August 2017 was a fever dream for NBA fans. One minute, we’re all debating if the Golden State Warriors are actually beatable, and the next, a notification pops up that changes the Eastern Conference forever. Kyrie Irving wanted out of Cleveland. He was tired of playing in the shadow of the King. And the return? It was a bombshell: Isaiah Thomas to the Cavs.
On paper, it looked like a heist. Cleveland wasn't just getting an All-Star; they were getting a guy who had just finished one of the most statistically insane seasons for a "small" player in history. IT was coming off a year where he averaged nearly 29 points a game and finished top-five in MVP voting. He was the "King in the Fourth."
But as we now know, the reality was much messier. The trade wasn't just a swap of point guards; it was the beginning of a downward spiral for one of the league's most beloved underdogs.
The Trade That Shook the League
When the news broke, it felt like the Boston Celtics had done the unthinkable. Danny Ainge traded the heart and soul of the city. Isaiah Thomas had played through the tragic death of his sister and a literal broken hip to lead Boston to the Eastern Conference Finals. Then, he got the call.
The deal was massive. Cleveland sent Kyrie Irving to Boston. In return, they got:
- Isaiah Thomas
- Jae Crowder
- Ante Zizic
- Brooklyn’s 2018 unprotected first-round pick (which eventually became Collin Sexton)
At first, Cavs fans were ecstatic. You’ve got LeBron James, and now you’re pairing him with a guy who scores at will? It seemed like the perfect way to stay competitive while also hedging for the future with that Brooklyn pick. Honestly, the pick was probably the "real" prize for Cleveland's front office, especially with the looming fear that LeBron might bolt for Los Angeles in free agency.
💡 You might also like: Current Score of the Steelers Game: Why the 30-6 Texans Blowout Changed Everything
The Hip Injury Nobody Wanted to Talk About
Here is where things got "kinda" dark. The trade almost didn't happen. When Isaiah showed up for his physical in Cleveland, the doctors saw something they didn't like. That hip injury from the playoffs? It was way worse than the public realized.
The Cavs threatened to veto the entire thing. There were days of posturing, leaks, and drama. Eventually, the Celtics threw in a 2020 second-round pick just to get the deal across the finish line. But the damage was done. The "damaged goods" label was stuck to Isaiah before he even put on a Wine and Gold jersey.
Why the Fit Never Worked
It took months for Isaiah to actually get on the court. He didn't make his debut until January 2018 against Portland. He scored 17 points in 19 minutes, and for one night, it felt like the magic was back.
It wasn't.
The chemistry was non-existent. You have to remember, that 2017-18 Cavs team was a rotating door of personalities. Dwyane Wade was there. Derrick Rose was there. Jae Crowder was struggling. And right in the middle of it was a 5-foot-9 guard trying to find his rhythm while his hip was essentially screaming at him.
📖 Related: Last Match Man City: Why Newcastle Couldn't Stop the Semenyo Surge
- Defensive Nightmares: The Cavs were already a bad defensive team. Adding IT, who was a known liability on that end even when healthy, made them a sieve.
- Ball Dominance: Isaiah needs the ball to be effective. LeBron needs the ball. In Boston, the offense was built for IT. In Cleveland, he was just another piece of the puzzle, and a clunky one at that.
- Locker Room Tension: There were reports of "shouting matches" and finger-pointing. Isaiah was vocal, maybe too vocal for a guy who hadn't "earned it" in that locker room yet.
Basically, the team was 7-8 in the 15 games Isaiah played. That’s not exactly championship DNA.
The Panic Move: The 2018 Trade Deadline
Cleveland realized pretty quickly that the Isaiah Thomas to the Cavs experiment was a disaster. On February 8, 2018, Koby Altman pulled the trigger on a total roster overhaul. In a matter of hours, Isaiah Thomas, Channing Frye, and a first-round pick were shipped off to the Lakers for Jordan Clarkson and Larry Nance Jr.
IT was gone after just 15 games.
He went from being the face of the Celtics to a journeyman in less than six months. It’s one of the most brutal "business of basketball" stories you’ll ever find. He never got that "Brink’s truck" contract he famously talked about, and his career became a series of 10-day contracts and "what-if" scenarios.
Lessons from the IT Era in Cleveland
Looking back, the trade was a massive gamble that failed for everyone except the Celtics. Boston got Kyrie (for a while), and Cleveland got a draft pick that helped them start their post-LeBron rebuild. But for Isaiah, it was the end of his superstar arc.
👉 See also: Cowboys Score: Why Dallas Just Can't Finish the Job When it Matters
If you’re looking for the "why" behind the failure, it comes down to three things:
- Medical Transparency: The gap between what Boston knew and what Cleveland found was the first crack in the foundation.
- Timeline Mismatch: Cleveland needed a "win-now" replacement for Kyrie. Isaiah needed a "rehab-now" environment.
- The LeBron Factor: Playing with LeBron is a spotlight that magnifies every flaw. For a player relying on explosive speed while injured, that spotlight was blinding.
What You Can Take Away
For sports fans and analysts, the Isaiah Thomas trade is a case study in asset management versus human element. Teams often view players as contracts and stats, but the physical and mental toll of a trade can ruin a career.
If you're following the NBA today, watch how teams handle "injured stars" in trades. The "IT rule" basically governs how front offices double-check medicals now. No one wants to repeat the 2017 Cleveland disaster.
To understand the long-term impact, look at how the Cavs eventually rebuilt using the pieces from that era. While the Isaiah experiment failed, the Brooklyn pick they held onto became the first brick in the wall of their current competitive roster.
The next time a "blockbuster" trade is announced, don't just look at the points per game. Look at the medical reports and the locker room fit. Those are the things that actually determine if a trade is a win or a total bust.
Actionable Insight: If you're tracking player trades or team rebuilds, always prioritize looking at "Net Rating" changes post-trade rather than just raw scoring numbers. As we saw with IT, a high-scoring player can still result in a negative team impact if the defensive fit isn't there. For the most accurate historical stats on this specific era, Basketball-Reference remains the gold standard for seeing how that 2018 Cavs roster actually performed during those 15 games.