is usually about 4-6 weeks out. Don't wait until the last minute, especially during spring break or the holidays. Long Islanders love Florida, and these small planes fill up fast. If the flight is 90% full, the price jumps from $150 to $450 overnight.
What Happens if Things Go Wrong?
This is the one "gotcha" about Islip. Because it’s a smaller airport, there are fewer backup flights. If a storm hits and your 8:00 AM Southwest flight is canceled, they might not have another one until the next day.
📖 Related: Historic Sears Building LA: What Really Happened to This Boyle Heights Icon
At JFK, they might have five more flights that afternoon. It’s a trade-off. You’re trading the massive convenience of a small airport for the slightly higher risk of a delay with fewer recovery options. Most of the time? It’s totally worth the risk.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Flight
- Check the Low Fare Calendar: Southwest and Frontier both have "monthly view" calendars. If you can shift your trip from a Friday to a Wednesday, you’ll likely save $100 per person.
- Download the Airline App: Since ISP is small, gate changes happen fast. The app will ping you before the overhead announcement does.
- Measure Your Bags: If you’re flying Frontier or Breeze, they are strict. Don't be the person arguing at the gate because your "personal item" is actually a giant duffel bag.
- Pre-pay for Parking: While not always required at ISP, checking their website for any "daily max" updates can save you a headache at the exit gate.
- Arrive 90 Minutes Early: You don't need three hours like at JFK. Ninety minutes gives you plenty of time to grab a coffee, hit the restroom, and still be first in line to board.
Flying out of Islip is sort of like taking a private jet compared to the chaos of the city. You skip the traffic, you skip the lines, and you start your Florida vacation before you even leave the island. If you haven't checked the ISP schedules lately, you're probably paying too much—and working way too hard—to get to the Sunshine State.