Honestly, the Marvel Cinematic Universe hasn't always been great at looking in the mirror. But when Carl Lumbly showed up in a quiet Baltimore house during The Falcon and the Winter Soldier, everything shifted. Now, with Isaiah Bradley in Captain America: Brave New World, that weight finally lands. This isn't just a cameo. It is a reckoning.
If you’re expecting a simple "superhero vs. villain" plot, you’re looking at the wrong movie. Isaiah represents the "truth" that the title of the original 2003 comic miniseries (Truth: Red, White & Black) so pointedly promised. He is the first Black Captain America. A man the history books tried to erase. And in this new film, he’s at the very center of a global conspiracy that Sam Wilson has to untangle.
The Tragedy of the Forgotten Super Soldier
Let’s back up for a second. In the MCU timeline, Isaiah was a Korean War veteran. While Steve Rogers was frozen in ice being a legend, the U.S. government was trying to cook up the serum again. They used Black soldiers as lab rats. Isaiah was the only one who didn't just survive—he thrived.
He actually took down the Winter Soldier back in 1951. Think about that. He did the job and his "reward" was thirty years in a cell being poked and prodded. The government stole his life. They stole his legacy. When Sam Wilson finally tracks him down, Isaiah is a man who knows exactly how the world treats heroes who don't fit the "perfect" image.
Why he matters in Brave New World
In the new film, the stakes get messy. Isaiah is no longer just sitting on a porch. He’s active. But it’s not the kind of "heroic return" you might expect. Early on, we see a brainwashed Isaiah Bradley attempt to assassinate President Thaddeus "Thunderbolt" Ross (played by Harrison Ford).
It’s heartbreaking.
🔗 Read more: Jurassic World Dominion: How Long It Is and Why the Extended Cut Matters
Basically, Samuel Sterns—the Leader—is pulling the strings. He uses mind control to turn a man who was already a victim of the state into a weapon against it. This isn't just a plot device. It’s a thematic hammer. It forces Sam Wilson to decide what kind of Captain America he wants to be. Does he follow orders, or does he fight for the man the system wants to throw away?
Breaking Down the Comic vs. Movie Differences
If you're a comic book nerd, you know the MCU changed some things. In the books, Isaiah fought in World War II, not Korea. The comics also leaned way harder into the real-life parallels of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study. It was brutal.
- Comics: Isaiah steals Steve’s suit for a suicide mission in Germany. He gets court-martialed for "theft."
- MCU: He’s a Korean War hero who gets jailed to hide the fact that the serum worked on a Black man.
- The Outcome: Both versions end up as "urban legends" within the Black community.
Carl Lumbly plays this with such a weary, sharp edge. He’s not a "grumpy old man." He’s a survivor of systemic trauma. In Brave New World, we see Sam training with Isaiah. He’s a mentor now. But that mentorship is tested when the assassination attempt happens. Sam doesn't just see a criminal; he sees a friend who is being exploited all over again.
Is Eli Bradley (Patriot) in the Movie?
This is the question everyone is asking. We saw Eli in the TV show. Most fans assumed he’d suit up as Patriot in this movie.
But here’s the reality: Marvel producer Nate Moore confirmed that while Eli was in early drafts, he was cut to focus on the relationship between Sam and Isaiah. It sucks for Young Avengers fans. However, it makes sense for the story. The movie needs to feel like a grounded political thriller. Adding a teenage superhero with a star-spangled shield might have diluted the tension between the two generations of men who have actually carried the weight of the name.
The Leader’s Master Plan
Samuel Sterns is the real "villain," but the government’s past is the accomplice. By framing Isaiah, Sterns creates a PR nightmare for Sam.
✨ Don't miss: What's Good on Netflix Now: Why Your Algorithm is Hiding the Best Stuff
If Sam defends a "terrorist," he loses the public.
If he abandons Isaiah, he loses his soul.
It’s a classic paranoid thriller setup. The movie spends a lot of time in the gray areas. You’ve got Ruth Bat-Seraph (Sabra) working for Ross, and Joaquin Torres taking over the Falcon mantle. It’s a crowded house, but Isaiah is the emotional anchor. Without him, Sam is just a guy with a shield. With him, Sam is a man fighting for the truth of what America actually is.
What You Should Do Next
If you want to fully appreciate the layers of Isaiah Bradley in Captain America: Brave New World, you should go back and watch the second and fifth episodes of The Falcon and the Winter Soldier. Specifically, pay attention to the scene where Isaiah shows Sam his scars. It explains every choice he makes in the new film.
Also, track down a copy of Truth: Red, White & Black by Robert Morales and Kyle Baker. It’s one of the most important stories Marvel has ever published. It gives you the "why" behind the character’s anger. Understanding that history makes the ending of Brave New World—where Sam finally works to exonerate Isaiah—feel like a victory that’s been eighty years in the making.
👉 See also: The Boy Is Mine Tour Dates 2025: What Most People Get Wrong
Go see the movie on the biggest screen possible. The action is great, but the conversations between Sam and Isaiah are the parts that will actually stay with you.