You’ve probably driven past it a hundred times on the Long Island Expressway without even blinking. Exit 57 or 58. It’s that blur of office buildings and hotels between Hauppauge and Central Islip. Honestly, most people think Islandia, New York is just a "pass-through" town. A place where you stop for gas or maybe hit the casino.
But here’s the thing. Islandia is weird. In a good way.
It is one of the youngest villages in Suffolk County, officially incorporating in 1985. Back then, it was basically a move to stop other towns from gobbling up their land and tax revenue. Fast forward to 2026, and this tiny 2.2-square-mile patch of land has pulled off something most New Yorkers think is a fairytale: Zero village property taxes. Yeah, you read 그 right. While the rest of Long Island is drowning in some of the highest property taxes in the United States, the residents of Islandia haven't paid a dime in village-level taxes for years. It’s a bizarre economic anomaly fueled by a mix of corporate headquarters and a very controversial casino.
The Casino That Saved (and Split) the Town
If you want to understand Islandia New York, you have to talk about Jake’s 58. It’s the elephant in the room. Or rather, the flashing neon sign on the North Service Road.
When Delaware North first proposed putting video lottery terminals (VLTs) into what was then a Marriott hotel, the local pushback was intense. People were terrified. They thought it would bring crime, traffic, and ruin the "suburban-rural mix" the village is known for. It was a massive local drama that lasted years.
📖 Related: What Does a Stoner Mean? Why the Answer Is Changing in 2026
But then the checks started coming in.
The village worked out a Taxpayer Relief Agreement. Basically, the casino pays millions to the village every year. Because of that influx of cash, Mayor Allan Dorman was able to slash village taxes by 50% in 2017, and eventually, just get rid of them for residents entirely. In 2026, the village even covers garbage pickup for free. For a typical homeowner, that’s about $1,750 back in their pocket every year.
Does everyone love it? No. Some old-timers still miss the quiet days before the "adults-only" hotel became a gambling hub. But it's hard to argue with a tax bill that says $0.00.
It’s Not All Slot Machines and Traffic
Despite the "casino town" reputation it’s picked up lately, Islandia is surprisingly leafy. If you head north of the LIE, it feels like a different world.
👉 See also: Am I Gay Buzzfeed Quizzes and the Quest for Identity Online
Take Lakeland County Park. It’s one of the best-kept secrets in the Town of Islip. Most people don’t realize that portions of the Connetquot River actually run through the village. The park has these long, winding wooden boardwalks that are 100% accessible. It’s a prime spot for bird watching or just getting away from the hum of the expressway.
Then there’s Honeysuckle Pond. It sounds like something out of a children’s book, but it’s a real, serene spot for fishing or just sitting on a bench while your brain resets.
Life in the "South Hauppauge" Shadow
For a long time, Islandia didn't even have a name. People just called it South Hauppauge. When they incorporated in '85, it was a scrappy move to keep control over their own zoning.
That independent streak is still there. The village is tiny—only about 3,500 people. It’s the kind of place where you actually know your neighbors because there’s only one real neighborhood. Most of the homes were built between 1960 and 1980, so you get those solid, "good bones" Ranches and Colonials.
✨ Don't miss: Easy recipes dinner for two: Why you are probably overcomplicating date night
- Diversity: It’s one of the most diverse suburbs in New York.
- Income: The median household income is way above the national average, hovering around $112,000.
- Work: It’s a mix. You’ve got professionals commuting into the city (it’s about an hour drive) and a lot of people working in the nearby Hauppauge Industrial Park.
What Most People Get Wrong About Islandia
The biggest misconception is that Islandia is "dangerous" because of the casino. Data doesn't really back that up. Most of the "crime" reported is related to minor incidents within the casino/hotel itself, not the residential streets. The village has its own security patrols and a very tight relationship with the Suffolk County Police 4th Precinct.
Another thing? People think it’s just a playground for seniors. While there are some great 55+ communities like The Polo Club, the 25-to-44 demographic is actually the largest chunk of the population. Young professionals are moving here specifically because of the tax breaks and the fact that the schools—mostly Central Islip, but small slivers of Hauppauge and Connetquot—are accessible.
Practical Insights for 2026
If you’re thinking about visiting or even moving to Islandia, here’s the reality on the ground right now:
- The Casino is the Hub: If you’re staying at Jake’s 58, remember it’s strictly 18+ to enter and 21+ to check into the hotel. No kids allowed on the property.
- Strategic Staying: If you’re doing a Long Island trip, Islandia is the "goldilocks" zone. You’re 15 minutes from MacArthur Airport, 30 minutes from the Hamptons (if traffic behaves), and 45 minutes from the city.
- Real Estate is Tight: Because of the zero-tax situation, people don't leave. When a house hits the market on Split Cedar Drive or Silverleaf Lane, it goes fast.
- Dining Low-Key: Don't just eat at the casino. There are some killer local spots and coffee shops in the shopping centers along Veterans Memorial Highway that the locals swear by.
Islandia is a case study in how a tiny village can use corporate commercialism to fund a high-quality residential life. It’s not the sleepy farming community it was in 1950, but it’s arguably one of the most financially savvy places to live in the United States.
Next Steps for You:
If you're planning a trip, check the current event calendar at Village Hall—they often host defensive driving courses or "Toys for Tots" drives that are open to the public. If you're a bird watcher, hit Lakeland County Park at sunrise; the boardwalks are empty and the wildlife is active. For those looking at real estate, verify the school district boundaries for specific addresses, as Islandia is split between three different districts, which can significantly impact your resale value.